The eighth annual meeting of the stockholders of the (reorganized) Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association convened, according to notice duly published, at 10 A. M. (local time), March 9, 1899. The president of the board, W. C. Sisley, occupied the chair. Prayer was offered by Elder J. N. Loughborough.
The secretary of the association called the roll of stockholders and those holding proxies, and all such present responded.
On motion, the reading of the minutes of the last annual meeting was waived.
The Chair made a few remarks, calling attention to the fact that this was the thirty-ninth annual meeting (eighth under the new charter) since the organization of the association, and during all that time the Lord’s fostering care has been over the institution. He reminded the stockholders that this was the time for the annual election of officers, and extended an urgent invitation to all to make a close investigation of all the affairs of the office of publication. He hoped that in the selection of the directors, care would be exercised, and just such ones chosen as would best carry out their wishes, and advance the cause of God. For brevity’s sake, he omitted the detailed report, owing to the fact that it had been published in the Conference Bulletin.
A condensed report, giving the resources and liabilities of the institution, was presented by the Treasurer, C. D. Rhodes, as follows:—
FINANCIAL STATEMENT OF THE S. D. A. PUBLISHING ASSOCIATION, FOR YEAR ENDING DEC. 31, 1898.
| Resources. | Liabilities. | |
|---|---|---|
| Real estate, | $70,326 00 | |
| Personal property, | 116,766 08 | |
| Cuts and engravings, | 4,427 85 | |
| Type, | 11,393 63 | |
| Material, | 25,200 96 | |
| Work in progress, | 9,362 82 | |
| Cash on hand, | 4,324 33 | |
| Cash in bank, | 4,439 02 | |
| Bills receivable, | 29,500 55 | |
| Accounts receivable, | 138,792 00 | |
| Stock in sales-room, | 77,933 84 | |
| Stock in retail dept., | 1,303 23 | |
| Fuel on hand, | 498 60 | |
| Notes payable, | $150,289 72 | |
| Demand notes, | 15,918 29 | |
| Accounts payable, | 80,287 39 | |
| Capital stock, | 149,160 00 | |
| Stock not issued, | 61,897 27 | |
| Surplus, | 33,631 10 | |
| Donations and legacies, | 3,085 14 | |
| $494,268 91 | $494,268 91 | |
| Capital stock, | $149,160 00 | |
| Stock not issued, | 61,897 27 | $211,057 27 |
| Surplus, | $31,275 08 | |
| Net gain, | 2,356 02 | 33,631 10 |
| Present worth, | $244,688 37 |
Following this report, questions were asked concerning it, the cause of the deficit on some of the periodicals, etc. Some thought the report was too general, and ought to have been more specific. A special invitation was given for any who desired to do so to make the closest scrutiny into the way the accounts were kept, etc.
Elder A. T. Jones thought that was what the stockholders ought to do; for he believed that the present system made losses appear in some departments when losses did not actually exist. He believed this was true in regard to our own papers.
J. I. Gibson moved that a committee of five business men be appointed to examine into the matter of this charge. This was carried, and the following were nominated from the floor: L. McCoy, W. A. Wilcox, C. H. Jones, G. A. Nichols, and J. Sutherland.
The auditor’s report was called for, which was given, as follows:—
AUDITOR’S REPORT.
BATTLE CREEK, MICH., Feb. 1, 1899.
Mr. W. C. Sisley, Pres. Review and Herald Board, City.
DEAR SIR: I hand you herewith a statement of the accounts of the Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association, after having completed an examination for the year ending Dec. 31, 1898. This examination was made through arrangements with Elder S. H. Lane and Mr. C. D. Rhodes. In making this I was allowed free access to the records and to all matters pertaining to any part of the accounts, and a careful record was taken of the funds on hand, a list of which you will also find herewith. This agrees with the amount shown on statement, and the examination has been of such a character that I am prepared to say that the statement herewith presented is a true and correct representation. I find the condition of the records good, having been kept in a very complete and intelligent manner, with evidence showing that special efforts have been made in the work of the Office for the interest of all concerned.
Mr. C. D. Rhodes, cashier, extends an invitation to any who are personally interested, and who desire to make an investigation, to visit the Office, when all necessary information and assistance will be cheerfully rendered.
Very truly yours, R. H. CADWALADER, Auditor.
On motion, the report was accepted.
A. O. Burrill moved that the Chair appoint the usual committees. The motion was seconded, and they were announced as follows:—
On Nominations: J. N. Loughborough, I. H. Evans, Allen Moon.
On Plans: J. I. Gibson, O. A. Olsen, C. H. Jones.
On motion, the meeting adjourned until Monday, March 13, at 10:30 A. M.
