Seattle Letter on the W. C. T. U. Convention
By Susan M. I. Henry
SEATTLE, WASH., Oct. 29, 1899. The national W. C. T. U. convention has just closed. It has been a time of remarkable experiences, especially as manifested in the leading of God. That my brethren and sisters may have a full understanding of all that is involved in it, I will give the whole story through the REVIEW AND HERALD. I had come to the convention with my mind fully made up as to what should be my course of action; that I should probably have but little to do outside of regular conventional proceedings, leaving all attempts to make any change in the points touched by the Sabbath Observance department to some plans or methods as yet unknown. Considering the nature of my work as an evangelist, I could not see my way clear to force a discussion of the subject, which would necessarily, as it seemed to me, bring contention. But I was at times very much pressed with a sense of responsibility concerning this matter, and was waiting to know the mind of God. While I was at Victoria, at Brother Durland’s home, just three days before I must start for Seattle, I received a letter from Sister White, which, without anything having been written to her to call forth such an expression, contained these words:— “The word continues to come: In the name of the Lord advance. The Lord will honor the faith of those who trust him. God has called upon you to make your appeal, to show that you are worthy of the sacred trust that he has in his providence conferred upon you. God is testing the principles that move his people to action. Having adopted a right principle of action, reverence and obey it. Let it appear that you make it the law of your life, from which no temptation can swerve you. It is the life of the people of God to proclaim and act out heavenly principles. God has given you wisdom as a lamp for your feet in a dark path. Come what will, though heaven and earth pass away, hold fast to the light given, that not one jot or tittle of the principles God has laid before you be marred or dishonored. God accepts nothing less than absolute surrender of the mind, the heart, the will, the strength, the entire being, to his control. The Lord can guide. His voice will be heard in reproof, in warning, and in encouragement. Then there will be brought into the work a power which comes alone from God, simplifying all the movements of the life of the soul. This is as a thread of gold, binding man to God. Let those who are working upon wrong principles, whether with apparent failure or apparent success, remember that God never changes. His attributes are ever on the side of righteousness and truth. He can pluck down. He can build up. In full view of the world, let your voice and pen testify that God is truth, and that in him there is no variableness, neither shadow of turning.” The effect this had upon me was like a sudden shock, which overturned all that I had supposed was established in my plans for the immediate future. For a little while I was almost overwhelmed by the perplexities that it aroused; but after a season of prayer, in which Brother and Sister Durland and Miss Durland helped me to take it to the Lord, I found relief in a strong conviction that I should be safely led, that I need have no fear of being left to make any serious mistakes. This Testimony had at first seemed to me an arbitrary order to move upon that convention in some manner that would bring the very discussion I had so greatly dreaded. I have always dreaded anything like controversy. I am a woman given to peace. The sound of discussion has always been so painful that I could not endure to be mixed up in it. After that season of prayer at Brother Durland’s, in which the Spirit of the Lord was so manifestly poured out, I was relieved of all anxiety as to the part that I should play, or as to the outcome. Of course my face was still toward peace, even if I had to contend for it. At the time set, I came to Seattle, and took up the convention work that was laid upon me,—the work of preparing for and leading the evangelistic conferences,—at the same time giving Sabbath and Sunday, and the evenings of the week, to labor among our own people in their church in Seattle. In these meetings we had a most blessed manifestation of the Spirit of God from the first. They were a continual source of inspiration and strength, and of spiritual food, by which my strength was continually re-enforced. Among the first things in the convention work is the appointment of committees; and when Mrs. Katherine Lente Stevenson, of Massachusetts, our former National Corresponding Secretary, a woman of logical mind and most thorough consecration, in full harmony with the743 principles of religious liberty, upon whom any good cause can depend for candid consideration, was announced as the chairman of the Committee on Resolutions, I saw an opportunity such as I had not anticipated. I accordingly wrote out the following resolution, and sent it to her, hoping it might come in with her report before the convention, when I could simply speak to it like any other member, without any special prominence:— — Whereas. As a Woman’s Christian Temperance Union we most earnestly teach the principle and practise of Sabbath observance, and labor for the closing of the saloons on every day of every week, yet in order to free ourselves as an organization from a manifest inconsistency and impediment,— Resolved, That our plan of work shall be so changed as to remove from its departments everything that tends to