THE INTELLECTUAL LIFE OF THE CHILD.
By Sarah M. I. Henry
Many are the theories at present rife in the world as to the best route by which to approach the intellect, with its necessary supplies, what to take, and in what manner it shall be served. The way of truth is plain; while the way of speculative science is a perfect tanglewood, in which many honest parents and teachers have been caught, and have become bewildered in its mazes. Some of these have brought their burdens to my notice, and have propounded questions which, in the very asking, showed how far into the wilderness they had been led in their efforts to “keep up with the times.” Sometimes, in an effort to “keep up with the times,” you will be led backward into the Dark Ages; and this case is filled with just such possibility. All these questions have a most straightforward answer in the principles laid down in God’s word, but nowhere else. It will be well for us at this stage of the discussion to stop for a brief view of the situation with which we are confronted. One of the most pathetic episodes of the current year was the effort that a conscientious young mother and teacher was making to find out how to work with her children at home, and with her pupils in school, according to the rule laid down in the “law of suggestion.” She came to me with the question, “What do you think of the law of suggestion, and how would you work it out?” My reply, reduced to a sentence, would be, “I would let it alone: it does not belong to our grade.” I might have added that in the sense in which many use “suggestion,” it is of Satan; for this I fully believe to be the source of hypnotism in every form, and this is what the term “suggestion,” as used in that connection, really means. In the matter of the name, it is a clear case of a wolf in sheep’s clothing, for the purpose of getting in. The true suggestive method in menticulture is one of those simple things of God in nature, which man will do well to recognize at its full value, but which he need not attempt to analyze, tinker, amend, or stop and watch, to see whether or not it will run right on without being wound up by some human device. To amend it would be to ruin it; and this is what has produced hypnotism in all its variations. Hypnotism is an attempt to improve on nature,—a process of forcing a human will into a place which God has himself refused to occupy. It is a usurpation of a power which God surrendered to the individual man at his creation. This phase of the law of suggestion, as pedagogy has formulated it, is just as gross a repudiation of the fact that the life we have is from God as would be a pair of bellows and a windmill for the purpose of respiration. All the efforts to teach by “suggestion” are an exceedingly flimsy makeshift for the method of teaching by the Word of Life. Experience, under divine leading, is the only teacher that understands just how to use suggestion; and any man or woman who undertakes to usurp the place and office of personal experience in teaching will simply waste time and energy for both the teacher and pupil, and have nothing to show for it in the end but perplexity and disappointment. There is nothing to recommend the suggestive method, even if it is considered at its best, wholly aside from the actual dangers which must result from hypnotic interference, and also from those other dangers to which any will so subordinated to another must always be exposed.395 The child gets nothing from it for himself, not even a hint that he can carry away, and use in any independent manner. He is not educated nor trained in any degree, only used. The “teacher,” so-called, brings an arbitrary force to bear, under the power of which the child thinks,—if he does really think, I am not sure of that, but at least he acts, without any free volition or choice, according to the thinking of the teacher. A true, helpful hint might sometimes be a good thing to intellect, but the divine Teacher alone can get near enough to intellect to administer hints in any practical way; and he alone knows how to translate a hint into an idea so as to make it intelligible. The hint which the teacher of this suggestive school would throw upon the sensitive film of the child-mind is so arbitrary that even if it seems to develop all right, and come out in clear-cut action, it can no more be considered as a part of intellect than the photograph is considered as a part of the camera. Intellect must have its own way with every hint, suggestion, and fact, or it will not take it up at all; and the true teacher must learn that the translation which intelligence makes of any suggestion may differ as widely in appearance from that which was given it to work upon, as Chinese or Hebrew differs in appearance from English. It may mean almost the same; but there will be shades of difference, which would make a literal translation back into the original so different as to make you smile or weep, maybe drive you to despair of making that child what you had hoped. A truly educated child will be himself, and not a copy of any teacher; and any suggestion that he has taken up and used will be returned in such form as to prove that it has been retouched by a living, distinct, independent intelligence, with a will and way of its own. The stars were all lighted from the same great sun, but one star differs from another. The flowers of the field are all produced out of the same elements, but each has an individuality of its own, which intensifies the beauty of all. A bouquet of paper or wax flowers, all cut out by the same machinery, may be all alike. They may be even beautiful to the first glance, but their absolute changeless likeness to one another makes them very tiresome; and nothing in human manifestation is so wearying as the continual acting out, on the part of one individual, of those things that you know originated in the thought of another. “A copyist,” you say, and at once lose any interest that you may have had in his most brilliant performance. Even an actor must have individuality in his acting, or the world has no use for him.