AdventAI

BOVINE TUBERCULOSIS.

By L. D. House

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 21., May 23, 1899

L. D. HOUSE.

(Hokah, Minn.)

BOVINE Tuberculosis is the title of a bulletin issued by the Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, December, 1896, St. Anthony Park, Minn., from which we take a few extracts. It may be plainly seen from the first extract that the bulletin is not written from a vegetarian standpoint, but to show the value of tuberculin as a test for tuberculosis in cattle, and to suggest means whereby this terrible disease may be stamped out:—

“The history of man and disease has been the history of a long battle, with victory too often on the wrong side; and it is little to the credit of the medical and veterinary professions that no more is being done toward reducing mortality from tuberculosis, and controlling its spread. The subject of tuberculosis is one of such serious importance and large proportions, and is so many sided, that it has become the greatest medical problem of the day. . . .

“Sanitarians are not quarreling with butter, milk, or meat; not with dairymen nor breeders, but wholly with tuberculosis. We can not well do without milk and butter, nor do we wish to do without meat; but let us have them pure and wholesome. No man can do a better thing for his neighbor than to show him truth. There is safety when we see, and danger when we do not. . . . It was charged that tuberculin was inaccurate. . . . Others objected that it was too accurate because it condemned cattle so slightly diseased that it was not worth while to pay any attention to them; or that animals thus slightly diseased ought not to be condemned at all. Others objected on the ground that tuberculosis was evidently so wide-spread and so common among cattle that we could do nothing with it anyway; . . . while still others said the cattle thus condemned were in such fine condition, so sleek and fat, that they could not be seriously diseased. But it soon became evident to those who were making the post-mortems that this was wholly false, and that a cow could be rotten with tuberculosis, and yet apparently be in an ideal condition so far as the eye could read external symptoms. . . . Calves, pigs, and other animals have been infected by feeding, and by inoculations with meat and milk of tuberculous cows; and the reasonable inference is that human beings may be so infected. It is now generally accepted by health officers everywhere that human and bovine tuberculosis are identical, and may be transmitted either way; and that tuberculin gives an accurate diagnosis. . . .

“There is no ground for argument concerning the use of meat and milk from tuberculous cattle . . . . Possibilities of infection through this source have been demonstrated; and good sanitation always says that where there may be danger, there is danger. . . .

“Experiments have been made which demonstrate that meat may be roasted and boiled, and yet the center of large pieces remain infectious. . . . Again, in considering this matter of food products from tuberculous cattle, there come up the difficulty and expense of knowing, with reasonable certainty, that a certain sample of meat or milk does or does not contain the living bacilli.”

From a table contained in the Bulletin we glean the following facts: Native cattle tested in the State, 7.8 per cent. tuberculous; high grades, 10.8 per cent.; pure breeds, 16.6 per cent.; city dairy herds, 10.4 per cent. “Of the total of twenty-seven herds tested, twelve were more or less tuberculous, and the percentages differed from zero to 39.8, the latter being the highest found in any herd thus far tested by this station. Other stations and veterinarians in other States have found much higher percentages than we have found thus far in Minnesota. Many workers elsewhere in this field have found eighty per cent. and ninety per cent. of large herds tuberculous.”

The Bulletin ends with this statement: “The present discussion concerning the type of tuberculous form and general appearance is unfortunate. A great majority of all cows that have been condemned as tuberculous by test, and have been proved to be so on post-mortem, have been cows that no man would select as being tuberculous. On the other hand, the ones with narrow chest, and long, slender face, that we would pick out as probably tuberculous, have repeatedly stood the test.”

The foregoing is but a small amount of the valuable information contained in the Bulletin, and the lesson to be drawn from it is that all kinds of animal products in these last days are liable to contain the germs of this terrible “white plague,” which is the cause of one death in every seven.

We find that city dairy herds are especially liable to infection, over ten per cent. of them having been found tuberculous. Thus, in a herd containing ten cows, one would be apt to have consumption; and if, as is usually the case, the milk is all put together, the liability to infection would be vastly increased. Milk should never be used until subjected to a temperature of 160° F. for half an hour.