AdventAI

THE SEAMY SIDE OF LABOR.

By Antoinette Byrant Hervey

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 36., September 5, 1899

Antoinette Byrant Hervey, in Outlook.

Dr. MAXWELL, superintendent of schools of Greater New York, has been invited to address the chamber of commerce on the subject of commercial education in the city of New York. In preparation for this address he has written to leading merchants and manufacturers, asking their opinions as to the merits and defects of the training received by the boys and girls who enter mercantile or manufacturing establishments from the public schools. He has inquired in regard to their obedience, industry, accuracy, thrift, etc., and has asked if boys and girls of foreign birth and education are superior to American boys and girls in preparation for mercantile and manufacturing life.

While merchants and manufacturers are furnishing data for the city superintendent, it may be in order for a humble housekeeper to bear record to the defects — whether due to education or not — of those workers upon whose efficiency and faithfulness the comfort of homes and home-makers so largely depends.

Not long ago we took an apartment, and wished to get things settled as promptly as possible. It had fallen to me to secure the needed co-operation of draymen, plumbers, shopkeepers, and men of like vocation. Every man whom I engaged promised to do work at once; yet only one man kept his promise. When an expressman agreed to bring freight, it took three trips to his office to get him started; and when we sent him for a trunk, he brought a box. The man who was to repair a bookcase “immediately” did so only after three journeys to his shop. The gas-range, which was to be ready for use on Friday, gave us our first dinner on the following Tuesday. A kitchen table of marvelous appurtenances — the delight of the maid — was delivered with a big gouge in the top, and it required six letters and two visits to the store to effect a change; a washstand came broken; a mattress arrived dirty; a bureau, due on Saturday, came on the following Saturday, in spite of three letters written in the meantime; one bed came a day late, one three days late, and one a week late, and two mattresses were two inches too wide and five inches too long; one set of kitchen utensils reached us three days late, after two trips to the store, and another set was driven home by the use of two letters and a postal. The brooms, pails, and scrubbing-brushes for cleaning the apartment were kept from wear, because they came after the apartment was cleaned. I refrain from mentioning the constant blunders in the delivery of groceries.

The apartment itself, which was a beautiful one, and new, showed many signs of careless work. In our fine bath-room the plumber had put the faucets on wrong, so that the cold-water faucet read “hot,” and the hot-water faucet read “cold.” When I called his attention to it, hep. 571 said, musingly, “I can change it, but then the words would come on the under side.” “That does n’t matter,” I replied, with a mixture of hot and cold in my speech; “we can easily stand on our heads in the tub to read them.”

These repeated instances of unreliability, carelessness, and stupidity led me to recall the experiences of the last few years. The most arrant case of red-tape incompetence occurred a few years ago in the putting up of some curtain-rods. First there was sent, to measure the windows, Man No. 1. The next day Man No. 2 came to put the rods up. The mistress of the house was out, but she had left word that they were to be put one inch inside of the Venetian blinds. When she returned, the careful maid met her at the door, saying, “The man would n’t put them where you said. He put them four inches inside the blinds, marred the woodwork badly, and did not bring enough rods for the windows.” I immediately telephoned to the firm, and received the message, “We will send a man right down to inspect the work.” After waiting two days for the man, I went to the store, and had an interview with a bland gentleman, who promised to send a man at once. The next day Man No. 2 came smilingly on the scene, looked at the work, and decided that Man No. 2 must return and correct his blunders. The next day Man No. 2 appeared, and moved the rods, hacking the woodwork so that I reported him, and asked that the damage be repaired. The following day Man No. 4 arrived, was grieved that we should be so troubled, and said he would send a man to make everything satisfactory. Two days elapsed, when a blundering old Irishman, Man No. 5, arrived, bringing a can of white paint, and a can of red stuff, which he afterward said was aniline dye. The last room he visited was a bedroom; and when he left, you could play hare and hounds with him, and trace him out of the house and all the way back to the store. In the room he had spilled the dye on the window-sill, table-spread, and rug, and then had dripped it all along through the private hall, the main hall, the elevator, and out the front door.

Enraged, I went at once to the store, where I received a courteous expression of sympathy, and an assurance that the damage would be remedied. In two days more the same many-thumbed Irishman returned, bringing a bottle of benzine and cleaning-rags. Then followed a vigorous mopping in and spreading out of red dye. I entered the bedroom to find the man’s wet rags lying on a chair, although he had been given paper to use. He had cleaned (?) the rug, had it all up in a wad, and was standing on the wet heap, while he worked at the table-spread. When I remonstrated, he said, “Lady, I have swiped that up good.” “But you must not stand on it in that way,” I protested. Thereupon his Irish blood arose, and he yelled, “You go out of this room, and leave me alone.” It soon became evident that one of us must leave the house, and, as I seemed to have a prior claim, I asked the Irishman to go. He stubbornly refused, and not until I sent for the engineer of the house did he depart.

