AdventAI

PORTO RICO.

By H. E. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 13., March 28, 1899

Its Present and Future Conditions.

“Father Sherman,” a Catholic priest, son of General W. T. Sherman, last autumn took a trip through the Island of Porto Rico. Some of the facts of general interest in his report have been made public by the War Department at Washington.

The condition of the public roads was found to be very bad. With but few exceptions they are either unfit for, or entirely impassable with, wagons, and a liberal public outlay on them is advised. The fact that Porto Rico passed through a national crisis without losing a town or a crop, or suffering the serious consequences of war, shows that the people were ready to exchange rulers.

Considering that the Catholic Church has held sway in this place ever since its colonization, the words of this priest of that church, saying that “the state of religion on the island is unsatisfactory,” are especially noteworthy. Some quotations from the published report will show what is the state of religion there. The following extracts are from the priest’s report, as published in the New York Tribune:—

When the congregations have become accustomed to sustaining their priests, the Catholic religion will flourish much more in Porto Rico than it has under Spanish rule. The sacrament of confirmation has not been administered for many years in a great part of the island. The bishop recently appointed is said to be unwilling to serve, and there is need that the government should show an active interest in the matter. It would seem that a change in the ecclesiastical system was too sudden, causing a kind of paralysis and consternation among a body of men accustomed to lean on the government, and find in it their normal means of support. Religion is dead on the island. Whether it can be revived as a living influence is highly problematical. There is little or no observance of the sanctity of Sunday. Stores are open, the country people gather in the villages, and traffic is far more active on that day than on any other. The plazas of many towns on a Sunday morning present the aspect of a market and fair combined.

Though in every town of any size there is found a large and handsome edifice, the services are poorly attended. All the inhabitants of the island, with few exceptions, are, nominally at least, Roman Catholics. Few of the men are more than Catholic in name. They are baptized, married, and buried by the priests; that is the extent of their Catholicism. Now that the priests are deprived of governmental aid, many are leaving the country, and more intend to depart before the winter is over. A moderate percentage of the clergy are of native origin, and these will be more inclined to stay, as they are more in sympathy with the new order of things, and have a chance of procuring more desirable parishes, owing to the vacancies left by the departure of the Spanish clergy. The church in Porto Rico has been so united with the state, and so identified with it in the eyes of the people, that it must share the odium with which the Spanish rule is commonly regarded. Complaint is made that the priests were too much interested in political matters, that they preached Spain instead of the gospel, and that many displayed the mercenary spirit.

Another writer in the Christian Herald, in speaking of religion in Cuba and Porto Rico,p. 196 gives some additional light on the conditions met in those places. He says:—

Fully nine tenths of the congregations are composed of women. The men seldom attend, save on the more important feast-days. At each service confessions are heard. The confessionals are mere wooden boxes, or open stalls, placed against the wall. They have a square, grated aperture in each of the two sides, beneath which is a narrow, cushioned ledge, upon which the penitent kneels. The confessions are generally heard by a cowled, rough-robed monk, a member of one of the many orders. At high mass the music is always fine, it being the habit in Havana to employ the regular theatrical orchestra.

That the state of religion is as these paragraphs prove it to be, is evidently the result of a union of church and state. This being so, instead of carrying out the suggestion of the priest, “that the government should show an active interest in the matter,” it would seem far better wisdom for the government to attend to its legitimate work of governing in civil affairs, and let the power of true religion work in religious matters.

As usual, laxity in religion is not the only evil resulting from Spanish domination. Education has not received, and does not receive, in the island the attention desirable. The sending of teachers from this country who understand both English and Spanish is recommended. This, it is said, will improve the system as well as hasten the Americanizing of the people. The report says, further:—

The organized charities in Porto Rico are defective. There is no asylum for the blind, who are met on the roadside begging for bread. There is much more public mendacity than is deemed advisable to permit in the United States; and while individuals are kind and benevolent, they seem to lack the principle of association in their efforts to relieve the unfortunate. There is a great deal of poverty on the island. The malformation of so many of the children is due to imperfect nourishment. The great excess of infant mortality is probably due, in part, to the same cause, and some stringent public measures should be begun to ameliorate the condition of the lower classes.

Although a high degree of civilization is claimed for the people of the island, in one thing—the disposal of the dead—they are barbarous. Sometimes the corpses are thrown into shallow graves, without box or casket. In other instances small vaults are rented for a time, and then the bones are gathered up, and thrown into a common receptacle. The Catholic Church and the municipalities both claiming jurisdiction in this duty, evils have prevailed that demand immediate reform.

In his report “Father Sherman” confesses that “the state of morality is low.” He says that the eradication of this great evil is one of the most difficult problems this government will have to meet. He denies, of course, the often-repeated statement that the Catholic clergy is somewhat to blame for this state of affairs.

After pointing out in this report that “the government should show an active interest” in the matter of sustaining the priests; that “a liberal public outlay” on the roads is desirable; that Spanish-American teachers be sent there (who of course would be largely Catholic); and that efforts be put forth “to ameliorate the condition of the lower classes,”—after recommending that all this be done “at once” by the federal government, a shrewd hint for early statehood (in which, in the very nature of things, the Catholic Church would rule) is given by stating the population to be a million people, and that “political incapacity is not to be argued from factional differences.” This hint is completed by comparing the “highly civilized” cities, villages, and towns of Porto Rico, with their “teeming population,” to the “waste lands” of California and New Mexico in 1848, which were at that time largely Spanish colonies. A reference is also made in this connection to the “thousands of educated men” among the inhabitants, of whom the vast majority are priests. H. E. S.