Schurman's Defense of Sulu Slavery as Beneficent
President Schurman, of Cornell University, and of the United States Philippine Commission, in explaining the bargain with the sultan of the Sulus by which slavery there is adopted by the United States, says that “slavery as it is practised in the Sulu Islands is not cruel, inhuman slavery. On the contrary, it is rather beneficent in form, and the relations between masters and slaves are, as a general thing, most friendly.” Now “beneficent” signifies “doing or affecting good; performing acts of kindness and charity; marked by, or resulting from, good will.” And it “always implies a kind and worthy purpose back of that to which the adjective applies.” And all that is the character of slavery in the Sulus! And it is the president of a great American university and of a United States governmental commission who says it! Since slavery in the Sulu jurisdiction of the United States is all that, so beneficent indeed that it does not come within the prohibition of the United States Constitution, should anybody be surprised if such a beneficent thing should be extended to other localities in the jurisdiction of the United States? SLAVERY beneficent! and that from the president of a leading university and an official representative of the United States government! After this, what next? And what is the country coming to? Yea, to what has the country already come?