THE 144,000 AGAIN

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 7, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 36.

Read the full edition

THE 144,000 AGAIN.

We like to see any position which is taken upon any important Bible subject, examined with the greatest earnestness and care, and tested by the most rigid criticism. For none of us care to commit ourselves to any position which is not made invulnerable by a breastwork of impenetrable steel. With pleasure, therefore, we welcome from a correspondent some criticisms touching the article on the one hundred and forty-four thousand, which appeared in the Review of August 10.
The views set forth in the article referred to, do not seem clear to the mind of our correspondent, and therefore we will let him state his difficulties (which may be difficulties in other minds as well), and then try to compare them candidly with the evidence in the case. The reader will remember the positions taken, the principal of which were, that those who die in the third angel’s message will all be included among the 144,000; that these are those who “die in the Lord” from the time the message commences (Rev. 14: 13), upon whom a special blessing is pronounced; that they are raised in a special resurrection at the voice of God, at the beginning of the seventh plague (Rev. 16: 17; 1: 7; Dan. 12: 1, 2); that they are raised to the plane of mortality, the same condition of the living righteous, pass with them through the period of the seventh plague, and so, with them, come out of great tribulation (Rev. 7: 14), are with them made immortal at the appearing of Christ, and so are “redeemed from the earth,” and “redeemed from among men” (Rev. 14: 3, 4), and become the constant associates of Christ in the heavenly kingdom (Rev. 7: 14); and that these blessed experiences will be participated in by such pioneers in this work as Elders White, Andrews, Bates, etc.
The trouble of our correspondent seems to be to harmonize these views with statements found in “Great Controversy,” to which we now call attention. He says:—
At the bottom of page 648 (“Great Controversy”) we have a description of the 144,000. This company have gotten the victory over the beast, over his image, and over his mark. This company, then, will live to see the image to the beast made, in all its power, as brought to view in Revelation 13. This cannot include such persons as Elders White, Andrews, Bates, etc., unless it is maintained that they gain this victory after they come up in the special resurrection; but probation is then closed, and such victories are not then to be won or lost.
In considering this, let us bear in mind, and endeavor to comprehend the force of, the words spoken in reference to those who die in the message, in Rev. 14: 13: “Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord from henceforth: Yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labors; and their works do follow them.” Do not these words mean simply this: that these persons are permitted, by a calm repose in the grave, to escape the toils, struggles, pains, and sacrifices involved in the last conflict of the church on earth, and yet their works do follow them; that is, they are accounted, when they are raised from the dead, as having accomplished all the works they would have done, had they lived till that time, and had they never died? All that they would have done, had they lived, is placed to their account.
If this principle is correct (and what else can the words quoted mean?), we see how those who die before the image is formed, can be said, in the end, to have gained the victory over it: it is because they would have gained that victory had they lived, and so are accounted to have gained it. Thus “their works do follow them,” while they are “blessed” in escaping the perils of the conflict. On this ground the pioneers of this message are not shut out.
Again we quote: “This company [the 144,000] ‘sing a new song,’ the song of their experience; and because those who die before the message closes do not have that experience, it follows that they cannot join in that song. ‘Great Controversy,’ page 649, says: ‘None but the 144,000 can learn that song, for it is the song of their experience,—an experience such as no other company have ever had.’”
Let us apply the same principle here that is stated above. If the words, “Their works do follow them,” mean, as we suppose, that these raised ones are regarded and treated in all respects as if they had lived and been faithful through the entire message, does it not follow that all the reward the others reap, and all the emotions they feel, are equally shared in by these also? They hear the “covenant of peace” (page 637); they have been excused from much of the toil and tribulation of the way, but have the same reward; they escape the final conflict with the beast and his image, and yet are counted as victors over them; in some particulars of the experience of the remnant they do not share, yet they had embraced the message, had passed through some of its experiences, especially that important part of receiving into their hearts its spirit, and they had, in anticipation, looked through its future conflicts even to the end; and so, when they are raised, may they not enter at once into full sympathy with their brethren, understand their position as no others can, and when the last scenes are passed through, and immortality is given, be able to join with them in the same song of experience and triumph?—So it seems to us.
But our correspondent refers to still another point, which seems, perhaps, to involve a greater difficulty than the others. He says:—
Again, on page 649, speaking of this company [the 144,000] we read: “They have passed through the time of trouble such as never was since there was a nation; they have endured the anguish of the time of Jacob’s trouble; they have stood without an intercessor through the final outpouring of God’s judgments. . . . They have seen the earth wasted with famine and pestilence, the sun having power to scorch men with great heat, and they themselves have endured suffering, hunger, and thirst.” It seems evident to my mind that this company gain their experience, not by passing through the last plague only, but by passing through the entire seven. They see the sun scorch men with great heat and suffer under the time of the plague with heat and thirst. This is in the fourth plague, and the partial resurrection does not take place until the beginning of the seventh.
The principle stated above, in reply to previous queries, will apply largely here also; but there are other considerations which have a place here. Deceased believers in the message come up at the beginning of the seventh plague. Let us see, then, how much comes within the range of their observation and experience. The seventh plague, as noticed in the article of August 10, is the climax and aggregate of all the plagues together. In this plague the time of trouble reaches its greatest intensity, and they behold it; the desolation of the earth is most appalling, and this they also see; famine, pestilence, and sunstroke are still at work, with all their virulence; and all this they witness; and the final all-devastating plague of the great hail, peculiar to this plague, with the accompanying thunders, lightnings, and great earthquake, they pass through. Out of this scene, John beholds the whole company emerging; and may it not properly be said of them that they come together “out of great tribulation,” and are “redeemed from among men?”
But how is it that they themselves suffer under these things? On this point bear in mind that they are not yet made immortal. That crowning blessing does not come till Christ appears. Page 645. Being, then, in their mortal state, their physical systems, though they are clothed with the glory and power of God (pages 637, 645), are still subject to the impressions of evil conditions around them, and so they feel the effects of the scorching heat, hunger, and thirst. But they are soon made immortal, triumphantly enter the kingdom of God, and suffer no more. Rev. 7: 16.
In the light of these facts, from this point of view, it does not appear to us that there is any insuperable objection to the hypothesis set forth in this and the previous article.
U. S.