NATIONAL W. C. T. U., SEATTLE, WASH
By Grace Durland
Report of Special Order for the Consideration of Mrs. Henry’s Resolution.
10:30 A. M., Wednesday, Oct. 25, 1899. After the opening exercises the special order was called. This was the consideration of a resolution presented by Mrs. S. M. I. Henry the previous afternoon, as follows:— Whereas, As a Woman’s Christian Temperance Union we most earnestly teach the principle and practice of Sabbath observance, and labor for the closing of the saloons on every day of every week, yet in order to free ourselves as an organization from a manifest inconsistency and impediment,— Resolved, That our plan of work shall be so changed as to remove from its departments everything that tends to sectarian controversy, or which can in any sense be made to interfere with perfect liberty of conscience as regards the days which shall be given to worship, rest, or labor; or which can be used to give aid or comfort to any who, through ignorance, prejudice, or malice, would enact, or so enforce, civil law as to interfere with the religious convictions of any and all people. Mrs. Henry stated that if it was in order, she would like to withdraw this resolution, and offer another, which would more clearly cover the point that she wished to bring before them. This was ruled to be in order, and Mrs. Henry offered the following:— Resolved, That as a National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union we protest against any such interpretation or use of any lines of our work as shall give aid or comfort to those who, through ignorance, prejudice, or malice, would enact or enforce such laws as can be made to serve the purpose of persecution, or to in any manner interfere with the most perfect liberty of conscience concerning days, or the manner of their observance. Mrs. Henry moved the adoption of this resolution, and it was seconded by Mrs. Babcock, of Rhode Island. A second reading was called for, after which Mrs. Babcock spoke as follows:— Madam President: I came from the State of Rhode Island,—the very smallest State in all the Union, and the State which has for one of its fundamental principles the principle of religious liberty,—and, Madam President, in view of the fact that the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union is a nonsectarian body, inviting to its membership women of every nationality, irrespective of creed, and also in view of the fact that there is in the membership of this organization a considerable number of women, working and loyal members, who cannot co-operate with the organization in any efforts to obtain legal enactments requiring the observance of any special day as the Sabbath,—in behalf of such members of my own State, and also of many other States, I most earnestly plead that there may be an elimination of the legal part of the work of the Sabbath Observance department; and I am in favor of the adoption of the resolution offered by Mrs. Henry. Mrs. Henry then spoke as follows:— Madam President, and Sisters of the Convention: The glory of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union has ever been that it was a channel of light, that it has always been open toward the throne of God for illumination, open always toward the darkest corners of the earth for the dispensing of the light it should receive from the throne; and although there seems to be in the mind of many persons a supposition that the W. C. T. U. has changed her attitude upon many questions, that she is not to-day what she was in the beginning, yet I have that faith and confidence in our organization, and in the manner in which we were called into existence, and in the spirit which has wrought through us from the beginning until now, that I believe the W. C. T. U. is still true; that we are still open toward the throne to receive light, open to communicate to those who are down in the depths any light that comes to us, and that whenever we come to see in any line of our work that which does in any way interfere with this open channel, which does prevent the dissemination of light,741 we will at least take it into careful consideration; and I stand before you this morning to make an appeal for a large class of Christian workers in our organization,—a class growing larger and larger every month; for from among the ranks of the people who observe the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath there has come into the W. C. T. U. in the last year a large number of workers, good and true, many of them giving time and energies to the teaching of the ignorant in the very principles for which the W. C. T. U. stands. In some cases these workers have met with a strange interference in their work,—an interference of a character so malignant as to be nothing less than persecution; and I feel that I would be unjust to the W. C. T. U., as well as to my fellow laborers, did I not bring these matters to your notice, and make an appeal to you for the help which you can give. I know that our women would not countenance persecution; nor could we be a persecuting organization. I know our women do not understand the use that is being made of our department of Sabbath Observance, and that the department itself does not at all presuppose any such use as is made of it. A speaker from the floor then moved that Mrs. Henry be limited to two minutes. Mrs. Henry.—Madam President: I shall ask the courtesy of this convention to be heard once in these years on the subject of which my heart is full. Mrs. Stevens, of Maine, President N. W. C. T. U.—The Chair would say that there is a rule that no one shall be allowed to speak but three minutes upon any one question, and only once, until all others who wish to be heard shall have spoken. Miss Anna Gordon, of Illinois, Vice-President at Large.