UTTER CONFUSION

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 3, 1892

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 69, No. 18.

Read the full edition

UTTER CONFUSION.

A WRITER in the Golden Censer of March 19, 1892, under the heading, “The Real Sabbath,” says:—
“At best the world is in utter confusion as to what is the identical twenty-four hours ordained as the Sabbath at creation.”
We notice the article only to show the “utter confusion” under which the writer labors in reference to the whole question, and as a sample of the confusion which exists throughout Christendom on this subject, because the people will not let the Bible decide this matter for them, but will grasp at every straw they can find as an excuse for established custom and preconceived opinion.
Notice the heading, “The Real Sabbath.” From this we should be led to expect something very definite as to the day which should be observed as the Sabbath. But the very first sentence, while acknowledging the duty of keeping a real and definite Sabbath, utterly breaks down over the thought that we cannot tell which one it is. Thus the writer says:—
“We Christians would all keep the exact day God first ordained for our Sabbath, if we could reasonably ascertain which one it is.”
This squarely acknowledges that God did in the beginning ordain a definite day for the Sabbath. And why?—Evidently because only an exact and specified day would answer the purpose of the institution. But alas, that day is hopelessly lost. But the duty remains just the same to keep the Sabbath, and so we do the best we can and keep any day we decide is best.
The writer then admits that Adam, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob all kept the Sabbath, long before commanded to Israel. But then confusion breaks forth again; for then they had “a new beginning for their year,” and “their weekly and annual festivals were appointed them.” But what had all this to do with the Sabbath which had been appointed and kept so long before that time, as he admits?
“It might be,” he continues, “that the original day observed by Adam was then restored.” But he has given us no intimation that it had ever been lost.
Next he says, “If we date from creation, who knows whether the days of creation were literal days, or seven long periods?” Then he whisks around the world east and west, claiming that the count of days thus becomes hopelessly confused, and that “while we here in America are sleeping, they on the other side of the world are keeping the original Sabbath; and we are keeping our Sabbath while they sleep.” And so we cannot keep a Sabbath any way. And all this, remember, in an argument to show which is “the real Sabbath.”
The writer then admits that the early Christians kept the first day of the week, as a second Sabbath, observing the seventh day also, but gradually the church thought the new day better represented the new dispensation, “so that the believer might get away from the tendency to make an idol of the Jewish seventh day.”
He further says, “Some claim that a Roman emperor centuries later, for State policy, first ordained this [the first day] as the Christian Sabbath; but when it was done, and by whom, is of but little consequence to us to-day; first, because we cannot make the day certain; secondly, because we do not think God means us to be bound by the letter, but only by the spirit of the command.”
How is this? Cannot that first day ordained by this Roman emperor, be determined? Why then keep the first day in honor of Christ’s resurrection, if we do not know what day it was? Why not, on just as good ground, keep the seventh day in honor of the creation?
But again: If God only designed that we should keep “the spirit” of the commandment, why did he ordain at first a specific day, as the letter? Why did he not just give us the spirit, and let the letter go?
And now we come to the close of the article, which in view of all that has gone before, must be considered most singular, if not positively amusing. It reads as follows:—
“We say it is of little consequence what day we keep. The command is to observe the seventh day as a Sabbath to the Lord, which means one day in seven. We have a good reason for keeping Sunday as our Sabbath, since it represents, to us, the day Christ arose and redeemed us from death. This honors Christ. To keep the Saturday Sabbath honors Moses. But we are under a new dispensation, in which the letter killeth, but the spirit makes alive. Devoutly keeping the seventh day, and being ready to do God’s will most exactly when plainly discerned, we believe he accepts our keeping the Lord’s day as our Sabbath.”
Let us now analyze this a little, and so get at “the real Sabbath.” First, The command enjoins the day which God originally ordained, and that is acknowledged to be an exact and definite day. But now we learn that it does not mean a definite day at all, only one day in seven.
Second, It is of little consequence which day we keep, though an exact day was ordained in the beginning, and we would keep it if we could.
Third, It does not matter which day we keep, though one honors Christ and the other honors Moses. But why, we ask, does keeping the Saturday Sabbath honor Moses? What did Moses have to do with it? Why don’t we honor Adam, or Noah, or Abraham, all of whom are admitted to have kept the Sabbath, just as much as we honor Moses?
Fourth, Inasmuch as the day is lost, all we can do, anyway, is to say that we intend to honor Christ by keeping the first day of the week.
Fifth, But we are now under a new dispensation, which does not require any letter, or outward day, but only the spirit, which admits of no outward sign.
Sixth, But since we do keep the seventh day devoutly, and are ready to do so exactly what God requires, we believe he accepts of our keeping another day!
If any one wishes worse confusion than this (and we submit to the reader if we have not fairly represented the positions taken), we do not know where he would find it. Why will not men take the teachings of the Bible, as they are plainly given to us, namely, that the Sabbath was ordained in Eden; that it was incorporated into the moral law, with other moral precepts, at Sinai; that with the rest of the law it came over into this dispensation unchanged; that God has had one uniform, immutable standard of right, as his moral law, from the beginning to the end; that the Sabbath, in all its moral and spiritual requirements and relations, is just as much needed now as ever; that Sunday is not needed to commemorate any of the work of Christ, since God has given us divinely ordained memorials to show forth his humiliation, his death, and his resurrection in the ordinances of the Lord’s Supper and baptism; and that as the Sabbath shone forth in paradise before it was lost, so it will likewise appear in paradise restored (Isa. 66:22, 23)—a season of joy and blessedness forever. Here is harmony instead of confusion, clearness and satisfaction instead of doubt and uncertainty, and here only is this harmony to be found.