Socialist Combinations: The Trusts and Competition
Under the heading, “Socialist Combinations,” the New York Tribune of April 27 calls the attention of the trusts to the plain logic of their proceedings. It says:— The capitalist and captain of industry in these later days has set himself to demonstrate that the theories of the socialist are sound. After some centuries of adherence to the principle that individual competition brings the best results and the greatest progress for the individual and for society, suddenly many thousand employers and capitalists rush out of business, give up the positions they occupy and the plants they own, in order to avoid competition; and set themselves to prove that society can be best and most cheaply served, and the workers and managers, from highest to lowest, can get better returns, if all productive work in each branch is performed by a single centralized body controlling prices and wages at pleasure, abolishing agents and middlemen, restrained by no competition, and responsible only to society as a whole. If this theory is true, does it not follow as a matter of course that society as a whole might better take possession of the plants, and control the business, and absorb for itself the profits of production, or the gains by cheapening production, at its pleasure? If the modern combination proves that competition is no longer a benefit, but a curse; that individual struggling for success is no longer needed to evolve the best inventions and devices, and bring them into use; that the monster corporation can work more cheaply, and at the same time more wisely and ably, in handling many establishments of different kinds, far apart and under different circumstances, than the individual owners who have created them; that it can prevent the frequent stoppage of the weaker works, while the stronger continue to thrive; that society no longer needs any defense against monopoly, because the monopoly must always cheapen in order to enlarge business; and that workers, consumers, and employers will all gain by elimination of competition,—then, indeed, the socialist has only to demand the logical completion of the journey. There will be no sense in leaving the big corporations to blunder along, sometimes losing, and sometimes hurting society by unwisdom, when society itself can appropriate their plants, direct their labor, make and bear its own blunders, and pocket its own gains.