AdventAI

THE “NATIONAL REFORM” MOVEMENT.

By C. H. Keslake

From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 51., December 19, 1899

The National Reform Association held a convention in the Broadway Tabernacle, New York City, December 5-7, “for conference and action on the Christian principles of civil government.”

The writer was present at one of the afternoon sessions when the topics presented for consideration were, “Shall Our Nation Lose Its Sabbath?” and, “What Should This Nation Do to Preserve the Sabbath?” The speakers respectively were Rev. Dr. D. J. Burrell, of New York City, and Rev. J. W. Foster, of Boston, Mass.

The meeting itself was not largely attended, but the friends of this so-called reform movement who were present proved themselves to be desperately in earnest; and the utterances made by the speakers showed that they were prepared to take any step, and go to any length, to carry out their cherished scheme — to have a national Sunday law.

It would be an unusual thing if the association did not make some arguments which, taken by themselves, would make excellent reading for the Bible Sabbath. It would be unusual also if they did not present some glaring inconsistencies bordering on the ridiculous.

As the writer listened to the addresses, and remembered that they were prepared, not in the heat of the moment, but with cool deliberation after years of thought upon the subject, he realized as never before the significance of the prophecy of Rev. 13:15 (“And he had power to give life unto the image of the beast, that the image of the beast should both speak, and cause that as many as would not worship the image of the beast should be killed”) when, amid vehement hand-clapping of approval, it was argued by the Rev. J. W. Foster (I give his exact words) that “those who persist in violating God’s sabbath [Sunday] should be put to death.”

Dr. Burrell gave an excellent argument for the universality and perpetuity of the Sabbath when he said that he regarded it as a dangerous heresy for any minister to preach that the Sabbath of the fourth commandment has been abrogated. He pointed out that the Sabbath is based upon facts that can not possibly be changed, and that so “long as those facts [the six days of creation] shall exist, the seventh day will continue to be the Sabbath;” that they are “inseparably connected;” that “they stand or fall together;” to all of which every true Sabbath-keeper can say Amen. But what the foregoing had to do with Sunday, the day in behalf of which he spoke, he did not trouble himself to show. He probably thought it safer to let that go by default, and let his hearers assume that all he said pertained to the Sunday, instead of some of it to the seventh day.

The attentive listener must have felt it to be very odd that Dr. Burrell should urge the necessity of a national sabbath law, when he unqualifiedly confessed that the reason the “American sabbath” is passing away so rapidly is because of the failure of the ministry and the church to keep it, notwithstanding he claimed that twenty-seven millions of people of this country are identified with the Christian religion; that their mental vigor, etc., are unsurpassed; and that they constitute the brawn and strength of the nation.

Granting that to be so, what a confession! What an acknowledgment of the futility of the gospel that they preach! Professing to preach the gospel of the grace of God, and yet not having grace enough to do what they believe they ought to do! Advocating a civil law to compel themselves to do what there is not power enough in the gospel that they preach to enable them to do! Civil law greater than the grace of God! Think of it!

Dr. Burrell never fails to spring that old fallacy, first taught by Wilbur F. Crafts, I believe, that “the right to sabbath rest for one demands a law of rest for all.” Mr. Foster, in his address, expressed the same thought when he said, “A law of rest for all is a necessity in order for the liberty of rest for each.” This is an argument that seems to be believed by many to be a fundamental truth. But the truth is, it is false. The proposition is simply that no one is able to keep the sabbath unless everybody else does the same. This is just what Dr. Burrell declared in a speech before the Christian Endeavor Society of New Jersey, in Paterson, N. J., two years ago. He said that he can not keep the sabbath so long as there are others who do not. And therefore those who will not voluntarily keep the sabbath (Sunday) must be compelled to do so. And remember, on his own confession, those who do not do it are the ministers and Christian people! Verily “their rock is not as our Rock, even our enemies themselves being judges.”

Seventh-day Adventists in their exposition of the prophecies have maintained for many years that Sunday would be set forth as a mark — the seal of God. Many times this has been done by Sunday-law advocates. Dr. Burrell furnished another proof of the correctness of the Adventists’ position. He said that God called his ancient people out of Egypt, and made them a separate nation, and made a covenant with them, the seal of which was the Sabbath. In like manner, he said, God had established this nation, calling the people out from the nations of the Old World, making a covenant with them, and giving them the sabbath (Sunday) as a seal.

This was a bold claim, but it evidently went down with the majority of his hearers, if one may judge from the clapping of hands when the speaker took his seat. Of course, in showing the analogy between God’s dealing with ancient Israel and this American nation, Dr. Burrell could not fail to point out that just as the former nation was destroyed for not keeping the Sabbath, so this nation will finally go down under the wrath of God from the same failure. Thus he showed(?) what would happen should this nation lose its American sabbath.

Rev. J. W. Foster immediately followed, undertaking to show what needs to be done in order to preserve the sabbath, and so to preserve the nation. It may be there was no collusion between the speakers, yet Mr. Foster’s conclusions were a fitting climax to what had preceded. He, too, referred to the “Mosaic covenant,” showing how the violation of the commandments of God was punished with death. “Even now,” he said, “we hang a man for murder,—for violating the sixth commandment,—and I believe that those who persist in violating God’s sabbath [Sunday] should be put to death.” As before stated, this was received with hearty approval, if one may judge from the hand-clapping that followed.

It is very likely that a large number of Seventh-day Adventists have settled down into a condition of fancied security, believing that we are not in any immediate danger; but when a minister can stand up in a Christian church and coolly assert that a person should be put to death for sabbath-breaking, and be applauded, it seems to the writer that everything is ready for life to be given to the image, and the death penalty be enforced, and the prophecy be fulfilled.

It can be seen in all history that the word of God has been fulfilled at a time when, from a human standpoint, the event predicted was the least likely to occur. We are in such a situation now. Let every Seventh-day Adventist bestir himself.

C. H. KESLAKE.