AdventAI

MURDEROUS FOOTBALL.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 47., November 23, 1897

THERE are two of the leading journals of the country that have taken a positive stand against murderous football. These are the New York World and the Washington Star. The Star calls it “The Game of Manslaughter,” and says:—

The football season is only fairly begun, and yet at least three deaths have already occurred as the direct results of this brutally played game. It is to be expected that before the close of the season, other young men will have sacrificed their lives on the gridiron, in a foolish following of a “sport” that is based upon principles of pugilism rather than of athletics. Meanwhile arms are being broken daily, legs are wrenched, faces are disfigured, scalps are torn, and a thousand and one other accidents of a more or less distressing nature are occurring in the mad rushes of eleven against eleven. The latest death was typical of most others that are to be charged against the game. The victim had the ball, was tackled and thrown, and was instantly buried beneath a mound of human forms. His brain suffered a fatal concussion, and he died within a few hours, practically without having regained consciousness.

A season or two ago, when the death-roll of the game was unusually long, promises were made by some of those prominent in the management of the great contests of the year, that steps would be taken to render the game less brutal and dangerous. More “open” play was to be encouraged, and rules were to be adopted to prevent the mass plays that have crushed out so many lives. The spirit of reform seemed to have reached those responsible for the character of the prevailing rules; but it was apparent, when the succeeding season opened, that the matter had gone beyond the reach of rules, and that as long as football was played on the existing theories, it would remain a deadly sport, rules or no rules. The moving impulse of the game is to crush the opposition by sheer force and weight. The mass play, the piling up of body on body following a tackle and fall, is still the predominating feature of the game. Kicking is only an incident. It is no longer “football,” but battle.

The World sums up the deadly results so far the present season,—though another victim has died since the World’s editorial was printed, making nine dead instead of eight,—and under the heading, “Worse Than Bull-Fighting,” says:—

Eight dead, two hundred and eighty-six maimed, seventeen of them injured for life—this is the season’s record thus far of the noble “gentlemen’s game” of football, as carefully compiled by the World.

As Harry Beecher, the World’s famous football expert, points out, a few slight changes in the rules would end this disgrace upon American colleges. Yet the college athletic authorities, backed up by the professors and the presidents, refuse to make those changes.

The World proves that bull-fighting is a harmless sport compared with football as at present played. It would seem impossible for the colleges to resist the public sentiment which the World’s statistics will certainly arouse. But it ought not to be necessary to arouse public sentiment. Surely at a college, if anywhere, they ought to be able to distinguish between a manly contest of strength and skill and a brutal and degrading squabble, in which eleven young men of presumed intelligence try to maim and kill eleven other young men, who are being elaborately prepared for positions of honor and usefulness in life.

Shame on these colleges for setting an example which prize-fighters have a right to deplore!