—Madam President: The bell has already tapped, announcing the expiration of Mrs. Henry’s three minutes, but I move that she be allowed another three minutes. Unanimously granted. Mrs. Stevens.—It is so ordered: Mrs. Henry has the floor. Mrs. Henry.—Madam President: I will come directly to the point for which I wish to make an appeal. There is a work which has run parallel with the work of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union for more than twenty-five years in its benevolent and reformatory lines, as indicated in the Medical Missionary Association. From its training-school there go out self-supporting missionaries, who labor with their hands that they may preach and teach; and at this present time, while I am standing here before you, one of these self-supporting missionaries in Georgia is under a six-months’ sentence in the chain-gang because he followed his convictions, and, having kept the seventh day as the Sabbath, labored the first day of the week. This brother, a self-supporting missionary, labored with his hands to maintain himself and family while he preached the gospel to the poor and degraded in the community to which he had gone for that purpose. Understand that this man is under sentence for six months in the chain-gang of Georgia; and if the Supreme Court of that State sustains the Sunday law of the State, as it no doubt will, Brother Waters will have to serve that six months in the chain-gang in a State where there is no provision for Sabbath rest, and where there is a determination not to allow it; or else he must appeal to the court of last resort,—the Supreme Court of the United States. Should he do this, and should the United States Supreme Court sustain the Sunday law, as it doubtless would, he would be compelled to bring about what the National Reformers have sought for many years to do—the legalization of State Sunday laws; and it would not be long, according to present developments, until people would be persecuted for preaching on the Sabbath in place of Sunday, because that would be a violation of this law. This is the point toward which this is all tending. Women, however you may have looked at this in former days, this is a stern, live issue which is now upon us. Not only upon the people of the United States, but upon us as a W. C. T. U. This department in the W. C. T. U. is simply a hook upon which anything can be hung which, in the hands of ignorant people, may be used to persecute those who observe the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath. I would not say that any of our brethren of the National Reform Association desire to persecute anybody. I do not believe that; but they are placing a persecuting power in the hands of the ignorant and prejudiced; and I ask that the W. C. T. U. shall not be a party to any of those devices by which the weak and ignorant, who do not know how to control their passions and their prejudices, shall be equipped with such terrible powers. I ask that this resolution shall pass, and that we protest against such use of the W. C. T. U. in any line or department of work. Mrs. Henry.—Madam President: I would like to have an opportunity to speak again later on Mrs. Cox, of New Jersey, Superintendent Sunday Observance Department.—Madam President: I am sure that there is nothing in our Sabbath Observance department that would persecute any one. We have never worked for any law, and we never will work for any law that does not make an exception of those who habitually observe any other day than Sunday as the Sabbath; and we will work just as hard to protect those who desire to observe any other day than the first day of the week as a day of rest as any one. I think there is not the distinction made between the religious and the civil sabbath which should be. The law protects as far as possible every person in worshiping when, how, where, and whom he pleases. There is no law in the land that requires anybody to worship at any time or at any place. The Supreme Court has declared that our Sunday laws are not religious laws. One of the delegates then arose, addressed the Chair, and spoke as follows:— If this department must be dropped because it is sectarian, and we continue this course, we will drop out a large proportion of our departments, because the larger number of the one hundred and fifty-four denominations of the Protestant church have declared officially that the only proper emblem to represent the shed blood of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ— Mrs. Henry.—Madam President: I rise to a point of order. The speaker is not speaking to the motion. Allow me to read my resolution. I do not wish to give the impression that I do not believe in Sabbath observance. I do believe in Sabbath observance, and very clearly stated it in the resolution of which this is a substitute; but I thought it would make the discussion of the special point which I had in view easier, to leave that clause out. Mrs. Cox.—Madam President: There are only two requirements for membership in our organization,—sign the pledge, and pay the dues; and then do as you please. We cannot expect that in such a large body as ours all the women will be in perfect accord with all the departments. I know that there are women who are not in accord with many of our departments. A lady said to me, not long ago, “I am in perfect accord with you with the exception of one thing, and if it was not for that, I would have been a member of your organization long ago; that is the woman’s rights business that I cannot stand.” I was compelled to say to her, “If that department be the fly in the ointment which spoils it for you, we are very sorry; but we cannot take the fly out.” So it is with every one of our departments. Mrs. ——, of North Dakota.