AdventAI

QUESTIONS VERSUS QUESTIONS.

By Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 24., June 13, 1899

THOSE who have become convinced that the seventh day of each week is the day to be devoted to rest from all secular labor, and to the specific worship of the Lord, often, and very properly, ask those who zealously, but as we think, not according to knowledge, contend that the first day of the week is the day to be observed in this manner, for this purpose, these questions:—

  1. Where is there one instance in which any divine being is said to have rested on Sunday, to make it in any sense a rest day?
  2. Where is there one text which states that the first day of the week was ever blessed or made holy by any being capable of endowing it with that character?
  3. Where is there one text which gives the first intimation that a divine law was ever given for the religious observance of that day?
  4. Where is there one text which shows that Christ or any of his disciples ever observed that day as a Sabbath, or so taught any one to do?

These questions, the reader will observe, all involve elements which are absolutely vital to the existence of a Sabbatic institution; and where none of them can be sustained in behalf of a day, it is utterly futile to claim that day as a Sabbath, on any Bible ground. These questions can not be answered in behalf of Sunday, and no such texts in its support can be found. What, then, is the status of Sunday as a religious institution?

But some advocates of Sunday Sabbatism, not content, seemingly, to make no response, imagine they can work the Yankee method of offsetting one question by asking another, to nullify the significance of the facts stated; and they therefore proceed to ask a series of counter questions, not indeed touching the observance of Sunday, but in reference to the obligation of the seventh day, intending to show that that day is not binding on Christians. But even if this could be done, if it could be shown that the seventh day has no standing in court, what would that do in behalf of Sunday?—Nothing at all. Yet some seem to suppose that they can ask some “unanswerable questions” in reference to the seventh day, as damaging to that institution as the questions here asked in reference to Sunday are fatal to its claims. Then, having asked the hard questions, hard, as they suppose, in regard to the seventh day, they regard the questions in regard to Sunday as counteracted, and think that they have put the seventh day in a hole, and the Sunday on the throne. No thinker will greatly admire such logic, nor be much influenced by it.

There is also another point which they do not seem to perceive; it is this: None of the questions we ask about the Sunday can be answered at all; but those which they ask about the seventh day can all be easily and clearly answered, as a few specimens will show. Here is one which all our readers will recognize as the sentiment held by many of the opponents of the seventh day: “Please show us, from the Holy Scriptures, where any man from Adam to the exodus of the children of Israel out of Egypt, was commanded to keep the seventh-day Sabbath.”

This can be done easily enough. We have but to read Gen. 2:3. That plainly states, as a direct and unvarnished narrative, that after the first six days of time had passed, God rested on the seventh day, blessed it, and sanctified it. We now ask just one thought upon this word “sanctify:” What does the word mean? Any concordance, Bible dictionary, or lexicon will give the answer. To “sanctify” anything means to set that thing apart to a holy, sacred, or religious use. The record, then, is that God, in the beginning, set apart the seventh day to a holy, sacred, or religious use. How could a day be set apart to a sacred use? It could be thus set apart, only by telling some one to use it in a sacred and religious way; that is, for sacred purposes. Who was told to use the seventh day in this manner?—The ones, of course, for whom it was made; and that, our Saviour says, was man: “The Sabbath was made for man.” Adam and Eve were the only human beings then on the earth. Adam and Eve, then, were told by God to use the seventh day in a holy and religious way. And what way was that?—Just the way, exactly, that is enjoined in the fourth commandment. And whom did Adam and Eve represent?—They were the federal head of the whole human family, who were to spring from them. But was this entire arrangement to stop with them? Was this Sabbath law which they had, telling them how to use the seventh day, to go no further?—It must have been intended for all whom they represented; for in no other way could man, in a generic sense, have it. And it was true in the case of Adam, as it has been ever since a uniform and perpetual rule, that any truth committed to the head of a family is to be transmitted to all the members of that family. And yet some are so slow of perception, or so inattentive in their study of this subject, as to ask the question now under consideration: “Where was any man, from Adam to Moses, commanded to keep the seventh-day Sabbath?”