sectarian controversy, or which can in any sense be made to interfere with perfect liberty of conscience as regards the days which shall be given to worship, rest, or labor, or which can be used to give aid or comfort to any who, through ignorance, prejudice, or malice, would enact, or so enforce, civil law as to interfere with the religious convictions of any and all people. I also sent a copy of this resolution to the Seventh-day Baptist sisters in the convention, and a few others, including Mrs. Clara C. Hoffman, national recording secretary, and president of the Missouri State W.C.T.U. Mrs. Hoffman assured me that she would speak to this resolution if it was brought in by the Committee on Resolutions. This committee, according to the program, was to bring in its report Monday afternoon, but was prevented by the failure of the printer to send in the sheets in time, and the report had to be made a special order for Tuesday. Monday evening Mrs. Stevenson remarked to me that she did the very best she could to get my resolution through the committee, but it was voted out. I sat meditating on what I should do, wondering if I should present it myself from the floor of the convention, when Mrs. Hoffman said to me, “Do you know that your resolution was thrown out?” I replied, “Yes, Mrs. Stevenson has told me so.” “Well,” she said, “I am going to present it myself, and speak to it.” It would be impossible for me to tell you the feelings that this statement produced. I could not have anticipated such an action on the part of any of our women. Mrs. Hoffman’s generous heart, however, is always equal to taking hold of any burden that she discovers is resting heavily upon any soul; and besides this, she is personally interested, for she said, “I believe in this and will be glad to speak upon it; would be glad to see it go through.” On Tuesday afternoon the Committee on Resolutions reported. The discussion that followed continued until an hour so late that I saw it would be impossible to have time for a free discussion of my resolution, and besides, many of the women had already left. But I determined to bring the resolution before the convention so as to hold the floor for it at some time the next day. By this time I had begun to realize that I was being led right along in the way of that Testimony, and that my first impression of its import had been right. I still shrank a little from the ordeal that was before me, yet I was profoundly thankful that I had so placed myself in the hands of God, had so surrendered my will to him, that he could lead me in spite of all my natural sense of weakness and shrinking, and bring even me to stand in a place that I would never choose, and give me courage for even a discussion such as I would never provoke, into which I would never enter of my own choice. I had that morning received a telegram from Brother Irwin, president of the General Conference, telling me to read 1 Sam. 10:7 and Isa. 41:10–13, which was an unspeakable comfort. My course was running close to the dark line of overwhelming temptation, but I did not touch it. All the way I could see the magnitude of the mercy of God, by which I was always to be kept from falling. During all that long discussion of the resolutions brought in by the committee I had been impressed more and more with the conflict between light and darkness, of which that organization is the battle-field; and knowing, as I do, the integrity of those women, my whole heart was filled with the most tender anxiety that they should be delivered from all darkness, and led into perfect light and all truth. From what I have already said, you have noticed that several copies of my resolution had been available for examination in the house. I knew that two or three women had seen it; for word had come to me from one that she should speak against it with all the strength she had; and, from later developments, I am confident that the opposition had made careful preparation to prevent even its discussion. But the matter was already in the hand of our invincible Leader, and he was to have his own way. I had sent a copy to the president, with a note saying that the resolution had been before the Committee on Resolutions, but that it had been voted out; that I wished to present it immediately after the report had been acted upon. When the moment came, and I arose, she recognized me at once, so I had my opportunity, although Mrs. Chambers, president of the Pennsylvania State Union, having gone to the platform with a paper in her hand, addressed the chair at the same instant. The floor being mine, however, I proceeded to read my resolution, and moved its adoption, which was at once seconded by Mrs. Hoffman, as well as by several others. Mrs. Hoffman moved that it should be made the special order for the next morning at 10:30, which was carried. Then Mrs. Chambers, who had remained standing, presented a resolution, which in its entire construction was calculated to cut off any possible discussion of mine as it then was. I have not a copy of Mrs. Chambers’s resolution, but it was to the effect that no department of work could be abolished, combined, divided, or in any way changed without giving a year’s notice beforehand to the official board, who should act upon it, and report to the Executive Committee. This would involve two years of work and waiting to make it possible for any material change to be made in any department of work. And this is a very wise provision. I saw at once that this resolution would commend itself to every woman as just and