SERMON CRITICS

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 24, 1897

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 34.

Read the full edition

SERMON CRITICS.

A MINISTER said to me the other day: “I used to enjoy preaching in new places. It seemed to me like sowing seed in a new soil. I hoped that I might be able to interest some one by the special gifts that the Master had given me, even where abler preachers had failed. But I don’t feel so now. I go to supply a pulpit, when invited, from a sense of duty, with a reluctance that requires all the grace God gives me to overcome.”
“Why?” I asked; for I knew that the speaker was not only an able but a popular preacher. He was not a pastor, because he was engaged in educational work; but the best churches, when vacant, were glad to secure his services from Sabbath to Sabbath.
“I will tell you why. Not that I do not love to preach as well as in former years, but because the congregations are now so critical. There was a time, within my memory, when churches were hungry for the word. Then, as I looked over my audience, I saw that they were waiting to be fed. Their countenances said to me what the centurion said to Peter: ‘Now therefore are we all here present before God, to hear all things that are commanded thee of God.’ But it is not so now. The audiences are waiting to compare your style, your gestures, your illustrations, the logic and rhetoric of your sermon, with those of the man whom they had last Sabbath, or with their ideal of preaching; and then when the benediction is pronounced, the people don’t go away to meditate on the truth, but to discuss the preacher. As soon as the family gathers around the table, the discussion begins. ‘Well, John, did you like this man as well as the one who preached last Sabbath?’ says the wife. And the husband tells of all the imperfections that attracted his attention. The children join in; for are they not all learning at school to be critics? And so, while eating their Sabbath dinner, they make mince-meat of the sermon. I tell you it is not pleasant for a minister of the gospel to know that he is listened to merely to be criticized.”
“But how do you know all this? They don’t criticize you in your presence—when they have invited you to dine with them, for instance?”
“No; but they criticize the other preachers, and ask me what I think about something they said, or about the manner in which they said it. So I know that when Brother A comes next Sabbath, they will talk with him about me just as they talked with me about those who preceded me in supplying the pulpit. The critical habit is so universal and so disagreeable that I sometimes think I won’t try to preach any more. A sermon that is listened to merely to detect its imperfections and comment upon them, can’t do the hearer much good.”
Now, this minister is perhaps too sensitive, and exaggerates the evil of which he complains. But there is a good deal of truth, after all, in what he says. I have heard the same complaint from other ministers, and I have listened to a good many such discussions of sermons in the family as he reports. As I live some distance from the church, I am sometimes invited to dinner, and the table-talk is too often about the literary merits of the sermon instead of the truth presented in it. The worst of the matter is that we are training up a generation of critics. We are encouraging our young people to regard preaching from the artistic standpoint exclusively. “The sermon is not a message from God, but a work of art. We must show our skill and culture by analyzing it. We are not a set of ignoramuses to take as true, either in fact or in form, whatever the preacher chooses to tell us. No, indeed; we live in the nineteenth century. The old idea that any preacher who comes along is an ambassador for Christ, and that we are bound to esteem him very highly in love for his work’s sake, is obsolete. We pay liberally for our preaching; we have a right, therefore, to the best, and to complain if we don’t get it.” And by the best is meant, not the most spiritual, the most Scriptural, and the most practical, but the most rhetorical. O that the Holy Spirit would descend in power upon our congregations, and exorcise the spirit of criticism, which is too often the spirit of the devil! — Senex Smith, in the Christian Life.