Detroit News Tribune, Sunday, April 9, 1899.
“If the trumpet give an uncertain sound, who shall prepare himself to the battle?” asked St. Paul. The pulpiteers of Gotham seem to be giving forth an uncertain sound just now, and there seems to have been more truth than poetry in the Rev. Minot Savage’s recent remark, that “three fourths of the men in New York pulpits are agnostics.”
The New York Sun has been showing up this “confusion of religious thoughts,” which has been given vent to lately by metropolitan preachers. It instances, for example, the Rev. Dr. Van Dyke, supposed to be one of the most orthodox of Presbyterians, and yet, according to him, “the Son of God would have come into the world whether men had sinned or not.” Again, he says, “There are a thousand true doctrines of the atonement;” which the Sun thinks is “substantially the same as saying that no doctrine is specifically true.”
Then, the first sermon of the new pastor of Plymouth church, Dr. Hillis, it says, simply spoke of “the supremacy of Christ among men of genius,” calling Jesus “the supreme literary artist,” and celebrating, the wonderful power of his “imagination”—“nothing of the positive faith which gave the impulse to Christianity.”
Dr. Rainsford is cited also as not believing in the hell of the Scriptures. “Who believes in a material hell?” the reverend doctor asked recently, and the Sun answers, “All Roman Catholic priests of eminence and all orthodox Protestants do.” He does not believe, either, in “the theory of verbal inspiration.” To quote the Sun:—
“He rejected also the ‘physical resurrection of the personal body,’ and said: ‘I do not know any man that does’ believe in it. Yet when he consigns the body of the dead to the grave, the prayer-book requires him to say: ‘We therefore commit his body to the ground; earth to earth, ashes to ashes, dust to dust; looking for the general resurrection in the last day and the life of the world to come, through our Lord Jesus Christ, at whose second coming in glorious majesty to judge the world, the earth and the sea shall give up their dead, and the corruptible bodies of those who shall sleep shall be changed, and made like unto his glorious body.’”
“He repeats this, but he does not believe it, and does ‘not know any man that does.’ It is no wonder that ‘multitudes of people are turning away from the church’ when even its ministers are without belief in it, and insist that it ‘needs readaptation,’ and that changes are required in its ‘ordinances and methods’ to accommodate them to contemporary social tastes and conditions. That sort of preaching Dr. Da Costa, another Episcopal clergyman, calls ‘infidelity,’ and of course infidelity it is.”
The trouble is that this “confusion of religious thought” is not confined to New Yorkp. 391 City, but permeates the Protestant pulpits of every denomination throughout the country. The so-called higher criticism has left its votaries without a rule of faith. They acknowledge neither an infallible church nor an infallible Bible, so they are left to the guidance of their individual consciences, which means simply that every man is a law to himself, and has a perfect right to believe what he likes, and do what seems right in his own eyes; so there is no wonder that the trumpet gives an uncertain sound, or that the people do not know what to do about preparing for the battle.