right, although it would be in the nature of a gate that must arbitrarily swing against both the good and the evil alike. It would absolutely prevent the hasty discussion or any precipitate reforms in any methods of work in the organization; and I was profoundly thankful that I had been so guided as to obtain the opportunity to present my resolution before the door was closed against it. If Mrs. Chambers had succeeded in getting the floor before me, as soon as my resolution had been read I should doubtless have been met by the statement that I was out of order. I should probably have seen that I was cut off, and sat helplessly silent. In the light of later developments, I am confident that Mr. Crafts was the instigator of this movement, although I did not at the time connect him with it. I was, however, sure that Mrs. Chambers had seen my resolution, and had done this in the hope to strangle my resolution before it could draw breath; and my mind began to work very busily to see how I could prevent myself from being shut off the next morning as soon as the special order was called. Sometimes I tried to make myself believe that this had been innocently done without any reference to my resolution, and yet in my heart I knew better; and when, a little later, Brother Fero asked me if I did not understand that this movement of Mrs. Chambers was intended to cut me off, I was compelled to acknowledge that it was so. I was, however, so sure of being led of God that I knew whatever was his will would be accomplished, and therefore gave it no very serious thought, leaving it to work out the Lord’s own appointment. The convention had held so late, and the work had been so heavy on me, that it was thought best to relieve me of the meeting in our church that night. Brother Durland had come over from Victoria, and it was decided that he should take the leading part, making the service such as would be most helpful to all, ministers and people, who had together felt the pressure of responsibility concerning the great question that was pending. Of the brethren and sisters in this vicinity I wish to make this record, that they took their full share of this work, according to their best understanding of it, sitting in the convention, breathing out an atmosphere of prayer and sympathy, coming to the meetings in the evening to listen to the word of God with a devotion that I shall never forget. The Seattle church is bound to me by a very sacred tie for all time. Brother Fero opened the meeting that Tuesday night with a few appropriate words, after which Brother Durland gave a brief lesson from 1 Cor. 15:58, which was full of meat, preparing us for the prayer service that was to follow. I had one burden that night, of which I had, however, no intention of speaking; but as the meeting progressed, and I recognized the spirit of true prayer that filled the house, I felt that it was safe to present it. As has been intimated, Dr. Wilbur F. Crafts was in attendance at the convention; and, knowing the strong hold which he had upon the W. C. T. U.,—and for good reason,—knowing him as having all the courage of strong convictions, believing him to be honest in those convictions, and determined to carry his point at whatever cost to himself, I had reason to desire that he might be prevented from taking his usual unlimited advantage of that convention. He has always been able to come upon the platform at any time, and to hold it as long as he chose upon any question. While I believe in Mr. Crafts as a man, regard him highly as a personal friend, yet I can not, must not, for a moment forget that he is a most determined antagonist in a matter that we both consider vital, an antagonist against whom the Lord himself must fight for me; and I was inexpressibly glad that I had been given to feel that it was safe for me to ask my brethren to pray that during the discussion that must follow the presentation of my resolution, he might in some way be restrained from sweeping it entirely off the floor; and during the prayers that were offered, I was confident that we were heard, and our petition granted according to the promise. That was a remarkable season of prayer. Only two or three prayers were offered, but the words spoken by the few were so supported by the faith of the congregation that it was indeed a united prayer. Before the close of the service I was ready for the morrow. Upon retiring I immediately fell asleep, as I have done every night, and slept without a single wave of anxiety to fret me in the slightest degree. But about two o’clock in the morning I was awakened with the two conflicting resolutions in my mind, and the conviction that I must do something to meet the emergency that had been sprung upon me. As early as possible I arose, and began to try so to change the wording of my resolution that it should still embody the points that must be discussed, and yet steer clear of the obstruction that had been placed in its way. I wrote and re-wrote all the morning, keeping Miss Durland busy with her type-writer, and had almost enough resolutions to stock a committee, when the time came for me to go to the church. I met Mrs. Hoffman before the convention was called, and she confirmed my conviction that my first resolution could not even get a hearing. I then showed her what I had prepared, but she said, “No; nothing that you have will do. Those women are wedded to that department of Sabbath Observance. I would like something on this question to go through. There is nothing in the world so terrible to come into our