SOME MORE PRESENT-DAY PREACHING

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 9, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 19.

Read the full edition

SOME MORE PRESENT-DAY PREACHING.

WE have mentioned once or twice the sermons of Dr. Newell Dwight Hillis, of Plymouth church, Brooklyn, formerly of Central church, Chicago. A point has arisen that renders it proper that we should mention another one.
The Chicago Times-Herald each Monday prints, in full, the sermon that at least purports to have been preached the day—Sunday—before. Accordingly, in the Times-Herald of Monday, April 24, is printed what is headlined as “Rev. Newell Dwight Hillis’s Sermon in Plymouth Church;” and is introduced as follows:—
BROOKLYN, APRIL 23.—Rev. Newell Dwight Hillis spoke this morning to the congregation of Plymouth church, on “Happiness and the Victory of Life.” His text was: “Your joy no man taketh from you.” John 16 : 22.
Then follows the sermon. Yet when we have read perhaps a quarter of the way through it, we come to the following:—
Also our daily papers, finding out what the public want and will buy, exhibit the same pessimistic tendency. For weeks and months this city has been rising up and lying down upon a scandal consisting of an alleged murder, a soap-vat, a wagon-load of potash, and a choice assortment of old bones from the stock-yards. All this, too, during the days when the pageantry of autumn has never been more splendid.
This is the first time that we ever heard that the splendid pageantry of autumn is displayed, even in Brooklyn, as late as April 23.
Yet more than this: this sermon preached in Brooklyn says that for weeks and months “this city,”—Brooklyn, bear in mind,—by means of “the daily papers,” “has been rising up and lying down upon a scandal consisting of an alleged murder, a soap-vat, a wagon-load of potash, and a choice assortment of old bones from the stock-yards”!! All this in Brooklyn, according to the sermon; whereas no such thing ever occurred in Brooklyn. The city of Brooklyn never for a day either rose up or lay down upon any such affair.
The literal truth is that the whole matter of the alleged murder, and the soap-vat, and the potash, and the bones from the stock-yards all occurred in Chicago. And Chicago, not Brooklyn, is the city that rose up and lay down on it for weeks and months. It was in the autumn, too, when Chicago did it. In Chicago, a year ago last autumn, there was for a long time the trial of a man by the name of Luetgart, a sausage-maker, who was accused of murdering his wife, and destroying her body with potash, in a soap-vat in his factory. And to pass off all this upon Brooklyn, eighteen months after it occurred in Chicago, “splendid pageantry of autumn” and all, and late in the spring at that, seems rather odd, even among the odd ways of the present-day preaching.
It is possible, of course, that the sermon was written eighteen months ago, when Dr. Hillis was in Chicago, “during the days when the pageantry of autumn” was indeed “splendid;” and when Chicago, not Brooklyn, was “rising up and lying down” upon the matter of the alleged murder, the soap-vat, etc. But even then it is odd that he should publish it as being applicable to Brooklyn, and having the splendid pageantry of autumn in the last week of April.
Would it be impertinent to suggest that it might be well for Dr. Hillis to revise his methods of preaching, or else revise his old sermons?