—Madam President: As superintendent of this department for several years in my State, I feel that I must speak against the resolution. We have one of the best Sabbath laws in our State that there is in the Union, and it is a law that can in no way savor of persecution. Those who care to observe the seventh day as a day of rest are distinctly exempted from the punishment provided by this law; they are distinctly stated as not law-breakers. This is the only kind of law that I feel that our Sabbath Observance department or our nation can work for. If these laws have been used for persecution, I feel safe to say that it has not been under the influence of our Sabbath Observance workers. It seems to me that to take the legal part from this department would virtually be to kill the department, because in every line of reform we must have the law back of us if our work is to be effective; but the law is not directed in any religious sense toward those who wish to observe any other day than the first day. As one who is trying to understand the work in all its phases, from every standpoint, I feel that it would be a great mistake to adopt this resolution. Mrs. Stoddard, of Texas, President State W. C. T. U.—Madam President: I wish to second all the remarks which have just been made. Our Sunday institution is too weak already, and we must do something to reinforce our departments, and not weaken them. Mrs. C. C. Hoffman, of Missouri, National Recording Secretary.—Madam President: There is nothing in this resolution about any department—absolutely nothing. The request was then made for the resolution to be reread. Mrs. Hoffman read it, and continued:— There is nothing in this resolution concerning any of our departments of work; there is nothing asked to be changed in our departments of work. We can press this subject. We can go back a little ways farther, and find the time of civil and bloody persecution on account of opinions. But don’t let us be in that category. We say that every one is granted perfect liberty of conscience; and yet within our ranks there are devoted, lovely women, like our Mrs. Henry, and Mrs. Babcock, whom we all love, to whom there comes such threats as I shall read, from those also in our ranks. Our W. C. T. U. is not composed entirely of Christians, any more than any other society. We have those who are narrow, intolerant, and determined that everybody who does not measure up to their standard shall be rejected or ejected. This is the language of one such woman: “You, of course, cannot consistently remain with us, and think of flapping your second advent wings at our sessions; and as we to a man or woman are Sunday worshipers, and, politically, Prohibitionists, you would not enjoy yourself with us. We want you never again to claim any influence with us.” [Cries of Shame! Shame!] I am not a Seventh-day Adventist; I am not a Seventh-day Baptist; I have been reared to observe the first day of the week as the Lord’s day; and I have not changed my opinion; but I do protest, dear sisters, against this petty persecution of any one for conscience’ sake. We are simply asked to put ourselves on record as opposed to this kind of persecution, malice, ignorance, and intolerance— At this point some one arose and said that the speaker was not speaking to the question. Mrs. Hoffman reassured her that she certainly was speaking to the question, and was supported in this statement. Mrs. White-Kinney, of Oregon, President State W. C. T. U.—Madam President: I would like to ask if the letter from which the extract was read was not a private affair, and so ought not to be brought into public. I have received letters on the other side, but I would not like to bring them here. I wish to say that I most sincerely hope that this resolution will not prevail. It strikes at the existing Sunday laws, and this would place us on record as opposed to existing Sunday laws. We certainly would provide for the protection of those who may have another Sunday. Mrs. Morrow, of West Virginia.—Madam President: I wish to indorse what our Recording Secretary has said. I believe in the observance of the Sabbath, and we have in the State of West Virginia as loyal women as ever drew breath who are Seventh-day Baptists, and I believe in them, and that they have their rights; and it does seem to me that in the indorsement of the resolution, with perhaps a possible amendment, we shall not in any way work injury to our department of Sabbath Observance; and I wish that if the resolution should not prevail, to have some amendment made that will show that we do not indorse the persecution of Christians for conscience’ sake. Mrs. Katherine Lente Stevenson, President Massachusetts W. C. T. U.—Madam President: I wish with all my heart, mind, and strength to speak in favor of the resolution before the house. It seems to me that as a body of Christian women to whom tolerance is a fundamental principle, that we can afford to put our influence against any possible intolerance; and I believe that the adoption of this resolution would not aim a blow directly to the injury of any department work, but that it does prevent the abuse growing out of this department. I remember the woe unto him through whom the offense cometh. I hope the resolution will prevail. Mrs. Clark, of Ohio, President State W. C. T. U.