THAT we are in the era of frauds has long been apparent; but the crowning fraudulent pretense of the nineteenth century is now apparently reached: it is the making merchandise of so-called divine power, selling the gifts of the Spirit for money. There was an attempt at this kind of traffic at the beginning of the Christian era; and it is nothing more than is to be expected that it should reappear at its close. The effort did not meet with divine favor then; it will not now. We have the account in Acts 8:18–20: “And when Simon saw that through laying on of the apostles’ hands the Holy Ghost was given, he offered them money, saying, Give me also this power, that on whomsoever I lay hands, he may receive the Holy Ghost. But Peter said unto him, Thy money perish with thee, because thou hast thought that the gift of God may be purchased with money.”
The fraudulent counterpart of this is found at the present day in the workings of so-called “Christian Science,” of which science the Banner of Light of April 8 says:—
Everything of value in Christian Science has been almost wholly borrowed from the higher teachings of modern Spiritualism. The plagiarism is concealed by the bewildering negations and unwarranted assertions its advocates proclaim to the world, hoping to gain place and power for themselves at the expense of others. The “power” they claim to have is, according to their theory, the direct gift of God to them, gratis. Mrs. Eddy and her especially endowed pupils turn about and sell this power to less-favored mortals at several hundred dollars a head. The God of the Christian has been accused of almost everything; but the sale of his power, second or fourth hand, was not attempted until the closing days of the nineteenth century.
It has seemed evident from the beginning that Christian Science was only a modified form of Spiritualism; and when two phases of one great imposition, through jealousy of each other, fall into antagonism, it may lead to confessions which are amusing, if not edifying, to the outside world. Recent glaring exhibitions of presumptuous recklessness in regard to human life, resulting in the death of some noted persons, through the influence of Christian Science, have led to a wide-spread agitation and discussion in regard to the merits of the system in question. In reference to this the Banner of Light says:—
This discussion has led a number of the disciples of the Christian Science school to publish lengthy definitions of their so-called philosophy, all of which, while containing a few grains of truth, nevertheless are largely composed of chaff.
This, from a Spiritualist, is pre-eminently ludicrous. Again, the Banner says:—
If its present leader [of Christian Science, Mrs. Eddy] would confess the source from which she drew her inspiration, Dr. Quimby would be found to be the promoter of every important truth set forth in its name.
It strikes us that these two isms should not accuse each other of plagiarism, nor be envious or jealous of each other’s work.— U. S.