PHILOSOPHY AND SCIENCE VS. SCRIPTURE.
By M. E. K.
Ever since Satan told that great falsehood, “Ye shall not surely die,” by which he deceived Eve in the garden of Eden, there have not been wanting men who, themselves deceived into believing their own immortality, have labored most earnestly to make others believe that they are immortal. Even the Scriptures of truth have been laid hold of and twisted and distorted for that purpose. By so doing, the plan of salvation itself is robbed of its chief glory—the bestowal of life and immortality upon mankind. Philosophy has also been pressed into service to teach this error. Addison, the great essayist, referring to Plato’s argument for man’s natural immortality, exclaimed:— “It must be so — Plato, thou reasonest well! —
Else whence this pleasing hope, this fond desire,
This longing after immortality?”
In these words the fact that one longs for immortality is taken as evidence that he has it already! Upon this we may inquire, with the apostle, “For what a man seeth, why doth he yet hope for?” Rom. 8:24. If a man sees that he has immortality, why should he hope for it? But in the Scriptures, immortality is set before us as a subject of hope. We read that God will render “to them who by patient continuance in well-doing seek for glory and honor and immortality, eternal life.” Rom. 2:7. If immortality is an inherent gift, why speak of it as being sought for and obtained by “patient continuance in well-doing”? Scripture is more than philosophy, especially the “vain philosophy” which would have it that man has, through Adam, that which he can secure only through Christ, and for which Christ laid down his life. Not content with using human philosophy to controvert the Scriptures, science is now being invoked to prove that man is immortal. A scientific writer in the Westminster Review endeavors to prove his own immortality in the following manner:— I labor under the great disadvantage of ignorance, but I believe I am right when I say that the factor which represents me cannot be placed. I stay in my present manifestation, as we call the union of the subjective and the objective, as long as I can; but when, in obedience to the nature of life, separation comes, it is because all the factors are forming fresh combinations. The very fact that the body is forming new combinations shows that something has left it. Now, until I can be shown differently, I shall hold that this something is the subjective part of the combination; that it is “I”; that it must, in accordance with the nature of life, be forming a new combination also. The fact that when we die, as we say, we are still in the same universe as this, appears to some people absolutely blasphemous. Yet it is difficult to see why. The present world has been enjoyed for so short a time, the knowledge we have gained of it is so small, that it is hard to see why we should have been awakened to it at all if at death it is done, and still harder to see why what is good in one portion of eternity should not be good in another. So, for man, life is immortal, or endless; as in the objective world, so in the subjective. Life cannot be without immortality, for it is immortality; immortality, moreover, of individuality. The great trouble with this very scientific deduction is that it is not true. The factor which represents “me” is I myself, and it can be placed. If I cannot be placed, how can I bear personal responsibility? To say that a man stays in his “present manifestation” is begging the question,—it is assuming the very thing that must be proved. To the statement that “life cannot be without immortality,” it is sufficient to answer that this, if true, would prove the immortality of all vegetable and animal life. A tree decays, and forms fresh combinations, and all the animal creation does the same. But granting that the matter of which all things are composed is indestructible, that it exists and will always exist in some form, that by no means proves immortality of individuality. It proves, instead, the mutability and destructibility of individuality. Man is an individual, a specific organization and individuality. That individuality remains while he lives; upon his death it ceases. Says the psalmist: “His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146:4. Now when a man has returned to earth, and his very thoughts have perished, what has become of his individuality? Is there individuality in perished thoughts or in moldering earth?—No, indeed. But there is immortality for every one who believes on Jesus Christ, who “hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel.” 2 Tim. 1:10. But for the gospel, there could be no immortality for man; but through its merciful provisions, there is immortality for those who accept it. “Science falsely so called” has no need of God for anything. It can build a world, and people it, and make every man immortal and his own saviour. It tries to invest mortal man with divine attributes where he has need of nothing; in short, this science is but a feeble echo of that deceptive voice which at so early a period of man’s history whispered in the ear of Eve, “Ye shall not surely die. . . . Ye shall be as gods.” M. E. K.