—I wish to put myself on record as against any form of intolerance. We are, as an organization, bound to the greatest liberty of conscience, and it seems to me there is nothing in this resolution but a declaration of what all our departments demand; and so, Madam President, while I think Mrs. Henry has put it a little stronger than some of us might, yet we should declare ourselves in the right in such instances as Mrs. Henry has given us here. Such things are possible; we all know they are; we have read of these instances in the South, and in other portions of our country. These things are in existence, and with our “Do-everything” policy, and our “We’ll-see-to-you” policy, let us meet the obligation that has come to us in the fact that we have many members who do conscientiously observe the seventh day. They have a right to come in here and ask that some such declaration shall be made by the W. C. T. U. for their protection. I do not think there is one thought in this resolution that could be construed as an attack on any of our departments, or intended to injure our general work, but only to declare the principles that we have in our department work. Mrs. Woodward, of Nebraska.—Madam President: I am sorry to differ with any woman, especially the president of Ohio. I believe that the president of Oregon has struck the right line in this matter. We have in this resolution now before the house a reference to the enactment and enforcement of laws pertaining to the Sunday question. In the State of Georgia no railroad train can leave any division station after twelve o’clock on Saturday night. I wish to know if this convention desires to stand against the enforcement of the law that will hold at division stations all freight-trains in the State of Georgia, and so cause all employed men to lose their day of rest. I therefore move, being in hearty sympathy with all the rest of this resolution, and hoping that it may be made stronger in its protest against persecution, that we protest against persecution, and against anything that can infringe upon the rights of the minority in the United States who worship742 upon the seventh day, and do their ordinary duties, performing their ordinary work, upon the first day, according to their conviction and belief. It was then moved and seconded that that portion of the resolution that bears upon the making and enforcing of laws be stricken out. Speaker unknown.—Madam President: I think it must be understood that white-ribbon women do favor civil law for the observance of the Sabbath, but are opposed to religious intolerance. Mrs. Henry.—Madam President: I wish to read Paul, with reference to that amendment. “Who art thou that judgest another man’s servant? to his own master he standeth or falleth. Yea, he shall be holden up: for God is able to make him stand. One man esteemeth one day above another: another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind. He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the Lord he doth not regard it.” The observance of the Sabbath is a question that is entirely between God and man, with which man has no right whatsoever to meddle. He has nothing whatsoever to do with the enforcement of divine law. The Sabbath law is entirely between God and man. It concerns conscience always. Man has nothing to do with any legislation that enjoins the observance of the Sabbath. Those other laws that deal with affairs between man and man may be incorporated into civil legislation; but those which refer to God and man are not subject to civil legislation. Speaker unknown.—Madam President: I think that Paul was talking in favor of what we wish to retain, and not what we wish to strike out. Miss Brehm then offered the following amendment to the resolution, as involving all necessary points, and omitting the objectionable ones:— Resolved, That we favor the amendment of all State Sunday laws which do not contain the usual exemption for those who keep the Sabbath day. Mrs. Hunt, of Massachusetts, Superintendent Scientific Temperance Instruction.—Madam President: We have with us Rev. W. F. Crafts, and I move that he be allowed to speak to this resolution. Mrs. Hunt’s motion, however, was seconded, and an aye and no vote taken,—a number voting in the negative, but the majority in the affirmative; and Rev. Crafts came to the platform. Mrs. C. C. Hoffman.—Madam President: I move that Rev. Crafts be limited to the same amount of time as all others. This motion prevailed, which was necessarily somewhat embarrassing to the gentleman, as he could not begin to say all that he wished to say on this, to him, particularly interesting subject, and reached the limit of his time in the midst of a very important sentence. After addressing the Chair, Mr. Crafts remarked, reproachfully, that this was the first time that he ever received a “No” from a W. C. T. U. convention; and then proceeded as follows:— The resolution which is before the house, if adopted, would be interpreted in this whole country, without the slightest doubt, to refer to lines of work that intimate that the Sabbath Observance department, founded by Mrs. Bateham, which is one of the great corners of this association, which doubtless has done as grand a work as any you have, with possibly one exception,—that this department has been used to further persecution. Certain lines of work are intimated as having contributed to persecution. The thing which I have always worked for is that seventh day people shall be protected in every State. My dear friend, Mrs. Babcock, has made no complaint about the law in Rhode Island; and if every other State had a similar law, then the whole matter would be covered without any reflection upon any department, or a chance of being misunderstood. I wish to compliment these very earnest people. I wish that we were half as earnest and industrious in our work as are those who are advocating the seventh day. I am aware of the fact that some have strained the law in a few cases. I think that Mrs. Henry and others should make their protest to the State conventions of these two or three States in which persecutions have taken place, and the unions of those States should take these things in hand. There are two distinct days,—the religious and the civil. The only object of our work is to protect the toiler in his right to a day of rest, so that employers may not take advantage of his service. There is no worship enjoined upon any one. There is a hundred-dollar fine or imprisonment on any person that fails to observe the day religiously— Mrs. Beauchamp, of Kentucky, President State W. C. T. U.