SECOND MEETING.
The second meeting was held according to adjournment. After singing, prayer was offered by Elder U. Smith. The roll of proxy-holders was called, and the minutes of the previous meeting were read and approved.
Elder J. O. Corliss then made a few remarks, in the course of which he read the following:—
Resolved, That the trustees elected at this meeting be classified as follows: The three trustees receiving the highest number of votes shall serve for three years; the two trustees receiving the next highest number of votes shall serve for two years; and the two trustees receiving the next highest number of votes shall serve for one year. Should there be a tie vote as to any of said classes, then the classification shall be determined by lot among the trustees themselves.
In order to facilitate such a measure, he offered the following preparatory resolution:—
Resolved, That Article 8, of the Articles of Association of this corporation be, and the same is, amended to read as follows:—
“The stock, property, business, and affairs of this corporation shall be managed by seven directors, who shall all be chosen at the annual meeting for 1899; two for the term of one year, two for the term of two years, and three for the term of three years, and until their successors are elected, and appear to enter upon their duties. “As the term of service of each of said class of directors shall expire, others shall be elected by the stockholders, at the annual meetings, at such time and place as shall be provided by the by-laws, who shall serve respectively for the term of three years and until their successors are elected in the same manner, and for a like term of service. And so on thereafter annually each of said class of directors shall be elected for three years, and until their successors appear to enter upon their duties. Said directors must be stockholders, and of full age.”
The motion to adopt was seconded, after which remarks were made by Elders Olsen, McCoy, Holser, Mitchell, F. E. Belden, and others, when it was voted to lay the whole matter over for consideration one year hence.
The report of the Committee on Investigation was called for; and L. McCoy, the chairman, offered the following report:—
Your committee appointed to investigate the system of charges used by the Review and Herald Publishing Company in its accounts with your denominational papers, beg leave to submit the following report:—
First: We have made a careful investigation of the cost of the production of the REVIEW AND HERALD paper for the four months ending Feb. 1, 1899, and find that the manufacturer’s profit over and above the cost of production, is eight per cent. of the cost of production.
For the Instructor for the same time, five and one-third per cent.
For the German Hausfreund for the same time, without profit above production.
Second: We then made an investigation on two blocks of accounts, including about fifty jobs of commercial work, upon which there had been a gain above the cost of production of, on the first lot, eight and two-thirds per cent.; second lot, twenty per cent.
You will notice by the previous report, that there is a manufacturer’s profit of eight per cent. on the REVIEW AND HERALD, and five and one-third per cent. on the Instructor, which is below the profit for commercial work.
Third: As to the manner of ascertaining percentages upon the cost of production upon our denominational papers, we are not prepared to suggest anything better. We do suggest, however, that in the annual report a statement be made of the manufacturer’s profits on each one of these periodicals, though this will involve an additional expense.
Fourth: In reference to the deficit on the REVIEW AND HERALD paper for 1898, it can be partially accountedp. 188 for as follows: (1) The reduction of the subscription from two dollars to $1.50 a year; (2) additional expense in the editorial department; (3) the publication of the Sunset Calendar, which was furnished free to subscribers; (4) the Canvassers’ Supplement. The latter, we think, should have been charged to the Book Department, instead of to the REVIEW.
Fifth: In regard to the comparatively small net profit of the Review and Herald Publishing Association, of $2,356.02, as shown by the Treasurer’s report for 1898, we find that this can be accounted for largely by the heavy discount on type and machinery amounting to about $13,000, which should have been distributed over the last four or five years. During 1894-5-6 no discounts whatever have been made on some of the machinery.
L. McCOY, C. H. JONES, J. SUTHERLAND, } Committee. G. A. NICHOLS, W. A. WILCOX,
It was moved by Elder Underwood, seconded by I. D. Van Horn, that the report be accepted. The question was spoken to briefly by R. A. Hart, and at length by Elder A. T. Jones, who was interrogated in the course of his remarks by Elders Underwood and Santee, J. I. Gibson, and others. Elder Jones dwelt upon the principles involved in the matter in controversy, as set forth by the Spirit of God. The Testimonies call for a reformation of principles on which the institution was run, and he pleaded for that rather than to indorse some definite method of dealing.
At 1 P. M. the meeting adjourned, to meet at three o’clock the same afternoon.
THIRD MEETING.
Elder Kilgore offered prayer. The reading of the minutes of the previous meeting was waived.
The Chair then made a reply to a question that had been raised relative to the report of the investigating committee, as to depreciation in value of machinery, etc., in which he took occasion to say that he had no fear of the closest investigation into the conduct of the business, from a business standpoint, but that the way the Lord looks at things may be different from the way man looks at them. He desired to receive whatever lesson the Lord has for him, and that every wrong thing may be searched out, and righteousness and equity prevail throughout the institution.
