INCONSISTENCIES ALWAYS ACCOMPANY ERROR.
By R. E. S.
It seems impossible for false, or erroneous, propositions or theories to exist alone. Like men of questionable ways, they seem to have a mutual attraction for one another. “Misery loves company” is an old proverb, and a true one. A small boy, following the path of truth and uprightness, is perfectly happy and contented; but a mischievous urchin who has stolen watermelons or tormented a dumb animal, is uneasy until he has imparted to some of his playmates a knowledge of his transgressions, and enticed them to engage with him in what he knows is wrong. False doctrines breed incorrect statements and confusion. These thoughts present themselves on reading, in a church paper of a prominent and popular denomination, a letter from an army chaplain, who with his regiment is now in the Philippines. How he can make even himself think that he represents the meek and gentle Prince of Peace, as his profession demands, is more than one can imagine when the various incongruities of his letter are contemplated. Notwithstanding the statement of Dr. Schurman that the Filipino is the equal of any civilized man on the face of the earth, this reverend soldier says, “The Filipinos are no more capable of self-government than the American Indians.” To prove his statement, he refers to the past history of the islands, making special mention of a civil war in 1762, in which large numbers were killed. But the memories of many not yet called old will recall a terrible civil war much nearer us than the Philippines as regards distance, and one hundred years later in point of time. After speaking of his desire for a government “broad in principle and comprehensive in character,” the writer of the letter goes on to say that “Uncle Sam” ought to adopt the Philippine Islands as his youngest daughter, and give her all the privileges she can use to her safety. His words are:— Our government is able to hold the islands, and is the proper authority to hold them; and not to hold them and train these people out of barbarity into the light of civilization is nothing short of cruelty and foolishness. No greater blessing ever came from God to a people than has come to the Filipinos by our government’s taking possession of these islands. (Italics ours.) Notwithstanding the “barbarity” of the people which he has just mentioned, a little further down in his letter he tells of the second American-Filipino wedding that has taken place in Iloilo. A young company-clerk of a Tennessee regiment was united in marriage to Senorita Philisia Philin, the chaplain officiating. One can hardly understand the evident satisfaction of the chaplain in thus uniting one of his company with a Filipino belle in the bonds of holy matrimony if she is really one of a cruel, barbarous, uncivilized race. Another inconsistency seen in this chaplain’s letter, thus proving its statements to be incorrect, is his flattering description of the men in one regiment. He speaks of a major who has “worked hard” to organize a battalion from some regulars who were mustered out there. “The men,” he says, “are mostly Tennesseans, and that means here in the Philippines ‘good fighters.’” In telling of their good qualities he mentions things that are entirely incompatible with common respectability, not to speak of Christianity, which one would think would be the least that could possibly satisfy a true pastor. Lest some may think that his words have been misunderstood, we quote, direct, the following sentences:— For such faithful service the Tennessee regiment deserves great praise. They can curse more, “shoot more craps,” drink more whisky, and use more vulgarity, and do less grumbling than any regiment in the service. It is hard to believe that those words truly describe the character of the Tennessee soldiers; but there can be no doubt that the writing of such words for publication in an influential religious paper does reveal considerable of the character of the chaplain who wrote them. There are many persons in this country who will agree that at least the extra war tax which is required to pay this man’s salary might well be saved. For it is difficult to perceive, or even to conceive, how he can possibly be of any spiritual use to the soldiers. R. E. S.