AdventAI

ETERNAL TORMENT AND PAPAL PERSECUTION.

By Francis Hope

From Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 37., September 14, 1897

BY FRANCIS HOPE.

(Birkenhead, England.)

In reading the history of apostate Christianity, I have been struck with the fact that the intense belief in eternal torment was one great cause of the persecutions of the Dark Ages. This belief came into the church at a very early period, at a time when the Christians were suffering pagan persecution, and they consoled themselves with the thought that soon God would take eternal vengeance on their enemies. Treasured in this way, it soon became the one great doctrine of the church, until the Catholics seemed to go mad on the subject. Lecky says, of that period:—

The agonies of hell seemed then the central fact of religion, and the perpetual subject of the thoughts of men. The whole intellect of Europe was employed in illustrating them. All literature, all painting, all eloquence, was concentrated on the same dreadful theme. By the pen of Dante and by the pencil of Orgagna, by the pictures that crowded every church and the sermons that rang from every pulpit, the maddening terror was sustained. The saint was often permitted in vision to behold the agonies of the lost, and to recount the spectacle he had witnessed. He loved to tell how, by the lurid glare of the eternal flames, he had seen millions writhing in every form of ghastly suffering, their eyeballs rolling with unspeakable anguish, their limbs gashed and mutilated and quivering with pain, tortured by pangs that seemed ever keener by the recurrence, and shrieking in vain to an unpitying heaven.

They believed in the actual existence of such a place. A fresco in a monastery at Pavia is emblematical of the age. It is a monk with clasped hands, and a look of agonizing terror, regarding the sufferings of the lost, the inscription above revealing his one harrowing thought: “Quis sustinebit ne descendentem moriens?” Now when men intensely believe such a doctrine as a fact, and if they also believe that all who differ with them are so doomed, and if they also further believe that it is in their power to save them from it, even to “compel them,” such men will always persecute to the full extent of their power. And while it is true that persecutions have sometimes sprung from pure wickedness and cruelty, it is also true that the majority of burnings and tortures were administered by men who were loyal and devout to what they believed to be true, and who tortured from a sense of duty and not from wantonness. Their idea was to save the heretic from still worse and eternal tortures by making him recant. What claim could human suffering have on them if the Almighty punished with such a far more exceeding and eternal weight of torture? This was one reason why belief in that doctrine led to persecution.

Another reason was this: As already intimated, the church under persecution consoled itself with the very unchristian thought that soon God would reward their enemies with eternal fire. To show this, I quote the following ferocious passage from Tertullian. It is from a treatise dissuading Christians from attending the public shows. He points to them a counter-attraction,—a spectacle reserved for them, so attractive, so fascinating, that the most joyous festival of earth faded into insignificance. This happy scene was the tortures of hell. He says:—

What shall be the magnitude of that scene? How shall I admire? How shall I laugh? How shall I rejoice? How shall I triumph when I behold so many and such illustrious kings, who were said to have mounted into heaven, groaning with Jupiter, their god, in the lowest hell? Then shall the soldiers who had persecuted the name of Christ burn in a more cruel fire than any they had kindled for the saints. Then shall the tragedians pour forth in their misfortune more piteous cries than those with which they had made the theater resound, while the comedian’s powers will be better seen as he becomes flexible by the heat. Then shall the driver in the circus stand forth to view, all blushing in his flaming chariot, and the gladiators, pierced, not by spears, but by darts of fire! . . . Compared with such spectacles, with such subjects of triumph as these, what can prætor or consul, quæstor or pontiff, afford? And even now faith can bring them near; imagination can depict them as present.

Such longing for, and gloating over, the misery of their enemies soon had its effect; for as soon as the church became powerful, it could wait no longer for the pleasing spectacle, but had to anticipate the reality by having an “earnest” of the future joys here on earth. “Faith” might bring it near, imagination might make it vivid; but when they had power, they went in for the reality. This is without doubt one reason why burning was chosen for the punishment of heresy; it resembled hell. This is the second reason why that belief caused persecution.

The second reason suggests the third; that is, that the constant contemplation of suffering will indurate and debase and steel human nature. Every war and scene of violence is proof of this. If you regard the thought with delight, you will very soon long for the sight of the torture itself, and delight in it; for, as we all know, thoughts soon change into actions. Loyola, the founder of the Jesuits, used to consecrate one entire day each week for meditation upon the sufferings of the lost. Augustine said, “The end of religion is to become like the object of worship;” and having changed their God into a Moloch of cruelty, they insensibly became like him; and exhibited an amount of cold, passionless, deliberate, and studied barbarity unrivalled in the history of mankind. They punished the heretic in a manner as like unto hell as they knew how; for by a belief in the doctrine of eternal torment, they had come to think that the tortures they inflicted would be continued eternally.