Elder I. H. Evans then offered the following motion, which was seconded by Prof. F. W. Howe:—
I move an amendment to the Treasurer’s report to the effect that the gain or loss on our denominational papers shall be based upon the cost of production, plus a proper percentage for covering the insurance, taxes, interest, and incidental expenses.
This was spoken to by S. H. Lane, A. T. Jones, C. H. Jones, R. A. Hart, and others, after which it was carried. The original report of the committee, as discussed and amended, was then voted.
On motion, the meeting adjourned until 6 P. M., same day.
FOURTH MEETING.
After singing, prayer was offered by W. B. White. Minutes of previous meeting approved.
The report of the Nominating Committee was then presented, placing the following-named persons before the stockholders, from whom to choose seven directors: W. C. Sisley, C. D. Rhodes, Uriah Smith, S. H. Lane, J. I. Gibson, J. N. Nelson, L. McCoy, I. H. Evans, G. W. Amadon, R. A. Underwood, J. H. Morrison, Joseph Smith, M. J. Cornell, and H. Nicola.
Elder S. H. Lane asked permission to bring before the stockholders a matter that he considered of importance. In 1849 the REVIEW AND HERALD was first published, so this is the year of jubilee, when, according to Bible custom, wrongs should be righted. He then referred to the debt of $47,000 which the Review and Herald Publishing Association holds against the Battle Creek College, and thought it proper to instruct the board to remit at least the interest due, which is not far from $15,000; and, in addition, make a donation of, say, $5,000 worth of books, to be sold by the canvassers now being educated by the college, which could be used to help clear that debt.
Remarks were made by several persons, including Elders Loughborough, Westphal, Burrill, Mitchell, McCoy, and Morrison, and E. A. Sutherland, after which it was moved that the suggestion be adopted. Then a motion was made to amend the motion so as to include the entire debt. This was seconded, and an amendment to the amendment was offered, to forgive but $30,000 of the college debt, and give the balance in books. This was objected to by several, among them I. H. Evans, who could not see how a man could rejoice in his own jubilee and in the bondage of his brother; for it is known that the Review and Herald is itself owing $240,000, while the college is owing only $80,000. He thought it was a fine thing to forgive, and also a fine thing to pay. He was in favor of remitting the interest, but not the principal.
A substitution was then offered to the effect that the Review Office remit to the new College Association the interest that has accrued on its indebtedness.
Professor Sutherland considered this a very critical time. He had no desire to urge that any particular part or all of the debt be forgiven, but he believed that there would come such a blessing to the Review and Herald by such an act of liberality as would start a wave of liberality and prosperity that it has not known for many years. The question with him was, Who will get the blessing that comes from giving?
At this juncture the meeting adjourned until 7:30 the following morning.
FIFTH MEETING.
After the opening exercises, the minutes of the previous meeting were read and approved.
The question before the house was the substitution moved by Elder McCoy, which was as follows:—
That we, the stockholders of the Seventh-day Adventist Association, instruct our directors to remit to the new Battle Creek College Association, when formed, a sum equal to the accrued interest on the debt due from the college to this association.
Nearly the whole session was spent in a discussion of the matter, in which Dr. Kellogg, J. H. Morrison, C. D. Rhodes, J. I. Gibson, R. A. Underwood, E. A. Sutherland, and others joined. The motion was put to a vote, and carried.
On motion, the meeting adjourned until 2:30 P. M., same day.
SIXTH MEETING.
After the opening song, prayer, and reading of the minutes of the previous meeting, the Chair said the question before the house was the resolution of Dr. Kellogg, requesting the stockholders to remit the balance of college debt.
This was spoken to by several, after which the matter was laid over until the next annual meeting.
On motion, the Treasurer’s report was accepted.
On motion, the Chair was empowered to appoint three tellers to count the votes cast. These were W. O. Palmer, W. H. Hall, and Frederick Griggs. The roll-call showed that 1,731 shares were represented in person, and 4,308 by proxy.
The Committee on Plans submitted the following report:—
Your Committee on Plans would respectfully submit the following suggestions for your consideration:—
We beg to call the attention of the shareholders to the deficit in the running of the Instructor for the year 1898, which, we understand, was caused, in part, by the expensive form in which the paper is printed; and would suggest that the shareholders express their opinion with reference to the betterment of the paper, and the best means to increase its circulation.
We would suggest the propriety of discontinuing the publication of the Christian Educator, because its field of operations is so limited, being largely covered by other papers.
