STATE MUST NOT INTERFERE

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 15, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 7.

Read the full edition

STATE MUST NOT INTERFERE.

Is THE United Presbyterian going out of the “religious amendment” business? If not, how shall we account for an article, in its issue of January 27, protesting against a union of religion and the state, which is the poorly disguised church-and-state entering wedge of the so-called “National Reformers”? The article is by J. G. Carson, D. D., and a few clippings from it will show the trend of its arguments and the clearness of its views on this subject.
After stating some of the disabilities which existed in early colonial times, from the relics of church and state brought over from the Old World, the writer sets forth the new and better ground on which this nation was established. As late as 1780 the constitution of Massachusetts required every member of its legislature, on taking his seat, to subscribe to a declaration that he believed in the Christian religion. Against this regulation, Joseph Hawley, of the Congregational church of Northampton, sternly protested, as “against common right, and the natural franchises of every member of the commonwealth.”
“In this way,” remarks Bancroft, the historian, “from the heart of rigid Calvinism a protest was heard against any right in the temporal power to demand or receive a profession of faith in the Christian religion. The temporal power might punish the evil deed, but not punish, or even search after, the thought of the mind.”
So also Virginia, in 1786, placed among its statutes this declaration: “Opinion in matters of religion shall in nowise diminish, enlarge, or affect civil capacities. The rights here asserted are of the natural rights of mankind.”
Thus, in the words of Bancroft, “The new nation, when it came to establish a government for the United States, refused to treat faith as a matter to be regulated by a corporate body, or having a headship in a monarch or state. It left the management of temporal things to the temporal power, but withheld from the federal government the power to invade the home of reason, the citadel of conscience, the sanctuary of the soul; and this not from indifference, but that the infinite spirit of eternal truth might move in its freedom and purity and power.”
When it was objected, in a convention in New Hampshire, that there was no provision that men in power should have any religion,—that an infidel or a papist was as eligible as Christians,—Payson, a minister of Chelsea, replied that,—
Human tribunals for the consciences of men are impious encroachments upon the prerogatives of God. A religious test as a qualification for office would have been a great blemish.
Isaac Backus, Baptist minister of Middleborough, declared:—
In reason and the Holy Scriptures, religion is ever a matter between God and individuals; the imposing of religious tests hath been the greatest engine of tyranny in the world.
In the New Hampshire convention, Woodbury Langdon, formerly president of Harvard College, demonstrated that,—
Religion is a question between God and man, in which no civil authority may interfere.
“If this,” says Mr. Carson, “be the true position, then it follows,”—
  1. That the insertion of the proposed Christian amendment into our Constitution, even if it were possible, is not desirable. It is not desirable, because the experience of more than a hundred years has gone to prove that true religion flourishes best when it is most free from all connection with the state or civil government.
  2. The civil magistrate has no rightful power to prescribe to the people how they are to worship God.
  3. The civil magistrate has no rightful power to enforce the observance of the Sabbath, considered as a moral or religious duty.
That Christ is the civil King of this nation, as he was of the Jewish nation, will hardly be claimed; else this would be a theocracy as theirs was, and the judicial law of the Jewish commonwealth would be still in force.
On the broad ground, therefore, that the civil government has not the right, even if it had the power, to require such a profession of faith from any of its citizens, or in other words, to prescribe their religion, we conclude that the proposed religious amendment of the Constitution is not admissible.
The only weak point in Mr. Carson’s position is the admission that the government has a right to enforce upon all a day of rest, the day to be decided by the preferences of the majority of the people. But the fact that it is impossible to divorce the idea of a day of rest from moral and religious duties, nullifies this argument.
And what is a singular coincidence is that this protest comes from Xenia, Ohio, the very place where the “national reform” iniquity had its birth. U. S.