PUNISHMENT IN DISCIPLINE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 25, 1898

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 4.

Read the full edition

PUNISHMENT IN DISCIPLINE.

FREDERICK GRIGGS.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
In a paper recently read before a gathering of mothers and teachers in this city, it was advocated that it is incompatible with the self-respect and self-control of the child ever to administer punishment, and that the only proper way to overcome the evil is to strengthen the good. If the sentiments expressed in this paper were never expressed elsewhere, it might not be wise to speak of them in this connection; but they are simply an expression of a popular and rapidly growing sentiment. The great child-study movement in this and other countries is leading those who have charge of children to see the necessity of removing every cause for disobedience from the environment of the child. Improper food and clothing, a lack of exercise, nervous exhaustion from rapid growth, etc., etc., are recognized as causes of disobedience. The evil of this movement is that the attention is turned wholly to these causes, and when they are removed, the child is supposed to develop symmetrically; for according to Rousseau and others, who have either forsaken the Bible or overlooked what it has to say concerning the nature and disposition of the child, there is no evil in his nature by inheritance, but what he has he has got from his environment. There is a cause for the disobedience of children, which is so marked as to be a sign of the last days; and it seems to me that this cause is not far to seek when we so often hear theories advanced which are plainly contrary to what the Lord has said concerning the nature and training of the child.
I would not be misunderstood; for I do firmly believe that the first consideration in the training of a child is to provide those conditions of life and development from which the evil is removed and the good left. But there is evil in the child which he has inherited as a result of the fallen nature of man; this needs correction, and punishment is, at times, a necessary means of correction.
“Punishment is pain inflicted upon the mind or body of an individual by the authority to which he is subject, with a view of reforming him or of deterring others from the commission of offenses, or both. Some have alleged that fear and shame, the two principles addressed by punishment, are among the lowest in our natures; and hence have endeavored to show that punishment is always inexpedient, if not, indeed, always wrong. To this I answer that both fear and shame are incorporated in our nature by God himself, and hence I infer that they are there for a wise purpose. I find, moreover, that God, in his word and in his providence, does appeal to both these principles; hence I infer that punishment in the abstract is not wrong, and after the highest motives have been addressed, not altogether inexpedient.”
Punishments may be said to consist of two classes: first, those which directly address the mind, such as reproof and deprivation of privileges; and second, those which affect the mind through the body, such as the imposition of a task or bodily chastisement.
It must be ever in the mind of the one who is punishing that the true purpose of punishment is to lead the child to control himself. This will do away with improper punishments, such as scolding, ridicule, nagging, sarcasm, pinching, pulling the ear, jerking, and other indignities to the mind and body so commonly employed by parents and teachers who, while attempting to control others, do not control themselves. The child learns far more by example than by precept; and the quiet, composed manner of self-controlled parents and teachers is that which, after all, gives to the child the self-control which they wish him to have.
Kind reproof is one of the most effectual means of punishment. The Lord deals with his children along the line of cause and effect. Even the little child can reason from cause to effect, and often far more readily than we would at first suppose. When the reproof is of a reasoning nature, and he is led to see, clearly and vividly, the causes and results of his course, he cannot but be affected. It is in this connection that the removal of privileges and the loss of liberties are effectual. Reflection will often enable the child to see the errors of his course more clearly; and confinement, with this result in view, is often a wholesome punishment. But it must be remarked that confinement in a dark room always defeats this purpose. Light is as necessary as is air to the effectual working of the mind during its waking hours.
It is not my purpose in what I am here saying to enter into a discussion of all the different modes of punishment, but simply to enunciate those principles which I believe should govern punishment in all its forms. I should not neglect, however, to speak of bodily chastisement; for, in certain circumstances, it is a necessity. As well as all other forms of punishment, it should be used only to enable the child to control himself. When other means of inducing the child to bring himself to do, or to refrain from doing, that which reason and better judgment clearly indicate should or should not be done, then corporal punishment should be administered. The Scripture is clear and decided upon this point, and this is the only safe guide in the whole subject of discipline and punishment.
The Lord, in dealing with his children, often permits physical disabilities to afflict them so that they will obey his reasonable requirements. These afflictions are always sent in love, but they are almost invariably the righteous result of a wrong course of action. He plainly says, in his word, and in no figurative or symbolical sense whatever, that the rod is, at times, to be used for punishment. According to Davies’s Lexicon, the Hebrew word שֵׁבֶט, translated “rod,” as found in Prov. 13:24; 26:3; 23:13; 22:15; and 10:13, means: “(1) a staff, or rod, for beating ; (2) a flail; (3) a shepherd’s crook; (4) a staff of office; a scepter.” The primary meaning of the word is “an instrument for punishment;” the others are secondary meanings. In the Old Testament the word “rod” comes from three other Hebrew words. Two of the words mean simply “twig;” the other refers almost entirely to the rod used by Moses and Aaron. The same word is used in Ps. 23:4 and in Ex. 21:20. In the Psalms the word is clearly figurative because of the figurative context; but in the other cases it is not so, as plainly indicated in Ex. 21:20.
The effect of the Lord’s rod was to comfort, and this will be the effect which will surely follow the use of the rod when administered in the spirit in which the Lord chastises. The spirit of the Lord is always one of tenderness and love. “For he doth not afflict willingly nor grieve the children of men.” The same spirit is also revealed by the pleadings of Abraham in behalf of Sodom. This same tender love is manifested toward every one of God’s children; and all who have in their own hearts this love, which is the only power of self-control, will extend the same to the children committed to them as a precious charge from Heaven. And then, right there, will be fulfilled the precious promise: “And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers,” and “turn the hearts of the fathers to the children, and the disobedient to the wisdom of the Just; to make ready a people prepared for the Lord.”