AdventAI

THE LIBERAL CONGRESS OF RELIGION.

By F. D. Starr

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 49., December 7, 1897

F. D. STARR.

(Nashville, Tenn.)

As ALREADY noted in the REVIEW, this congress met in its fourth annual session at Nashville, Tenn., Oct. 19–24, 1897. The day sessions were held on the exposition grounds, and the night sessions in the Jewish temple in the city. The writer took occasion to be present at two of the night meetings. Without taking a morbidly critical view of the matter, I would venture to express a few thoughts that were impressed on my mind regarding the occasion.

The first address to which I listened was from Prof. Nathaniel Schmidt, of Cornell University, on “Biblical Criticism and Theological Belief.” It was considered by the assembly as a very scholarly production, and very highly commended.

The speaker defined “higher criticism” to be a thorough examination of the historical evidences concerning the Scriptures, while “lower criticism” had only to do with textual accuracies or inaccuracies. As the result of his higher criticism, this scholar claimed to have found that many portions of the Bible were not written by the commonly supposed authors. There were portions, he claimed, of the book of Isaiah that were not written by that prophet; Solomon never wrote the “Song” to which his name is attached; and Paul did not write the book of Hebrews, while it was quite uncertain whether he wrote all the minor epistles credited to him, etc. It was so easy for the transcriber of the Scriptures to add something, as a note or comment, in the copy he was making (which thing, it was intimated, was anciently often done), and that note come to be considered afterward as part of the original text. And finally, he concluded, there was much in the Book that could not be considered as inspired.

The tendency of this address by this “eminent scholar” seemed to be to lessen the confidence of the listener in the perfect veracity and authenticity of the Bible as a whole, seeing some portions of it had been tampered with so much. It was thought to be blind bigotry or superstition that would lead one to hold to the genuineness of the entire Bible against the plain “developments of science.” The defender of Buddhism stated that that religion is much older than Christianity, and that both Jews and Christians should be very thankful that such a system of religion exists, as many portions of the Bible were taken from the sacred writings of the Buddhist religion. This he essayed to prove by comparing passages of the Scriptures with selections from the teachings of Buddhism.

The Jewish rabbi who spoke in defense of Judaism was much rejoiced that the time had come when representatives of the various religions could come together in such a friendly manner. His eloquent address was warmly applauded by the mixed multitude of Christians, Jews, and Gentiles. “Progress” was the order of the day. Instead of the idea that the world had existed but five or six thousand years, this teacher in Israel stated that it had taken several million years to bring the human race up to the exalted plane it now occupies.

An eminent Methodist clergyman from Toledo, Ohio, felt that such a gathering betokened something very significant about to take place, the real nature and magnitude of which we can hardly yet conceive. This sentiment seemed to be shared by many.

The Jewish rabbi was followed by a leading minister of the gospel, who said: “Were I a Parsee, I would be proud of my religion; I would do all I could to advance the cause of the Parsee religion; I would not want to be anything but a Parsee. Were I a Jew, I would be proud of my religion; I would do all I could for the cause of Judaism; I would not want to be anything but a Jew. But I am a Christian, and I am proud of my religion; I will do all I can for Christianity; I do not want to be anything but a Christian.” He then spoke earnestly in praise of Jesus, repeating, in nearly every sentence, that name to Christians so dear, to Jews so offensive, to Gentiles foolishness. He described him as the exact representative of the Universal Father, though not the only representative, but the one designed for, and known by, Christians. The impression was left that other systems of religion also present ways of salvation.

Into this situation is Christianity forced to come in order to affiliate, on common terms, with other systems of religion. Is it true that there is “none other name under heaven given among men whereby we must be saved”? or may we climb up some other way?

But the thought that most forcibly impressed my mind was the query, Where is the “higher criticism” for these other religions and their sacred writings? The representative of Mohammedanism, wearing his yellow turban in the Jewish temple, surrounded by Christians, regaling himself with the “higher criticism” of evangelical divines,—what higher criticism has he to offer on the Koran? What higher (or lower) criticism has the Buddhist priest to present on the reputed sacred writings of Buddha? Where is the advocate of some heathen religion that has a higher criticism to suggest, by which he shows to the world the weak points and the unauthenticity of the sacred volumes of his religion?

“Pass over the isles of Chittim, and see; and send unto Kedar, and consider diligently, and see if there be such a thing. Hath a nation changed their gods, which are yet no gods? but my people have changed their glory for that which doth not profit.” What a spectacle! Has a heathen, or a Mohammedan, or the advocate of any other false system of belief, any criticism to offer in the face of the world upon his religious code? This seems to be left for those who have the living oracles committed to them. Must the Word again be wounded in the house of its friends and in the presence of enemies? God’s remnant people have the honor, though perhaps alone, of standing loyal to that Word.