THERE is considerable stir being made in the Episcopal church in the United States against Dr. Briggs's being ordained a minister of that church. The opposition is professedly based upon his views of the Bible as set forth in a late book of his, in which he recognizes the existence in Scripture of “myth, and legend, and fiction,” as well as drama and poetry. He holds that “in the story of David are incorporated incompatible legends; the book of Ruth is an idyl; the story of Jonah is a work of the imagination; the stories of Daniel are historical fiction.” However, the Outlook says that this is not the true ground of the opposition to his being ordained an Episcopalian clergyman; because “all this has been said before by eminent scholars in the Church of England,—by Dr. Cheyne, Dr. Driver, Dean Farrar, and others,”—and the Church of England, instead of refusing them its pulpits, “has honored them with its offices, and it would be very surprising if some of their writings are not to be found in the libraries of the very men who wish to exclude Dr. Briggs. . . . The real ground is his distinct and emphatic disavowal of the authority of tradition.” But all the difference here is that while Dr. Briggs disavows the authority of tradition, which is only the authority of other men, he requires that his own authority shall be accepted, not only as to what is the truth of the Scripture, but indeed as to what is the Scripture itself; for when he can set aside as myth, and idyl, and imagination, and legend, and historical fiction, whatever he chooses to disapprove, what is left to be Scripture but what he says? and how shall people know that even this is Scripture except as he says that it is? And that there are many such scholars is only so much the worse.
Episcopal Opposition to Dr. Briggs's Ordination
From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 23., June 6, 1899