We would respectfully recommend that this association handle the books published in other languages besides the English by our European publishing houses; and that we request these houses to reciprocate by handling the foreign books published by us; and, further, we would request the General Conference Committee to assist us in securing the services of a properly qualified person to look after this work, and also to look after the interests of our foreign papers.
That a new tent hymn-book be published as soon as expedient.
We would also suggest that the stockholders instruct the incoming board of directors to use their best endeavors to carry out the recommendations that have been made from time to time to put God-fearing young men in training for filling responsible positions in connection with the publishing work.
It was moved that the report be adopted and each item be voted on separately.
To the first resolution, S. H. Lane, C. H. Jones, A. T. Jones, B. M. Shull, A. J. Breed, Mrs. S. M. I. Henry, Mrs. Ida Hibben, and several others spoke, after which Elder F. M. Wilcox presented the following amendment to the resolution:—
Moved, That the board of directors be instructed so to change the style and character of the Youth’s Instructor as to make it conform to, and answer the design of, its original purpose as far as possible; and that such difference be made in the price of the journal as shall be permitted by the change.
This was supported and carried.
The Chair then stated that he wished to exonerate the editors of the Instructor from any blame in the matter of the policy of the paper during the last year or so; for they had acted according to instructions.
On motion of Elder Irwin, the suggestion concerning the Christian Educator was referred to the General Conference Committee, inasmuch as the Educator was first started in pursuance of a recommendation of the General Conference.
The fourth suggestion was spoken to by Elder J. M. Rees, who stated that of making song-books among us there was no end, and he would prefer a cheaper edition of the hymnal collection. He therefore submitted the following resolution:—
Whereas, There seems to be a general call for a cheaper edition of our regular song-book for use in tent and revival effort; therefore,—
Resolved, That we ask the board of directors to issue an edition of the church hymn-book at a price suited to this demand.
This was referred to the General Conference Committee.
To the sixth suggestion, Elder A. T. Jones spoke, stating that part of the increased expense in running the REVIEW was due to the editorial help in the way of young men who were in training for similar work in other fields. There have been two such in the Office, and now one of them has been called to England to assist in the work on Present Truth. He insisted that that was not expense, but an investment in brains, which he considered just as good an investment as to put the money in machinery in the press-room.
After the adoption of the report as amended, Elder C. McReynolds submitted the following resolution, which was seconded by Elder C. Santee:—p. 189 That Article 1 of Section 7 of the by-laws of this association be so amended as to provide for a committee to audit the accounts, and set the wages, of the heads of the departments of the association.
After some discussion, the motion was laid on the table.
The following motion was then made by Elder Westphal:—
Whereas, It seems necessary that the Christlicher Hausfreund be made a thoroughly missionary paper, and it is therefore necessary to have some other paper as a special means of communication to our people; therefore,—
Resolved, That a monthly church paper about the size of the Zions-Wächter, published at Hamburg, to cost not more than twenty-five cents a year, be published to meet the demand.
This matter was referred to the General Conference Committee and the board of directors of the Publishing Association.
On motion, the meeting adjourned to 7:30 P. M.
SEVENTH MEETING.
This meeting was called for the purpose of receiving the report of the tellers appointed to count the votes cast for the board of directors.
In behalf of the tellers, W. H. Hall made the following report:—
| Votes | |
|---|---|
| J. I. Gibson | 4,718 |
| C. D. Rhodes | 4,679 |
| S. H. Lane | 4,411 |
| U. Smith | 3,892 |
| W. C. Sisley | 3,453 |
| I. H. Evans | 2,936 |
| L. Mc Coy | 2,794 |
These persons were declared duly elected as directors of the Publishing Association for the ensuing year.
Following this, F. E. Belden offered the following resolution:—
Whereas, The sale of our subscription books has been the greatest of all sources of profit to this association in the past, in addition to the spiritual good accomplished by such books; therefore,—
Resolved, That as individuals and officers of Conferences and tract societies, we give special attention to this important branch of the cause by encouraging suitable persons everywhere to engage in this work.
This motion was supported and unanimously carried, after which the minutes of the meeting were read and accepted.
Then after several short talks by different persons, including I. H. Evans, A. R. Henry, and others, on motion of W. W. Prescott the meeting adjourned sine die, and was dismissed by Elder J. H. Morrison.
The newly elected board of directors of the Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association met at 267 West Main St., Battle Creek, Mich., on Wednesday, March 15, 1899, at 5 P. M., and organized as follows:—
President and General Manager, W. C. Sisley; Vice-President, S. H. Lane; Treasurer, C. D. Rhodes; Secretary, U. Smith; Superintendent, J. I. Gibson; Auditor, L. McCoy.
Jno. I. Gibson, Sec., pro tem.