AdventAI

In the Question Chair.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 42., October 19, 1897

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here may be answered by mail.]

796.—EXCHANGING STOCK FOR HAY.

If I sell part of my stock to purchase hay to feed the remainder, should I tithe the stock sold?

C. R. C.

Ans.— A reply was given to this question, as 795, in the REVIEW of September 28; but seeing, upon further thought, that a point was overlooked, we notice it again. It was there stated that the proceeds of the stock sold, being simply designed to purchase feed for the remaining stock, would not come under the law of the tithe; but there is another principle which is to be taken into account; and that is that all the increase of property in our hands is to be tithed; and it is to be supposed that that part of the stock sold had increased some in value while in the farmer’s possession before the sale; and that increase should be tithed. Take the following as an illustration: A farmer finds it necessary to purchase $50 worth of hay; and to raise the money, he sells ten sheep at $5 each. But suppose that he gets for the sheep $2.50 a head, over and above the original cost of the sheep, and the cost of feeding while he has them. Here would be an increase of $25, a tithe of which belongs to the Lord. But it may be said that the tithe of this will come in when the remainder of thep. 668 stock is sold to which the feed was appropriated. But this would not alter the fact that there was an increase of $25 on the sheep first sold, which it would be impossible to trace and keep separate in subsequent transactions. Would not the true way, therefore, be to take the increase when it can be accurately estimated, and render to the Lord an honest tithe thereof, as fast as it becomes due? U. S.