The people of the United States have often been able to profit from the results of the experiments of European nations, and should be able to find in the occasion of the recent political crisis in Prussia another opportunity for so doing. The issue involved on that occasion was one which was not long since sought to be raised in this country,—that of compulsory religious instruction in the public schools,—and it is not unlikely that the question will again be raised at no very distant day. Meanwhile it is interesting to note the manner in which some of the political authorities in Germany undertook to establish the measure, and the results which attended the effort.
The means which brought the issue before the people of Prussia was a bill introduced into the Prussian Landtag, in January, with the support of Emperor William, Chancellor Caprivi, and the Minister of Education, and of which compulsory religious instruction was the principal feature. Upon this point it provided as follows:—
- That every community including sixty scholars of a different religious faith from that of the majority must be divided, so that both majority and minority should be taught in their own religion.
- That all schools should be so arranged that each should contain scholars entirely of one faith, and that the teachers should be of the same religious creed as the pupils, and should teach to them the articles of that creed.
- That no pupils should be excused from this religious instruction, even at the request or demand of the parents.
- That the children of those who did not believe in any form of worship recognized by the State should also be compelled to receive religious instruction in the schools which they attended, unless it was shown that they received such instruction at home.
The measure was warmly favored by the conservative and aristocratic party and the Roman Catholic party, and as warmly opposed by the National Liberals and the Progressive, or Radical, party. The opposition proved so strong that Emperor William weakened in his support, whereupon Chancellor von Caprivi and Minister Zedlitz-Trützschler, who were strongly committed to the measure, resigned their offices. Chancellor von Caprivi was replaced by Count von Eulenburg, who on March 28, withdrew the objectionable bill in the Landtag.
Such was the rather disastrous result of the attempt to put in practice in the German empire the idea of compulsory religious instruction. The experiment ought, it would seem, to teach all civilized nations the wisdom of leaving religious instruction to the control of other agencies than the State. It can hardly be supposed that the question would have been dealt with in other countries by abler minds than those which attempted its solution in this instance, or that the political or social status in other lands would have made the problem easier of solution. Certainly it would not be so in our own country, where religious creeds are vastly more numerous than in Germany, and where the masses are certainly no less tenacious of their rights and their religious views.
L. A. S.