FEEDING ON ASHES

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 27, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 26.

Read the full edition

FEEDING ON ASHES.

Now let us turn to Emerson. Prophet Mills’s idea of him is probably best expressed in the following portion of a character sketch of Emerson, taken from a popular text-book on American literature. It says: “Emerson was that rare phenomenon, a type of pure human innocence. He neither did, nor was tempted to do, evil. The experience that reveals to a man that he is a compact of evil, from which only God’s mercy can rescue him,—in religious parlance, regeneration,—was as unknown to Emerson as to an infant a year old. The voice of conscience, convicting of sin, and calling to repentance, was never heard in his soul. He was never other than spontaneously good.” Again, “He could not allow that Christ was more than a man, because he believed any man capable of being a Christ.”
Little comment on these extracts is needed. A thoughtful reading, especially of the portions we have italicized, will suffice. The sum of Emerson’s character and teachings, according to these modern prophets, is: He was naturally angelic and sinless; he never broke the law of God; he felt and taught that there is no need of Christ. And this is the chaff on which the world is being fed. Verily this is feeding on ashes.
But this whole world-wide movement is demonstrably only the rankest Spiritualism. It would be easy to produce page after page, column upon column, of this latter-day preaching, and then turn to the chapter on “Spiritualism,” in “Great Controversy,” and lay the finger on passage after passage that identifies this preaching as the incoming flood of the final great world-delusion. Let one or two examples from the foregoing extracts suffice: In the account of this vision, Dr. Burke says, “I saw that all men are immortal [Spiritualism]; that the foundation principle of the world, of all the worlds, is what we call love.” Turn now to “Great Controversy,” page 554: “He [Satan] appeals to the reason by the presentation of elevating themes, he delights the fancy with enrapturing scenes, and he enlists the affections by his eloquent portrayals of love and charity.”
Take again the belief of Emerson, that “any man is capable of being a Christ,” and compare it with the sentiment shown, at the bottom of page 554, to be Spiritualism: “And another declares, ‘Any just and perfect being is Christ.’” Once more: All these writers represent man as progressive, as approximating nearer and nearer to Godlikeness. Compare with the following from “Great Controversy,” same page: “Spiritualism teaches that man is the creature of progression; that it is his destiny from his birth to progress, even to eternity, toward the Godhead.”
We must enlarge our idea of what constitutes Spiritualism: it is more than rappings, and slate-writings, and mediumistic trances, and séance manifestations. Thousands who would utterly repudiate these are as truly Spiritualists as those that accept them. Swedenborg was a Spiritualist, so was Emerson, so was Whitman, so is B. Fay Mills, T. De Witt Talmage, J. Minot Savage, and the great majority of the popular writers and preachers of the day. Spiritualism is as varied as the dispositions of men. “To the self-indulgent, the pleasure-loving, the sensual, Spiritualism presents itself under a less subtle disguise than to the more refined and intellectual; in its grosser forms they find that which is in harmony with their inclinations.” “He excites the imagination to lofty flights.”
There is a most subtle temptation of Spiritualism, which comes as a psychic phenomenon to many, and yet again and again I have seen professed Seventh-day Adventists fall before it. I would to God that I could reveal this with an inspired pen, as plainly as I see it, and as I have seen its workings and results. The genesis of the temptation, as I have watched it, comes, as it did to Eve, in a longing for a wider, larger, higher sphere of knowledge, attainment, and activity. It is the individual expressing the spirit of the age for “broader conceptions” of man and nature, of the brotherhood of all men, the unity of all religions and creeds—Brahmanism, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Catholicism, and Protestantism. While it speaks in the name of more liberal sympathy, of universal brotherhood, it insinuates that the professing of the doctrines of any one church is a very narrow field, and restrictive not only of one’s influence for good, but of what he may accomplish and become. It is, therefore, most insidious flattery and a hidden attraction to personal ambition.
Such persons soon manifest an impatience of what seems to them the narrow limits of present truth. At first they may not themselves be able to say at just what point the restriction lies, but there is a secret discontent, a longing for what they deem would be a larger usefulness and attainment, and for broader intellectual culture. Not that these things are wrong in themselves, be it understood; but it is the spirit which accompanies the desire, as with the desire of our first parents to partake of the tree of knowledge, and to become as gods in any way and at any cost.
Perhaps an instance which I met while a student in Battle Creek College will illustrate to some extent. There was in school an intelligent young man. He was thoroughly conversant with present truth, and accepted it fully. The first indication I had that the temptation was upon him was in some rather incidental criticisms on the inadequacy of our college course. Soon there was added to these a desire to leave school, and enter some “higher” institution of learning,—not that this would not have been right if he had first obtained all that our college could give him; but this he had not done. I soon saw that connected with this was a desire to get out into the world, though he himself probably had no idea of giving up the faith, and to try his fortunes on “broader” lines than work in the message. A poem which he wrote at the time, but of which I remember only a stanza, presented something of his condition of mind. The stanza is:—
“What should I see if I should go Over the mountains high? Perhaps there is nothing but drifting snow Over the mountains high.”
“The mountains high” were doubtless presented to him by the adversary as the narrow limits of his belief. I loved the boy, and as the parent watches the son who, “youth’s gay spring-time scarcely knowing,” ventures forth to seek his fortune in the wide world, so I saw him go. Do not wonder that this stanza bears to me a mournful burden. Yes, he went. He entered a State university, he formed a bond of friendship with a lady not of his faith, he was graduated with good standing; but I was not surprised to get a letter from him in which he said that he could not agree with our people any longer on certain points; he had gone beyond the “mountains high.” He is now possessed only of worldly ambition. Sad indeed is this recollection to me; but sadder the fact that so few of our dear young people realize the strength of this deceitful temptation.
There is another case I will mention: A family consisting of the parents and three or four children lived in Battle Creek. They were friends of mine. I called on them frequently. It seemed to me that I never saw a woman more truly devout and more firmly established in the message than the wife and mother. One day, while making a call at their home, I was emphasizing the fact that each person must be led for himself by the Spirit of God. But when laying stress upon the matter of individual judgment and personal guidance, I noticed she assented with unusual stress. She said she had been thinking of the same thing herself. But I soon discerned that what she understood by following the “inward law,” the “voice within,” the “low whisper,” was something quite different from following the Spirit of truth. She manifested the same longings for “broader” influence on the world, for “larger” activity, for more “liberal” culture, that were shown by the young man just mentioned. Dissatisfaction was entertained, criticism indulged, airy plans were laid to give her children the advantages of university education, but—she left the truth. Not long after, she doubted whether there ever had been a Jesus Christ.
This is all a phase of Satan’s work through the power and influence of Spiritualism, as can be plainly seen by a perusal of the chapter on that subject in “Great Controversy.”
Thus the world is feeding upon ashes, led astray by a deceived heart. Never before in the history of the world were truth and error so much alike; never were temptations more subtle. When these are from without,—rebuffs, reproaches, persecutions,—or even of a sensual nature—pleasure, appetite, passion,—they are usually easily discerned; but when they come as psychic phenomena, mental states, moods, and the like, they are most dangerous. Nothing but the soul in full surrender to God will escape them. The devil can work on the feelings; God impresses the conscience.
J. A. L. DERBY.
(To be concluded.)