THE CHRISTIAN ENDEAVOR CONVENTION AT DETROIT

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 1, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 31.

Read the full edition

THE CHRISTIAN ENDEAVOR CONVENTION AT DETROIT.

One movement among the Endeavorers is certainly commendable, and that is what is known as the “Tenth Legion.” Commenting on this organization, President Clark said:—
“The Christian Endeavor ‘Tenth Legion’ now numbers fourteen thousand seven hundred members, who are giving not less than one tenth of their incomes to God. This is an increase of over four thousand members since we met in Nashville. But you are no more satisfied with that growth than I am. Let’s work for ten thousand new members this year. When the proper proportion of our rank and file is marching under the banner, ‘Render . . . unto God the things that are God’s,’ such a dilemma as a missionary board in debt, or a young student volunteer equipped for service, but prevented from reaching the front because of lack of funds, will never be known.”
Commenting on the tithing system, the general lack of money for the carrying forward of religious and missionary work, and the subterfuges too often resorted to for raising funds, another speaker very pertinently remarked:—
“We have our church fairs, and for one dollar’s worth of material and one dollar’s worth of work the ladies try to get $1.50 from some rich outsider. We have given great dinners and gorged our stomachs for Christ’s sake, at twenty-five cents a gorge, all to make some rich old fellow loosen up with his twenty-five cents.”
Among the good things briefly said at the convention are the following:—
“Soda-water preaching, with its foam and fizz, may be all right for the ‘dilettante’ and the élite, but we need the water of life for the thirsty soul.”
“What I want to see is reality in religion, and not mere professions of godliness. I want to see secular life so permeated with loftiness of purpose, with height of thought, that it will matter not how humble a man’s pursuit is, he will be respected by all his fellows. Better one ounce of real Christian thought and ideal than one hundred tons of empty outward show.”
“If small churches and many churches have any justification, it is the increase of opportunity to reach the unit. The church needs to make this emphasis. The power of the pastor is in danger of being forgotten amid the glamor and éclat of pulpit oratory, in the presence of immense congregations. The pastorate is, I am sure, too much neglected. The poor and the sick are not visited as they once were. The divine process is ‘one soul at a time.’”
“One of the last things in the world that people will acknowledge belongs to God is money. They speak of my house, my corner lot, my bank account. If they use these words with the thought of ‘mine to administer,’ it is all right.”
“There is not one thing in all God’s word that commands me or your pastor to be a better man, to have a higher kind of conduct, than the man who rides out here on this car, than the man who works down-town in the hotel. There is only one standard of conduct for the whole wide world, and that is to live the life that Jesus lived.”
“Unless one has innate grace, goodness of heart, and a pure mind, in fact, has God in him and with him, humbles himself to seek lovingly his Saviour, and does not expect to be sought after, he must needs stop and think. Yet none is so poor, so lowly, so commonplace, but if he will only humble himself, he can hope for the blessing divine.”
Notwithstanding all the good things said at the convention, and the good things there reported to have been accomplished by the organization, in the mind of one who is candidly seeking to learn the truth regarding the Christian Endeavor movement, there must arise certain serious questionings as to the real moral and spiritual uplift which it signifies; as to the validity of the claims made by its general officers as to membership, activity in Christian service; and its general efficiency in promoting the cause of Christ throughout the world.
It is evident that at these conventions every possible effort is made to make the greatest possible show of numbers, enthusiasm, and devotion. Not only is cheering freely permitted at the services, but if the audience does not make a sufficiently noisy demonstration in favor of some sentiment or speaker, the officials often call for a second effort. Then, too, at nearly every large meeting the delegates were strongly urged to sing gospel songs at any time of night or day they might be passing to and fro through the city on the street-cars.
The real consecration of Christian Endeavor members throughout the world may be fairly judged, in a measure at least, by the number who conform to the Scriptural rule of tithing. The claimed membership throughout the world is 3,500,000, and yet of this vast army, only 14,700, according to President Clark, are systematically “rendering unto the Lord his own.”
But that which most causes the observer seriously to question the general claims made in behalf of the Christian Endeavor movement, is the wholly unwarranted figures given out by the general officers, at the conclusion of the convention, as to the attendance of delegates. Throughout the entire week the highest estimate made by railway officials and others capable of judging of the number of visitors in Detroit on account of the convention, was 15,000. These figures included hundreds, and probably thousands, who simply took advantage of the low rates to visit the city, and were not, and never had been, members of the Endeavor organization. Yet on Monday, President Clark sent a message to President McKinley conveying to him the greetings of “twenty-eight thousand Christian Endeavorers” in convention, and at both the large tents practically the same misleading and extravagant figures were given out.
In the morning papers giving these wholly unwarranted figures of the Endeavor officials, the report of the joint railway agent, Frank E. Snow, showed that up to that time only five thousand Endeavor Convention tickets had been executed in his office, and that six thousand three hundred tickets of the same kind had been placed on deposit, making a total of less than eleven thousand. Two more days were allowed for depositing tickets, and no doubt that, during that time, two or three thousand more tickets were placed in the hands of the joint agent.
In this connection a statement contained in the next morning’s Tribune is of interest:—
“‘I never saw such brazen-faced estimates in my life,’ said Blaine Gavett, of the D., G. R. & W., in horror. ‘We put on no specials, we carried no delegations, we did but an individual business. Our returns show seven hundred and fifty persons traveled on Christian Endeavor rates during the convention. But if the Michigan Central carried eight thousand five hundred, we carried fifteen hundred; and if the Grand Trunk carried seven thousand five hundred, we carried twenty-five hundred. You can’t tell me that this convention filled the city anything like others we have had here. There have been crowds in Detroit before. Exclusive of the few carried by the suburban car-lines, I should say that the total number of visitors to the city was between thirteen and fourteen thousand.’”
Just how twenty-eight thousand people, and all Christian Endeavorers, came to Detroit on less than fifteen thousand tickets might be quite an endeavor for President Clark to explain.
If other “official” figures given out by the managers of the General Society of Christian Endeavor are no more reliable than are those relating to attendance at the Detroit convention, they are worth but very little. J. C. BARTHOLF.