WHICH IS THE MORE SO?

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Michigan · Oct 12, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 41.

Read the full edition

WHICH IS THE MORE SO?

The Catholic Mirror well says that “The most wide-spread objection to Spiritualism is that it is a delusion and a cheat.” Yet in that same number of the Mirror, in the department devoted to the work of converting Protestants, there is presented, among “the saving doctrines” of the church, that of “the communion with the dead.”
Now the sole basis of Spiritualism is this very doctrine of “the communion with the dead.” Without that there could not possibly be any Spiritualism. And this is presented as a “saving doctrine” of the Catholic Church. Then as Spiritualism, which could not possibly exist without this doctrine, is “a delusion and a cheat,” what is the Catholic Church, at least so far as this “saving doctrine” is concerned?
Spiritualism is truly “a delusion and a cheat.” It is a delusion and a cheat solely because of this doctrine of “the communion with the dead,” without which there could be no such thing as Spiritualism. This doctrine alone is its life: and it is a delusion and a cheat solely because the idea of “the communion with the dead” is a delusion and a cheat. The “saving doctrine” of “the communion with the dead” is a delusion and a cheat, because that when a person dies, he is dead, and not alive; because “the dead know not anything,” and so “have no more a portion forever in anything that is done under the sun.”
Yes; “the most wide-spread objection to Spiritualism is that it is a delusion and a cheat;” and so it is precisely with the Catholic Church as to that “saving doctrine”—“the communion with the dead”—which alone is the life of Spiritualism.