SPIRITUALISTS SURPRISED

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 22, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 34.

Read the full edition

SPIRITUALISTS SURPRISED.

A Methodist has astonished Spiritualism in his disbelief of the Bible, as is shown by the following from the Banner of Light, the leading Spiritualist paper in the United States:—
According to Rev. S. P. Cadman, an eminent Methodist clergyman, the following Bible stories may be honestly doubted: Creation in six days; Methuselah’s life of nine hundred and sixty-nine years; the whale and Jonah; crossing the Red Sea; Eve and the snake; Joshua and the sun; tower of Babel; Lot’s wife and the pillar of salt; the flood; Aaron’s rod turned into a serpent; translation of Elijah; the fiery furnace of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abed-nego. Well, well, well!!
This summing up of the belief, or unbelief, of Dr. Cadman is doubtless taken from the newspaper reports of his address, on the sixth of last March, before a congregation composed of four hundred Methodist preachers, of whom the largest part loudly applauded him, and accepted his words as the doctrines of their church. He afterward said that the reporters had not correctly represented him, and gave out a “revised” interview, from which we quote the following:—
I said, and I thoroughly believe, that the absolute inerrancy and infallibility of the Bible are no longer possible of belief among reasoning men. . . . Half the pages of the Old Testament are of unknown authorship, and the New Testament contains contradictions.
On his address there was much comment by the press at the time. The Outlook said:—
The reception of this paper shows that there is in the Methodist communion a large number of people who would be almost panic-stricken by such a simple statement of facts concerning the Bible as all scholarly students accept, and, on the other hand, that there are many among the ministry and professors of the Methodist Episcopal Church whose eyes are open, and who are not at all afraid to tell the people the conclusions to which a reverent and thorough study of the origins of the Sacred Scriptures inevitably lead.
The Michigan Christian Advocate said:—
Methodism is not committed to the unwise and non-progressive attitude concerning inspiration, which has so embarrassed certain other churches.
A prominent Boston paper of the Methodist denomination expressed the following:—
The Bible is the livest and most agitating of books. It is the leaven that is constantly working in and upon the human mind. Its truths must be turned over and readjusted to every new generation. The results of the profound and universal study of this Book are in the air. Our ministers, especially our young men and those older men who are intellectually receptive and studious, are familiar, as they ought to be, with the results of this searching scrutiny. That is why the three hundred ministers applauded Dr. Cadman’s especially frank and honest utterances. It is useless, as it is insincere, to try to check this devout study of the Scriptures, or to brand it as something wrong.
While these Methodists, including Dr. Cadman, are perhaps not yet ready to say they doubt all the events mentioned in our first quotation, yet the doubts he did calmly acknowledge in the revised interview, and which his brethren applauded at the time they were uttered, and which they vindicated in their prominent papers afterward, are enough to cause surprise on the part of Spiritualists. No wonder they are encouraged to make light of the word of God when they have such prominent companions.
We wonder how much further Dr. Cadman and his associates will have to go to become Spiritualists indeed. The Spiritualists’ belief in the immortality of the soul will not stand in their way, as they already doubt the inspired words, which say: “God only hath immortality.” There can really be nothing in the Scriptures in the way; for when a man once says that portions of the Scriptures are untrue, he can easily bring himself to believe that any particular portion is untrue, which may stand in the way of any step he may wish to take. Truly “the world moves,” but which way?
H. E. S.