Bishop Thoburn declares that the Philippine Islands “can never be kept in a state of peace in any other way [than by employing natives in the war against the natives], until the people become enlightened, and learn to love peace for its own sake.” About how long it will probably take for “the people to become enlightened, and learn to love peace for its own sake,” by war, and fratricidal war at that, and that by a people of whom he says many are “literally ‘half-devil and half-child,’” the bishop does not attempt to say. But the strongest part of this thing is that a professed Christian bishop could commend such a means as that by which a people shall “become enlightened, and learn to love peace for its own sake”! That can be nothing else than a distinct abandonment, in principle, of Christianity as the true means of enlightenment, and of love of peace for its own sake. Another reason that he offers in justification of this anti-Christian and inhuman thing is that this is “the policy which has, for more than a century, been so successfully employed by the English in India.” But for the American people to adopt British forms and procedure in government is distinctly to abandon American principles, and to take up the old order of things, which was expressly repudiated in the establishment of this nation. For the United States to take the anti-Christian course advised by Bishop Thoburn would be apostasy; and to advise the United States to take such a course is nothing less.
Bishop Thoburn's Proposal to Wage War in the Philippines
From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 39., September 26, 1899