A QUESTION WITH KINKS IN IT.
By Uriah Smith
The old adage says that “necessity is the mother of invention.” A sense of some tremendous necessity must therefore have held sway of the feelings of those who have had on their hands the Sunday institution to sustain, and the Sabbath institution to overthrow; for there has been apparently more inventive study bestowed upon these two problems than upon any other questions in the religious world, for the last quarter of a century. And when a man takes this job on his hands, to uplift Sunday and tear down the Sabbath, he must feel himself in a very hard situation; for in the whole range of Scripture and history, no support can be found for the one or the other; hence the overwhelming pressure of necessity on those committed to such efforts, and the unending swarm of inventions that have been brought forth to meet the case. We have just received a pamphlet from a writer on the Pacific Coast, entitled “Sabbatarian Theories Unscriptural.” By “Sabbatarians” the author means those who keep the seventh day; and what he would like to have his readers suppose is that those who do hold to the view and practice of seventh-day-keeping have devised and framed a line of theories, by which to defend their faith and practice in this respect. We have the satisfaction of saying to this man, that in the very first discharge of his field-piece, he has shot entirely wide of the mark; for those who observe the seventh day as the Sabbath do not have any theories on that point. They do not need to have, and there is no room for any. On that question, necessity does not rise up here and demand some invention by which to hide a truth, or manufacture an error. We, as Seventh-day Adventists, take what the Bible says, and just as it says it, and let that decide the question. And in the Bible, God says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work.” How much theory is there about that?806 A theory is “a doctrine or scheme of things, which terminates in speculation or contemplation, without a view to practice.” How does this definition, which we quote from a standard lexicon, fit the words of the Lord Jehovah, respecting his Sabbath? Well, this is all the theory we have on the Sabbath question. The Lord has told us what day is the Sabbath, and has commanded us to keep it; and he has told us how to keep it. What more can be required? That is why we keep it. Had he not said anything of this kind, we should not keep it. And whosoever would dissuade us from keeping it must show either that God has never said these words, or that we are under no obligation to obey what God says. That is the simple and limited issue to which the Sabbath question is reduced so far as so-called Sabbatarians, or keepers of the seventh day, are concerned. In view of this plain, direct testimony, it is most astounding that any one with a mind not given over to abandoned recklessness should audaciously stop and banter with the Lord in regard to the meaning of what he had said. “Lord, you don’t mean a day of twenty-four hours, do you? You have no reference to a week, have you? You have no reference to the seventh day of any particular period of time, especially a week, have you? You do not mean that we should keep the seventh day of each week, do you? You do not mean that we should literally cease from the labor of our hands, do you? but only that we should rest in spirit?” And some do not even stop long enough to put these thoughts into the interrogative form, but launch right out to assert their propositions, as if they could be established by their own reasoning. Thus the writer under notice, endeavors to put the crowning stroke to his effort by asserting that the days of Genesis 1 and 2, at least the day of the Sabbath, was not a day of twenty-four hours, a literal day, but a period of time, a thousand years in length. Does not Peter say that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day? Was not Adam to die in the day that he ate the forbidden fruit? and did he not live nearly a thousand years? Is not the whole time of the creation of the heavens and the earth called simply a day—“in the day that the Lord God made the earth and the heavens”? In the calendar of heaven, when the Lord, who is from everlasting to everlasting, surveys his work, and speaks of his purposes, the word “day” may be used in a sense which would not be applicable to the experiences and transactions of men; but it must be left for the Lord to indicate, as he has done in Peter, when he so intends it. And in a multifold manner has he done this in the case of the Sabbath. This sacred institution God has taken all pains to hedge about, on every hand, against misunderstanding and perversion. In the early records this matter is demonstrated beyond the possibility of misconception. In Genesis the record of the institution of the Sabbath is given. In Exodus, when events became contemporary with the writer, the institution is brought into actual contact with the life of the people, and an application is made of the obligations we are under in regard to it. In Ex. 20:8–11 the Sabbath commandment is given. In that commandment the great facts of creation are rehearsed. Days are referred to—days of labor, and the day of rest. There is no change of intention, or of the method, or the manner, of using language, between Genesis and Exodus. Whatever the day meant to Moses and the children of Israel in the wilderness, it meant the same at creation. The work of God at creation, his labor and rest, was given to mankind as an example; and on that example, as rehearsed in the commandment, the law was based. Exodus 20 tells us how to carry out that example in our lives. But the Sabbath in Genesis, we are told, was a thousand years in length, so could be no example for us to observe the seventh day of the week as we have it now. Just try to carry out the same rule in Exodus, where the Sabbath problem is worked out for our assistance, not with the thought to find sober argument therein, but just for the diversion and amusement of seeing how utterly absurd it is. Six days of labor, and one of rest; if one was a thousand years in length, all were. In that case, and in any case on this theory, there was not a soul of those who heard the commandment who could have fulfilled it. In an expanded sense, covering the whole course of this world’s history,—six thousand years of sin, followed by a thousand years of rest, peace, and righteousness, ere we reach our final inheritance in the earth made new,—Peter’s rule may apply, and each day in this symbolical week represent a thousand years, according to a long-cherished and respectable tradition and expectation. But that has nothing to do with our duty as prescribed by the fourth commandment. The language of Solomon would seem to have a very forcible application to this subject: “Lo, this only have I found, that God hath made man upright; but they have sought out many inventions.” Eccl. 7:29. Man was made at first upright, righteous in all his ways, loving the Lord’s Sabbath, and keeping all his commandments; but in no direction, as already remarked, have they sought out so many and complicated inventions as in their attempts to play blind to the Sabbath, as if they could not see it, or to ignore it, or openly set it aside; and all this in reference to an institution that God has set up as a monument of his power and glory, and a pledge of his earnest desire for the highest happiness and welfare of his creatures.