We have received, from a correspondent, a clipping from the Investigator, an infidel paper of Boston, with the request that the statements of the clipping be replied to, for the benefit of a puzzled believer.
Considering the source from which the extract is taken, the reader can very easily form an idea of the nature of what is said. It is a tirade against the word of God, and the dealings of God with his people, in the usual style of such writings, which show a studied effort to see how much bitterness, reproach, and insult can be condensed into every syllable against God and his course toward men; and with what boldness and dare-devil spirit of abandoned mockery it can be expressed. Now, we know that the world is full of just such spirits, and that they will, with great diligence and persistence, ply their vocation, especially in the last days. Therefore no believer should be puzzled by their course; for we have been fully instructed in the word of God, and warned against their work.
Perhaps, however, it is not the fact that such men are to be found, but rather some of the sentiments they utter, which constitutes the puzzle; for there is one short paragraph underscored, for consideration. The writer is trying to heap reproach upon Moses; and to this end, refers to the time when he was up in the mount the first time, just after God had spoken the commandments from Sinai; and when the people strangely became impatient at the delay of Moses to come down, and there, while the mount still trembled under the presence of Jehovah, and while the plain injunctions of the first and second commandments were still ringing in their ears, deliberately turned their back on God, and caused the golden calf to be set up, and chose that as their god who had brought them up out of Egypt, and which should lead them back again; and when Moses came down, and, overwhelmed at the magnitude of their guilt, cast the tables down and broke them, and called upon all who were on the Lord's side to rally to his standard, and the result was that about three thousand of the guilty men were slain. This man lifts his hands in holy horror at such brutality and cruelty, and gives vent to his feelings, as follows:—
It was a terrible sin to worship a calf made of gold, but a great and holy deed to murder three thousand men in cold blood. This is Bible morality.
These men, in their own minds and feelings, have so lowered, and limited, and degraded, the Lord Jehovah, that it seems impossible for them to attach any guilt to the most daring rebellion and insult raised against him, and heaped upon his name and government. Hence the apostasy and rebellion of Israel count for nothing with them; but the least move on the part of God to vindicate his authority, and arrest in its beginning an evil that was sure to bring wide-spread disaster and ruin, and defeat the whole work he had in view,—that is awful in the extreme!
Why does not this astute reasoner, who can so nicely balance moral relations and obligations, turn his weapons against his own government, and reproach and scoff at the civil and military discipline, which they find it so necessary to maintain, even at the cost of life? For instance, let him shift the charge to the affairs of human life, and say: “It is a terrible sin for a soldier on guard, overcome by overwork and the utter exhaustion of his physical nature, to fall asleep, but a great and holy deed when he is court-martialed and shot—murdered in cold blood—for his unfaithfulness.” Again, he might say, “It is a terrible sin when a soldier, tired of his bloody work, and army hardships and burdens, concludes quietly to slip away; in other words, to desert. But when he is caught, and brought before the army, and shot,—deliberately murdered in cold blood,—that is a great and holy deed.” Does not he know, as every one else knows, that under some circumstances the severest measures must be resorted to, to maintain discipline, as the only barrier against otherwise impending ruin?
The apostasy of Israel at the time referred to, if unchecked, would very soon have rendered that whole mighty host wholly uncontrollable, and would have wrought havoc and ruin, which would have cost the lives of many times the three thousand that were slain, and defeated the whole plan and effort of God in bringing Israel, as his people, out of Egypt, and planting them in Canaan. So, sleeping on guard when the interests of the whole army are in one's keeping, and desertion from the service of one's country, in some season of crisis and peril, must be summarily suppressed, if there is to be any army or government. But this is only rebellion against human authority; what must it be, then, when it is against divine authority, which is as much higher than human as the heavens are higher than the earth?
To maintain just and righteous discipline, and arrest festering and death-working evils, even if to do so causes some of the guilty parties to perish, is not murder, but mercy,—mercy to the many more who would otherwise perish. There is nothing in this problem that need puzzle one, if he will look at the bearing and relation of the acts in question, and look at their inevitable results, and judge of their character accordingly. Judged by this standard, God will be found righteous in all his ways, and the song the redeemed at last will sing will be vindicated: “Great and marvelous are thy works, Lord God Almighty; just and true are thy ways, thou King of saints.” Rev. 15: 3. U. S.