“It used to be thought that the stars were all very much alike in magnitude and constitution; not, indeed, without considerable difference, but as much resembling one another as do individuals of the same race.”—Young’s “Astronomy.”
That one star shines more brightly than another was always apparent; but it was thought that one star was brighter than another simply because it was nearer to us. Men did not believe that the radiance of different stars meant an actual difference in the stars themselves; the difference in the brightness of various stars was because of their difference in distance. One star was brighter than another because it was nearer to us.
But there came a time when men learned that this explanation was not sufficient. There might be instances where one star was brighter than another because it was much nearer; but as the distances to the stars began to be measured, it was found that sometimes a very bright star was actually many times farther away than another star very inferior in point of brilliancy.
Alpha Centauri is about two hundred and thirty thousand times farther from us than is the sun. This star has a companion that emits about one sixth as much light as itself. According to the most careful estimate of the brilliancy of Alpha Centauri, the light we receive from it is about 1/16,950,000,000 of that we receive from the sun. But if the sun were removed to a distance equal to that of Alpha Centauri, it would shine with only 1/52,900,000,000 of its present brilliancy. It follows, therefore, that the star emits about three times as much light as the sun. A man situated at Alpha Centauri would see the sun as a star one third as bright as Alpha Centauri appears to us. Here is a difference which can not be accounted for by a difference of distance.
Take another example: The parallax of Sirius has not been definitely determined. Proctor estimates that it is at least four times farther from us than Alpha Centauri, and, did it emit no greater amount of light, would appear to shine with but one sixteenth of that star’s luster. But the fact of the case is that it is four times more bright; hence, the real amount of light it emits must exceed that of Alpha Centauri no less than sixty-four times, and that of our sun no less than one hundred and ninety-two times. The correctness of these figures can not be definitely determined until the distance of Sirius is more accurately known, but it is certainly more distant than Alpha Centauri; and though later investigation may reduce the estimate, the result can not affect the argument.
By similar reasoning it is judged that if Alpha Centauri were removed to the distance at which 61 Cygni lies from us, although thereby its light would be diminished to one ninth of its present value, it would, nevertheless, outshine either component of the double star, 61 Cygni, more than eleven times.
In these instances, distance would not account for the difference in brightness. There appears an actual difference in the stars themselves when placed at equal distances from us. Men had a ready explanation for this. It showed, they said, a difference in size. Assuming this, the diameter of Sirius may be held to exceed that of our sun in the proportion of about 14 to 1, or to have a diameter of nearly 12,000,000 miles, and a volume 2,688 times as large as the sun’s.
But is this second explanation joined with the first able to account for the difference in star luster?—No; there is still another factor. Astronomers have found that they must not overlook one more characteristic of the stars if they would be with the facts:—
“The differences of brightness are due, first, to difference of distance; second, to difference of dimensions, or of light-giving area; third, to difference in the brilliance of the light-giving surface, depending upon difference of temperature and constitution.”
“As Bessel puts it, there is no reason that there may not ‘be as many dark stars as bright ones.’ . . . The companion of Sirius though only giving about 1/12,000 part as much light as Sirius itself, is at least 1/10 part as heavy; so that, mass for mass, it can not be 1/120,000 part as luminous.”
In the case of Sirius and its companion, we have two stars equally distant, or nearly so, from us; but owing to careful investigation regarding their perturbations in their orbits through their mutual attractions, which is directly as the mass, it has been ascertained that Sirius is fully ten times heavier. By a careful measure of the light that we receive from them respectively, we find that Sirius sends us twelve thousand times as much as the companion star. It is thus easily found that, mass for mass, the companion star can not be 1/120,000 part as luminous.
These are the findings of modern astronomy. Students of the skies have at length reached the great and final truth that “one star differs from another star in [radiance or] glory.” It took much patient, careful, accurate investigation; and it took time to gather sufficient facts to get at last at the great truth; but the student of the Word was told nearly two thousand years ago that one star differs from another star in radiance. Here was the great truth, given by the God who made the stars. Here was a truth which comprehended the facts. But men refused to credit the truth until they could find it through the facts.
There is no question that had they believed the Word, and conducted their investigations in the light of it, it would have been to them an invaluable aid. From the moment that faith entered, knowledge of the truth must come with that faith. The only thing left to do would be, in time, to find the facts. But God knew that it would be ages before the facts could be gathered one by one. For our best good, he left us to search them out; but to keep us from ignorance during the interval, he gave us the eternal truth; and astronomers, though they live everlasting years, will never be able to revise or amend this simple statement of God.