—Madam President: I sincerely hope this substitute will prevail. I do not believe in religious persecution, but I do believe in a civil sabbath. I believe that our bodies are the temples of God and the Holy Spirit, and that his law is written in our members, and that that law requires that one seventh of our time shall be given to rest. I believe that municipal labor means compulsory labor. I sincerely hope that this substitute will prevail, because I cannot understand to what else but to our department the significant words, “Any line of our work,” in the original resolution can refer. If what is really wanted is the freedom to keep the seventh day, if the law of every State can be so amended as to exempt such from the Sabbath law, the purpose is answered; and so, Madam President, I sincerely hope that this convention will adopt the substitute. Mrs. Cox.—Madam President: I sincerely hope that the substitute will prevail, and I pledge myself, as the superintendent of that department for the ensuing year, to give to it all my time and strength. Ever since I have served you in this capacity, it has been my desire to have the utmost protection afforded to everybody to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience; and I hope that this substitute will prevail, and that strong efforts will be made to secure such an amendment to any Sunday laws that now exist as shall afford protection to those who worship upon the seventh day or any other. Mrs. Tomlinson, of New Jersey, National Superintendent Parlor Meetings.—Madam President: New Jersey has a law which makes an exception of those keeping the seventh day as the Sabbath; and yet in my own State this last winter the seventh-day people who had observed the day strictly, and who opened their stores or places of business in a quiet manner upon the first day of the week, were visited by the chief of police, and told that if they did not close their places of business upon the first day, they would be arrested. Of course our seventh-day people made strong protest; but at the same time the street-cars were running, the post-offices were open, the railroad trains were running. The people who were trying to observe the first day of the week paid no attention to these things; but when a person, conscientious in his belief, observes the seventh day, and labors on the first, according to the dictates of his own conscience, he is arrested, when his neighbor will perhaps perform the same labor on the first day, and there is nothing said about it. Therefore in those States where there is an exemption the people are not always protected. Speaker unknown.—Madam President: Believing that this convention ought not to refuse to pass a resolution against intolerance at any time, I move that this matter be referred to a committee of three, consisting of Mrs. Henry, Mrs. Tomlinson, and Mrs. Cox, who shall prepare a resolution upon which they can agree, covering the controverted points. It was then moved by some other delegate that some more disinterested person should take the place of Mrs. Tomlinson on the committee. Mrs. Cox.—Madam President: I am opposed to any such committee. I think this matter ought to be settled in the convention, and not by a committee. The motion to appoint a committee was lost. The question was then called for, and the motion to adopt the resolution as amended prevailed. This closed the first discussion of these principles in the W. C. T. U. Before leaving the platform, Mrs. Henry again called the attention of the Chair, and said:— Madam President and Delegates: I give notice that at the next annual convention I, or some one in my place, will offer the following amendment to the constitution:— ARTICLE VI.—PLANS OF WORK.
Nothing shall ever be incorporated into any plan of N. W. C. T. U. work, by department or otherwise, which must of necessity become the occasion of sectarian controversy, or which can in any sense be made to interfere with perfect liberty of conscience. Reports of superintendents followed until the near approach of the noontide hour of prayer, when Mrs. Henry was called to the platform to conduct the closing evangelistic service of the convention. She announced the hymn, “How firm a foundation,” which was sung with deep earnestness, and followed by Bradbury’s “If I were a voice,” rendered by the Musical Director of the N. W. C. T. U., Mrs. Frances W. Graham, of New York, in a manner so tender, sweet, and pure as to move and melt every heart. Mrs. Henry read the ninety-third psalm, and called on Mrs. Anna M. Palmer, of Iowa (National Evangelist), to lead in prayer, after which there followed one of the most remarkable praise services on record. Mrs. Henry introduced it by saying that praise is due to him who can keep our hearts steady with love and confidence toward one another, even when we must disagree on what seems a vital point. She thanked God for light that brightens even our cloudiest days. As she gave the meeting into the hands of that vast audience, and the short, pointed words of praise and testimony began to flow in a steady, musical current, it was like a wave of heavenly rest to the women, weary with discussion and well-nigh hopeless planning during so many years against a foe invincible to any but the omnipotent One.