This little episode led to another visit to headquarters, where the pleasing assurance was given that a man would be sent to inspect. One day later bland gentleman No. 6 came to inspect, regret, sympathize, and promise to send a man. Men — of their kind — seemed to be plentiful, and the next day No. 7 walked proudly in, carrying a bottle of cleaning-fluid. His air of self-confidence dwindled as soon as he looked at the rug, and he said that he could do nothing, that the rug must be sent to a cleaner. One week elapsed, and Man No. 8 arrived, and took the rug. Another week rolled by, when the rug was returned, in sadder plight than ever. Then followed more visits to the store, letters, promises, until we were worn out by our four-weeks’ bustle, and, counting the cost of postage, shoe-leather, and nerves, we let the matter drop. This fiasco is charged to the account of one of the largest stores in Harlem.

Another experience, showing the incompetence of workmen, also illustrated one of the annoying phases of labor — the apparently well-arranged scheme of heads of firms to hang on to jobs and increase the time occupied in performing work. In a former apartment our range was out of order. The landlord sent for a man to repair it. After three-days’ waiting a man arrived on the scene, looked the range over, and said, “Yes, we can do it.” “Do it, then,” said I. “Oh! I don’t do it. I only came to view the job. A man will come to-morrow to do the work.” The next morning brought joyful expectations, for a man arrived carrying a kit of tools. These he deposited in the middle of the kitchen floor, and started to go out; but I planted myself in front of the door, and said, defiantly, “Where are you going?” “Why, I’m not going to do the job to-day,” he said, with an injured air; “I only brought my tools.” The next day the workman returned, worked two hours, and then departed, saying, “I’ve got to finish a job in Christopher street.” The kitchen was black from ceiling to floor. The neat maid could not stand that, so she spent the afternoon cleaning. The next day the man returned, finished the job, and she cleaned again; but, alas! the stove was no better. After having that stove under treatment for three months, the repairer declared that he could bake in it all right, if I couldn’t. I took him at his word, told him I would make a cake, and he should bake. Even now I can see the perspiration on the man’s face after he had baked thin layer-cakes an hour and a half, and they came out white and doughy on the bottom.

One could endure the delays and broken promises if work were well done, but only in exceptional cases is work done faithfully and well.

As I was meditating on these things, a carpenter came to our apartment on an errand of mercy. When I called his attention to the fact that but few of our windows would shut down properly, and that all were chipping little bits of wood out of the sills, he opened his heart to me, and said: “These are degenerate days. Everything is growing worse. I have been a carpenter in New York for fifteen years, and my work is not nearly as good as at the start. One can’t do his work well. I work eight hours a day now, and do more work than I did in twelve hours ten years ago. If a fellow doesn’t do it, he loses his job. We all have to learn to do skimp work. It’s rush, tear, push, jam, in this competitive system. I like to do good work, but I can’t. I never go to bed at night feeling that I have done my work well; and it’s so with most workmen. They don’t do good, honest work. When I see how buildings are put up in this city, I wonder that more of them don’t tumble.”

These are but a few of the experiences of a single housekeeper. They are not exceptional. They are typical of what is going on all over our country. While in the midst of these housekeeping trials, a friend from Washington called. The conversation turned upon the seamy side of labor. He said: “It is very difficult to find honest, reliable workmen in Washington, but I had supposed that in this respect Washington was the worst place in the United States.” Alas! the evil is wide-spread, and indicates — what can it indicate but radical defects in training and in character? And if this is true, the remedy is clear, for the specific, which alone can reach things so deep-seated as these, is education. What the form shall be, and what we shall call it, whether commercial education or practical education or a liberal education, worthy of being so called, because it frees, must be left to our city superintendent and his advisers, and to other educational experts who are alive to practical needs and conditions.

But as to the spirit and results of this education, every one who has suffered may have a right to his own convictions — and mine are these: That there must be in this country a better system of education, a system that is in closer touch with life, and that fits rather than unfits for life. There must be something in our common schools that will make for self-respect, and for that respect for others that is a part of true self-respect; something that will develop faithfulness and intelligence and pride in work; something that will link head and hands by indissoluble bonds. Domestic science and manual training in schools will gradually give a greater respect for manual labor; and with this respect should go a greater diffusion of manual labor; for the lack in our present system is quite as much on the side of employers as of employed.

An intelligent and many-sided woman recently remarked to me that Queen Victoria would be a better woman if she made her own bed daily. While it may not be practicable for queens to make their own beds, or for the president of the United States to chop his own wood, there never will be faithfulness, respect, and intelligence on the side of the workers unless the same attitude toward work is found in the employers.