UNEQUAL TAXATION

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 8, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 6.

Read the full edition

UNEQUAL TAXATION.

The Independent.
The question of equal taxation will become a burning question in this country when people are made to see how monstrous are the inequalities of our present system or systems. State Comptroller Roberts, of New York, recently showed how little personal property the assessors find. Selecting at random one hundred and seven estates passing to heirs, from lists in his office, he states that of these, thirty-four, with personal property ranging in value from $55,000 to $3,300,000, paid no tax at all before the death of the owners. The assessment the year before death on all the estates amounted to less than two per cent. of the actual valuation. These men, the comptroller says, were not sinners above their fellows; the cases are simply representative cases.
No doubt similar inequalities exist elsewhere. They certainly do in Chicago; for the Taxpayers' Defense League, organized only last summer, has brought them to light. An estate which passed $2,000,000 of personal property through the probate court, had paid tax on only $750; and the heir is assessed for $500. One large grocery firm was assessed for $50,000; another, no larger, for $750,000, afterward reduced to $95,000. A banker pays on a one-per-cent. valuation, a poor woman on a twenty-three-per-cent. valuation, while a large packing-house escapes altogether.
These are a few of the many instances given by Edward W. Bemis in the Bibliotheca Sacra, which also prints an open letter to the Pullman Car Company, from the president of the Taxpayers' Defense League, Z. Swift Holbrook, contending that the property of that company, if taxed as other property in Illinois is assessed, namely, at one tenth of its value, would pay $200,000 more annually to the city.