organization as religious intolerance; but you have nothing there that will even be given a hearing.” I was convinced that she was right. I had been so anxious to get some one point of the truth before those women that in everything I had as yet proposed, I had embodied more than a simple resolution ought to carry,—things which would more properly belong to the speeches made in its support,—and at last determined to cast out the simple, naked, undressed timber, upon which to sink or swim for that session. I retired to a quiet corner, and wrote the following:— Resolved, That as a National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union we protest against any such interpretation or use of any lines of our work as shall give aid or comfort to those who, through ignorance, prejudice, or malice, would enact or enforce such laws as can be made to serve the purpose of persecution, or to in any manner interfere with the most perfect liberty of conscience concerning days, or the manner of their observance. Miss Durland is busy preparing a report of the discussion that followed the presentation of this resolution. It will accompany this personal account. I am glad to have the whole story go to our faithful brethren and sisters, who have, I know, been following and supporting me with their prayers and sympathy in this, which from the distance looked like almost the greatest trial of my life, but which in passing has proved to be one of its greatest blessings; for I know that I never before realized so truly the wonderful sustaining power of God, and his marvelous leading in things for which I could not have been made ready by any wisdom of my own. After reading Miss Durland’s stenographic report of the proceedings, some may feel inclined to ask, What has been gained? for certainly the resolution that was at last substituted for mine, and passed by a large majority (although there were a great many votes against it), amounts to nothing. But there has been gain, large and material, as the brethren who were present could see even from their superficial view of it. But for my part, with the whole broad outlook of years before me, I can only hold myself in wondering gratitude before God at the manner in which he revealed his good hand spread out over us his children, who as yet are not able to see eye to eye in this matter. The answer to the prayers offered at my special request on Tuesday night was so evident that the most unbelieving and dull of comprehension must have recognized it. During that discussion, instead of being all over the platform, Dr. Crafts was down in the audience. Of course he was busy. He was amid the delegations, where he had no right. But in that very assumption of privilege under the circumstances, he injured himself. He wrote the resolution that was finally substituted for mine, and the women let him do it; but it was no help to him or to them in the minds of those who from the galleries were looking down upon the floor of the house, and watching proceedings with the most intense interest. He was called into the discussion by some of the women, but under circumstances that proved even to him that he was limited in his power over that convention. The cries of744 “No! No!” from all over the house, such as he never heard before from any W. C. T. U. convention. His large vote against allowing him to speak at all, and the limitation to three minutes, with the warning tap of the time-keeper’s little bell, were all too significant for him to ignore or forget. For further particulars I cite you to Miss Durland’s stenographic report. Another gain was in the discussion that brought into activity much that was latent in sympathy for justice and equal rights. There was also an awakening to the fact that liberty of conscience is actually in danger in the W. C. T. U., as an organization. Flashes of light were thrown on many points to which the majority of those women had never given a serious thought. They saw enough during that discussion to keep their eyes open from this time truthward; and the honesty of the hearts that had been aroused to this interest was manifested in many ways all the time thereafter until we finally separated for the work of the year that is before us; and that this subject will be the center of the next year’s thought and effort is assured by the fact that they know that at the next convention they must meet the amendment to the constitution, which you will find at the close of the report of proceedings. One of the leading women sent me the following note by a page, soon after the close of the discussion: “It was a victory, dear, taken all in all, and the righteous leaven is working. The women will yet understand just what your protest stands for, and it is so much better than if you and the other dear women had withdrawn. God reigns.” As I sat on the platform during that discussion, with the church full of faces turned toward me, I saw only expressions of sisterly sympathy and kindness; and oh, how my whole soul longed that they might understand this question as it stands out so clearly in the word of God! Some do, but many are still blind to the points of danger before the W. C. T. U.; and seeing them as I do, you can, I am sure, realize something of the burden of prayer that I am carrying for them, and what this next year’s work means to me. Not one of those women who led the opposition dreams how far over they are on the dark side of liberty. They could not even see that my contention is, not as to whether we should have liberty to worship as we