AdventAI

INSPIRED PROPHECY AND MODERN VIEWS.

By Simeon Gilbert

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 46., November 16, 1897

Simeon Gilbert, D. D., in Interior.

THE fresh Bible study, which the new “spirit of study” on every side has happily made inevitable, which makes larger account and freer use of literary characteristics and historical settings and conditions, is on every account to be welcomed. The Book itself is infinitely worthy of it. And the place which the all-pervading element of prophecy holds in the entire body of our Holy Scripture gives to the question as to the right understanding of it an importance at this time which cannot be overestimated.

The term “modern views” has no doubt a fascination for many, but is one which, before using it too freely, it is well to look straight in the eye and see exactly what it means, as also what impression it is likely to convey. Cant phrases of every kind are to be avoided, or, at least, if used, born anew, as it were, in the way in which they are used. Besides, “modern views” have an instability about them, which one who is anxious to see clearly, and to see the whole, finds that he needs to watch and see which way they are facing. There was, for instance, held recently in one of the interior cities of Germany a “congress” of “modern views,” at which there were present more than one hundred representatives, a goodly number of them being from the leading universities, Berlin and the rest. They came, it is said, at the call of the most widely circulated religious journal in Germany, the Christian World. The purpose appears to have been to get together and compare notes, listen to such modern-day authorities as Kaftan and Harnack, and see how far along in the advance, up-hill or down the road, their modern views had already come. Two points of arrival, if not also for new departures, were distinctly noted. The one was that modern Protestantism, as Professor Harnack reasoned out, has at last become emancipated, not merely from traditionalism, but from the binding authority of Scripture itself; the other, as Professor Kaftan showed, is that, in the light of the modern view, the traditional teaching as to the pre-existence and incarnation of Christ has now been antiquated. Do I mean by such allusion to disparage the actual achievements of modern scholarship and modern thinking?—Not in the least. I only mean, modestly, yet boldly, to reassert the old adage, that all is not gold that glitters.

It is to be remembered that the Bible—the Bible in its divinely inspired completeness—is a book meant for a perpetual and world-wide use; and that it takes the two component parts of it, Old Testament and New Testament, to constitute the unity of God’s revelation for the salvation of men. No doubt the utterances of the prophets had an immediate timeliness and a keen pertinence to then-existing conditions and needs, and yet the value of the prophecy did not end with the primary occasion; nor was its use divinely intended for that first occasion, only.

Whose intent? It is said that it is the purpose of a scientific historic exegesis to interpret each passage according to its intent, and not according to the understanding of a later age. As to this assertion, it makes all the difference in the world whose intent it is that is meant—the human intent or the divine intention. Just how clearly or how dimly the inspired prophet understood his own message, none but an inspired “critic” could say.

It cannot be a wisely proportioned exegesis that lays more stress upon the circumstances which served as the occasion for an inspired prophecy, than upon the total significance of the prophecy itself. Biblical scholars nowadays—“modern critics” they seem to be fond of calling themselves—are of coursep. 725 right in their tireless effort to get at and to set forth the circumstances and needs of the times which gave these prophecies birth. This more careful search and research as to the occasions for the divine kindling, rekindling, and reinforcement of the great “hope of Israel,” alike by prefigurement and prediction, thus making ever more clear and more impressive the things concerning the Saviour who was to come, cannot be too strongly commended. All the lights of modern study and archeological discovery are eagerly welcomed. And yet it is worth while for the critics to remember that when the disciples of Christ declared, “Did not our hearts burn within us while he talked with us by the way, and while he opened to us the Scriptures?” it is not at all likely that the so strangely enkindled interest was made to burn within them by some merely critical expatiation about the circumstances and temporary occasions.

It is, therefore, a mistake to disparage the value of prophecy for all time, as, for instance, is done by such assertions as that, while “preaching was the great work of the Old Testament prophets,” “foretelling future events was merely subsidiary.” Isaiah, as in chapter 53, was foretelling future events,—the event of all time,—but no sufficiently thoughtful evangelical interpretation would like to speak of this as “merely subsidiary” to the prophet’s preachment to that particular generation,—an inspired prophetic utterance, the value and religious use of which infinitely outreached the immediate occasion of it.

The disposition to disparage the permanent value of the properly prophetic element in Scripture betrays a mistaken conception of the far-reaching use which the preserved record of such prophetic predictions and prefigurements was intended to serve.

Nor is it the question of chief importance concerning any particular instalment in the ancient unfolding of the world’s great hope,—the gospel of the kingdom in the person of the Christ,—just how much or how little the favored prophet himself was, at the time, given distinctly to understand. Dogmatism at this point would be an obvious impertinence. But for the inspiration of the Holy Spirit that was upon him, the prophet could not have had any sort of expectations about Him. That class of critics, of whatever school or nationality, who, holding to evolution only, deny the supernatural as having had anything to do with the Bible, are at least consistent in denying that any of the so-called prophets could have had any real expectations about Christ, or of any other far-off divine event. But Christ himself, speaking of Abraham, declared: “Your father Abraham rejoiced to see my day: and he saw it and was glad.” It may be critical enough, but it is not reverent scholarship, or in any true sense of the term, scientific exegesis, that would claim in the matter of Messianic prophecy to be wiser than the Christ himself. Yet it is claimed by some that in New Testament times “the interpretation of disconnected verses, was the only sort of exegesis known;” that even “the New Testament writers knew nothing about scientific exegesis,”—an assumption of modern-view superiority which rather curiously illuminates the modesty of our time. Imagine one of these so-styled higher critics standing up before a Paul, a John, a Peter, or the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews, and saying: “You were an excellent witness for Christian truth, in some ways, for your time; but you knew nothing about the true principles of Biblical exegesis”! Comment would the text confound.

There is, as I believe, a more reverent scholarship, a larger and nobler thought, a more convincing mode of exegesis, a more consistent position for the evangelical critic to take. And it is a strikingly just and fruitful remark made by Professor Curtiss, to the effect that “God is, in the entire Old Testament, preparing the way for the coming of his Son.” What, then, could be more natural, or more rationally credible, or, if one please, more scientific, than that one of the ways, not only of preparing for the great advent, but, in the event and forever thereafter, confirming for all time and for all the world, its glorious reality, was the long series, less and more specific, of Messianic foreshowings?

Let historic and scientific studies do their utmost to explain the circumstances and primary occasions of such prophecies; but that should be no excuse for attempts to explain them away, or to write them down as “merely subsidiary.”