AdventAI

Captain Sigsbee's Reply on the Maine Sermon

From Review and Herald, Vol. 75, No. 24., June 14, 1898

A PREACHER in Massachusetts delivered a sermon on the “Maine” disaster, and found the cause of it in the fact that her captain had attended a bull-fight on Sunday. One of the people who heard the sermon wrote to Captain Sigsbee about the matter, and received the following letter in reply:—

DEAR SIR: I beg to acknowledge the receipt of your letter, which seems to indicate that your pastor regards the destruction of the “Maine” as a possible visitation of divine Providence against that ship because of my visit to the bull-fight on Sunday. It is a fact that I attended a bull-fight on that day, not, however, to see the bull-fight, but to test the feeling of the Spaniards at Havana against me and my vessel under circumstances when they were wildly excited. I considered this an important matter.

I fail to understand your pastor’s logic. It is inconceivable that the good Lord would utterly destroy, in an instant, so many men who did not attend the bull-fight, and were not responsible for my attendance, whereas he permitted those to be saved, without exception, who actually attended the bull-fight, including myself. I trust I have a proper sense of propriety; and in respect to the bull-fight, my conscience is perfectly clear.

I beg to thank you for the kind good will which you express toward me in your letter. Military and naval men are oftentimes obliged to do things, in a professional way, which they would hardly deem agreeable in their home life.

Yours very truly.

C. D. SIGSBEE, Captain, U. S. N.