Markham's "The Man with the Hoe" Reconsidered
THERE are many folks who, not knowing the spring of Markham’s poem, “The Man with the Hoe,” rush into print with criticism and condemnation of Mr. Markham as an “aristocrat,” and so, on general principles, one who despises the hoe and everybody that might ever use it. The origin of that poem was in Mr. Markham’s contemplation of the man with the hoe in that excessively dull and dismal picture, “The Angelus,” for which such a large sum of money was paid, and over which such a great furor was made, a few years ago. And no one who has ever seen that picture can deny that the poem is apt and true to its object in every line. It is that “man with the hoe,” and his kind alone, with whom the poem deals. And to make it universal is altogether a mistake as to the intent of the poem, as well as a mistake as to fact. Mr. Markham himself, is, on occasion, a man—not “the man”—with the hoe.