WHY THE BATTLE CREEK COLLEGE CAN NOT CONFER DEGREES.
By E. A. Sutherland
The Battle Creek College desires to be as free from the errors of worldly education, to stand on the everlasting principles of Christian education, as the remnant church should desire to be free from worldly religion, and to rest on the principles of the everlasting gospel. If our school conforms to the worldly principles of education in its work, the students in their religious life will seek the spirit of worldly religion; if they are educated to receive honors from men while in our school, they will crave more honors from men in the church, or even in the world. Literary degrees are the germs, the beginnings, of the destructive evils which have permeated Protestantism, and from which the third angel’s message is now calling the people. Can we nurse in our educational system principles from which we must be separated in the church? Protestantism has allowed an enemy to fashion the educational system which she is now following. Deceived and bewildered, she has been led along until she is now knocking for entrance at the gate of the papacy. How could it be otherwise, when Protestantism foolishly allowed the papacy, through the Jesuits and the deceived civil power, to fashion her educational system? The few historical extracts given herewith will reveal the whole situation to the seeker after truth. These extracts from the sayings of popular educators show that the granting of honors, in the form of degrees, is as great a farce, and as devoid of life, as the fruits of this system are hollow and dead, which appear in the mere forms and ceremonies of the popular churches, from which thousands have turned away, and from which we should be calling them with a loud cry. Shall we sow principles in our school that we are unwilling to harvest in our church? In a work entitled “Religion or no Religion in Education,” by Rev. B. Hartmann, we read: “The Catholic Church, which has been the mother of popular education, does not require the advice of the state in conducting schools. When civil governments were yet in their teens; she had already developed great skill in the art. The great universities of Europe are of her creation. The conferring of degrees was originated by a pope.”—Page 43. “Previous to this time, that is, up to the middle of the twelfth century, any one was taught in the infant universities who thought he had the requisite knowledge. . . . At first, each man who had it in him, or thought he had, began to lecture, and took his chance. As a lecturer, he was called magister or doctor, in the generic sense of these words—that is, simply a master or teacher.”—“Rise and Constitution of Universities,” pages 222, 228. “Among the humble early Christians, teaching had been regarded as the gift of God, and teachers had sought their credentials at the throne of grace rather than at the hand of bishops and abbots. Even in the second half of the twelfth century, when the bishops and abbots, who acted, personally or through their deputies, as chancellors of the rising university schools, wished to assume to themselves exclusively the right of granting the license (with a view to check abuses, I presume), Pope Alexander III forbade them on the ground that the teaching faculty was a gift of God.”—Id., pages 223, 224. These scruples seem not to have held long, however, for very soon ambitious men were seeking and receiving from the educators of the church the degrees of “master” or “doctor,” which gave them the privilege of teaching whether or not their lives bore the heavenly credentials. To-day the granting of these honors has become such a nuisance that thoughtful men all over the country are deploring the traffic in titles now carried on. It is a well-known fact that these are bought and sold, sometimes for money, and still more often as mere favors. The following extracts from the Educational Review will show what is the candid public mind upon this matter:— “We are impressed, too, with the opportunity here afforded for traveling salesmen, political orators, and itinerant musicians to be appropriately decorated with any or all of the degrees of B. S., Ph. B., A. B., M. S., Ph. M., A. M., Ph. D., D. D., and LL. D., as fate may decree and the fee provide. For we read, ‘Those who are not college graduates may become candidates for degrees whenever the success and common fame in their line of professional work seem to justify the honor to be conferred.’”—February, 1899, Editorial. “One college president writes very frankly that Ph. D. was conferred on him without any sufficient reason. Another says that he never was in favor of granting honorary Ph. D., and knows of no good institution that is.” “The reasons given as grounds for the bestowal of the honor are remarkable for their indefiniteness. One college in Kansas granted it to two women for ‘conspicuous work, especially in a literary way.’ A New York College has been giving it to ‘skilled teachers.’ A leading Pennsylvania institution bestows it for ‘eminent attainments.’ Another college in the same State has been limiting it to professors and principals, while a third gives it for ‘meritorious scientific work;’ and one in Ohio requires ‘eminence in philosophical pursuits.’ Several colleges avow their practise of bestowing LL. D. on the State governors. . . .” “The grounds usually given for LL. D. are such uncertain qualifications as ‘scholarship and position,’ ‘distinction in science or letters,’ ‘valuable services,’ ‘distinction as a statesman,’ ‘general ability,’ and ‘general fitness.’ The degree of D. D. is granted for ‘distinguished church work,’ ‘meritorious scholarship,’ or ‘general fitness.’ One president says it is a ‘hard question to answer,’ and another remarks that the ‘rule is not very stringent.’ A. M. is being given as an honorary acknowledgment of ‘marked success of many years’ teaching,’ of ‘ability as a preacher or writer,’ or of ‘sufficient prominence.’ One New England college granted it to ‘an old lady in Vermont, an old teacher and efficient worker in the cause of temperance,’ while another leading college says that it gives the degree ‘to a citizen or benefactor, not literate, whom the university desires to honor.’ . . .” “The abuse of this degree is due to the rage after titles. . . . Since the chief thing with many is the Ph. D., the question with them is not how to earn it in the most meritorious way, but how to gain it as quickly and as easily as possible. Unfortunately there are institutions willing to meet such persons half-way, and thus dishonor both themselves and the cause of higher education.”—William O. Sproull, in Educational Review, October, 1893. “In 1893-94, not less than eight hundred degrees of honor were granted in this country, the State of Ohio standing foremost, and the State of Minnesota last, in the exercise of this undesirable liberality. It would be inexcusable narrow-mindedness to deny the patent fact that many a holder of a lower degree, or no degree at all, may eclipse, in his line, many a proud holder of the highest academic honors. And the best degree, that of proficiency, may well continue to be recognized.”—Hjalmar Edgren, in Educational Review, March, 1899. In an article in the same magazine, David Starr Jordan, president of Stanford University, says, speaking of Leland Stanford, that “he valued learning; but had little respect for degrees, requirements, and the details of organization which have come down from the University of Paris.” Thus we find that worldly educators honor the principle that true worth lies not in name, but in being. More than that, God has spoken to us concerning this matter:— “In our institutions of learning there was to be exerted an influence that would counteract the influence of the world, and give no encouragement to indulgence in appetite, in selfish gratification of the senses, in pride, ambition, love of dress and display, love of praise and flattery, and strife for high rewards, and honors as a recompense for good scholarship. All this was to be discouraged in our schools. It would be impossible to avoid these things, and yet send them to the public schools, where they would daily be brought into contact with that which would contaminate their morals.”—“Home, Church, and State Schools,” page 72.