choose or to keep the Sabbath, or that we have this liberty in Christ in spite of anybody, situated so far inside that it is beyond the power of any to interfere with it, but for liberty to labor without interference from the civil law during the full six days of the week, instead of being cut down to five. When at the next convention my amendment to the constitution comes up for discussion, I shall hope to make this issue stand out in such clear light that no one can help seeing it. One point gained in this effort is that I was able to see more clearly what has to be done in the future, and a better understanding all around was manifested at once, such as will tend to relieve prejudice and promote freedom of intercourse between us. Many of the women manifested their appreciation in a very characteristic manner, in the afternoon. I had sent Brother Fero’s name to the Committee on Courtesies, of which Anna Gordon, vice-president at large, was chairman, asking that he be introduced at the proper time to the convention, and allowed to say a few words. Introductions always take place on the second and last afternoons. He had been called on the first occasion, but was not present; so I was informed that there would be another opportunity, Wednesday. Just before he was to go up, I wrote a note to the president, telling her that Elder Fero was in charge of the Seventh-day Adventist work in this city and vicinity, and that I wished him introduced for just what he is. She quickly caught the spirit of my request, and did as I had asked distinctly, reaching out and taking him heartily by the hand, when from the delegations there came a quick, full round of applause. It was noticeable because of the fact that while many men who had preceded him had been applauded during their speeches, he was the only one who was received with applause before he had even reached the front of the platform. On Thursday morning at nine o’clock I went, by invitation, before the Post-Executive Committee, to have a little more personal talk with them concerning my own work. At this time I told them of our sisters who had come into the W. C. T. U. during the year, of the many who were inquiring about the consistency of Sabbath-keeping women belonging to an organization that aids Sunday legislation, and asked the Executive Committee to tell me what I should say to them. It was moved that this matter be thoroughly discussed in the Executive Committee, and that I should be informed of their action. I spoke of my desire again to take up evangelistic work as in former years; that I am able to travel, and do almost any amount of labor, when one of the women said:— “Well, what is to hinder?” “Only this,” I said, “that the women sometimes seem afraid of me, as if they did not know what I was going to do next.” Mrs. Stevens, the presiding officer, beside whom I was standing, then turned toward me, and said: “Afraid of you, Mrs. Henry? Have you seen any indications that the women are afraid of you? Just notice the manner in which you have been received at this convention,—your evangelistic conferences, and that lovely devotional hour yesterday!” “No, not you women here,” I replied, “but those out in the field. It is evident everywhere at first that the women are a little shy of me, as if they were afraid that I was going to promulgate some offensive doctrine instead of laboring for the salvation of souls.” At this Mrs. Boole, president of the New York State W. C. T. U., arose and said:— “Madam President: I would like to say just a word to Mrs. Henry in answer to this. It is true that the women are shy, and Mrs. Henry will bear with me,—I speak of it with all kindness,—it is because of the leaflet which she has sent broadcast, which has forced the consideration of the seventh day as the Sabbath upon so many of our women.” I then asked the privilege of making an explanation, which was granted. I said that this leaflet was sent out for the purpose of informing the women of the change in my belief before I should accept my reappointment as national evangelist, which had just been announced to me from St. Louis, in 1896. I said: “The general officers here all know that I held my acceptance of that reappointment in abeyance until I should hear from the women; and it was only after I had heard from them in such kind and sisterly utterances that I wrote and forwarded to the national secretary my acceptance of this reappointment.” There was assent to this fact, and I could see that by this statement the minds of the women were relieved of a shadow which had been between us. Among other things, Mrs. Boole said, “I honor any woman who will stand by her honest convictions as Mrs. Henry has done in this convention;” and by many other expressions indicated that she had been aroused to a genuine interest, and that our old-time friendship had in no way abated, but was strengthened by the things that had taken place. I have been thus explicit, have given this story in detail, that you, my brethren, may see and judge of the true and candid hearts that beat in the breasts of these women; and that you may, because of this, become interested to follow them in their educational and rescue work until you shall be able to see in it the grand fulfilment of that prophecy contained in Ps. 68:11, and to know that in his own time and way God will so purge this branch of his vine that it shall bring forth more and more fruit for his house, and that you may have for these, my sisters of the W. C. T. U., a genuine spirit of prayer such as prevails with God.