Another assertion commonly met with, is this: “Show us where, by divine authority, any nation or people, except the Jews, or their proselytes, were commanded to observe the seventh-day Sabbath.”

This question is the same as the one already noticed, only spread out to a nation, instead of being confined to an individual; and the answer already given, answers this sufficiently for all practical purposes. A word of recapitulation will show this. The Sabbath, being given to Adam, the father of the human family, was, of course, given, through him, to all his posterity; and this meets the statement of our Lord, “The Sabbath was made for man.” The word “man,” as noticed, being used in its generic sense, includes the whole human family, all men. “Jews and their proselytes” certainly do not include all men. And as we have seen, the observance of the seventh day rested on an explicit commandment from the Lord; hence all men, not Jews alone, were under commandment to keep it. It ought not to be necessary to show, by a process of reasoning, that other people besides the Jews were under obligation to keep the seventh-day Sabbath.

But, further, the fourth commandment itself shows that the Sabbath is of universal obligation. After saying, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy man servant, nor thy maid servant, nor thy cattle,” it then continues in these words: “nor thy stranger that is within thy gates.” Were these “strangers” Jews or their proselytes?—Certainly not. They might have come from every nation under heaven; but the command was just the same for every one, no matter from what nation he came. Now if it was their duty to keep the Sabbath whenever they came in contact with that people, the Jews, whom God had set apart for himself, were they not under just as much obligation to keep it wherever they might be? In other words, did any moral obligation originate from association with the Jewish people, so that men would be bound by such obligations while they were with the Jews, but be released from those moral duties when they were away?—No one will endure upon such a position. Therefore when we are asked to show where any people but the Jews were commanded to keep the seventh-day Sabbath, we have but to refer to the fourth commandment itself. So simple and easy is it to meet the objections that are urged against the seventh day. And besides the fourth commandment, we may also refer to such scriptures as Gen. 2:3; Mark 2:27, and Isaiah 56, in answer to this question.

There is another sophism so persistently used, that it should not, perhaps, be passed by. It is formulated in this language:—

“Put your finger on the passage which tells us when and where God took away the penalty for the violation of the seventh-day Sabbath, and did not take away the day itself; and still further, if the penalty still remains in force, what would be the result now, as regards Sabbath-day keepers, in general?”

That the enmity men bear to the Sabbath is so all-absorbing that they can think of no other commandment except the Sabbath to which the same conditions apply, is indeed strange. Against this objection a retort might fairly be made, as follows: “Put your finger on the passage where God took away the penalty for idolatry (a penalty stated in Deut. 13:6–10), and did not take away the law itself.” But that penalty is done away, as much as the penalty against Sabbath-breaking. Would any one have us now believe that men are just as much at liberty to violate the law against idolatry as they are to violate the law against breaking the Sabbath? And so it may be said in reference to all the ten commandments; for the death penalty was attached to the violation of each and all of them under the Mosaic system. The infliction of the death penalty by the hand of the magistrate is now taken away; and shall we therefore say that the commandments are all taken away too? According to the doctrine under notice, we must. Then men may go after other gods, worship idols, blaspheme, lie, steal, commit adultery, etc., because the death penalty against these things is not now inflicted. If all this is not so, then let no such argument any more be used against the Sabbath.

But a passage is called for; it is at hand. Whoever attaches so much importance to putting his finger on the passage, let him put his finger on Col. 2:14–17. The death penalty was attached to the violation of the ten commandments, simply as those commandments were made a part of the civil constitution of the Jewish people, under the theocracy. But the peculiar regulations attached to the law in this relation, occupying temporarily this subordinate position, did not affect the law at all, in its independent position as the moral law of God; nor did it alter the relation of the people to that law, in that office, as expressing the will of the Creator in reference to man, the creature. Col. 2:14–17 states that that whole Mosaic economy, the ceremonial and civil constitution of that dispensation, with all that was typical and shadowy connected with it, has passed away. But that did not affect the moral law at all, nor our relation and obligation to it; for no part of that moral law ever was, or is, in the least degree, typical or shadowy.

U. S.