A CORRESPONDENT asks, “Is a horse trader fit for the elder of a church?” Like a good many other questions, this one does not admit of a direct answer. It is the principle rather than the business itself that must decide the question. It frequently happens that a man may, to his own advantage and to that of others, buy or sell a horse, rendering or receiving therefor a just equivalent. There are also many cases in which two persons can exchange horses to mutual advantage; so that the act of trading horses is not sin of itself. Or a person might properly engage in purchasing horses and shipping them to another part of the country where a better price prevailed.
But such cases are not the ones referred to by our correspondent. He probably has in mind a person who devotes considerable of his time to trading and trafficking in horses among his neighbors, seeking in each trade to benefit himself, even though it be at the loss of the other party. Of such a man we could imagine that our Saviour would say, How hardly shall a horse-jockey enter into the kingdom of heaven! The eighth commandment says, “Thou shalt not steal;” and to deprive another individual of his rights or of his property is stealing. To take from a person that which is of value to him, without returning an equivalent, is a violation of the eighth commandment, no matter whether it is done by picking his pocket, robbing his dwelling, or trading horses. In fact, most people would prefer to have their pockets picked, to being cheated in a trade. And the man who cheats in a trade is no better than a man who picks pockets.
But is it necessary to conclude that all who make a business of trading horses cheat in trade? — Perhaps not. We would not set up a claim that horse-trading cannot be done honestly. But here is the question: when a man starts out with an old, good-for-nothing horse, and at the end of a period of time, by trading, has converted that horse into a valuable one, or perhaps into a span of valuable horses, or perhaps still has nothing but old horses, but has made a lot of money, where did his gain come from? — Undoubtedly it came from those with whom he traded, and for that gain he has not rendered any recompense. All around him are men who are smarting under the losses they have suffered at his hands. He has gained, in addition to his wealth, the reputation of a trickster. People look upon him with suspicion; and he is a thief. In the eyes of God he is no better than any other thief. He has filled his pockets with that which belongs to other men. He may laugh at his own cuteness, but it will be a very different thing when he meets it in the Judgment.
These principles apply to any other kind of trading as well as horse trading. And such people are evidently unfit to lead a church of Christ.
G. C. T.