D. T. BOURDEAU.
(Concluded)
Roman Catholic Priest.— The church did not have the whole Bible for centuries. Christ said, “As my Father has sent me, so have I sent you.”
Seventh-day Adventist Minister.— The books of the New Testament were in circulation even in the first century. They were exchanged among the churches, passed from one church to another, and read. Take, for example, this one injunction from Paul, which does not present an exception, as the principle involved includes all the epistles, etc.: “And when this epistle is read among you, cause that it be read also in the church of the Laodiceans; and that ye likewise read the epistle from Laodicea.” Col. 4:16. Of course the books of the New Testament were written to be read by all. It has been truthfully said that if all the New Testament were lost, it could, with the exception of fewer than a score of verses, be reproduced from quotations in the writings of the early Fathers. And why did the Fathers write?—For others to read, as well as themselves. In their writings the Holy Scriptures are lauded as desirable for all, and of course the masses had them, and read them. And this was in perfect harmony with God’s imperative commands anciently, that the people, the kings and the priests should read and acquaint themselves with the Scriptures. Deut. 11:18-21; 17:18; Nehemiah 8; etc. God the Father sent Christ to teach the Scriptures, and he sent the disciples to do the same, and they obeyed him, encouraging those who heard them to follow their example in studying, teaching, and obeying the Holy Scriptures.
P.— Peter himself says that there are in Paul’s epistles things “hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.” 2 Peter 3:16.
M.— The unlearned referred to by Peter were the very ones who were not informed as to what the Scriptures taught, not as to what men taught outside the Scriptures. All the human learning and knowledge in the world would not, independently of learning based on Scripture, secure to one an understanding of the Sacred Word. The Bible must be studied with prayer, and with a thirst for the true meaning, in order to be understood. Those who thus study it will be stable, not unstable and wavering.
P.— The pope is the infallible head of the church; and the bishop, or pope, of Rome has ever been regarded as such by the Catholic Church. Jesus Christ made Peter the first pope, the head of the church.
M.— Will you put your finger on the chapter and verse in the Bible where it is said that the pope is the head of the church, or that he is infallible, or that Jesus Christ made him the head of the church? It is not there. Paul declares that “Christ is the head of the church.” Eph. 5:23. Does the church have two heads?
P.— Christ is the invisible head of the church; the pope is her visible head.
M.— What Bible proof have you for those statements? What authority have you for making such a distinction? You do not even have a Bible right to use the word “pope,” or “father,” in the sense you give to it, applying to the pope an attribute that belongs to God alone. Exposing this very practise of putting man in the place of God, Christ says, “And call no man your father upon the earth: for one is your Father, which is in heaven.” Matt. 23:9. If you are acquainted with the history of the fourth century, you very well know about the almost endless controversies of the Catholic Church in the days of Constantine to settle the question whether the bishop of Rome or the bishop of Alexandria should be the first of all bishops. If the matter of the infallibility of the pope of Rome has always been settled, how does it happen that a council was held at Rome in 1870 to settle it? And if the pope was always generally regarded by Catholics as the head of the church, and as having the supremacy, why did the Greek Catholics separate from the Latin Catholics in the eleventh century, refusing to acknowledge the pope’s supremacy?
P.— Christ did make Peter the head of the church by telling him, “Thou art Peter [Greek, ‘a stone’], and upon this rock I will build my church.” Matt. 16:18. Peter is the rock upon which the church was to be built. The Hebrew-Syriac tongue, in which this passage was first written, makes no distinction between a stone and a rock. There is only one word for both.
M.— No tongue is so crude as not to distinguish between an ordinary stone and a rock. The Greek and Latin versions make this distinction; and if they do this, it is because they give the sense of the text as found in the language in which it was first written. They can not both be wrong. Christ is the big stone, which he intended by the expression “this rock.” He declares himself to be “the stone which the builders rejected” (Matt. 21:42); and of him, Paul says, “For other foundation can no man lay than that is laid, which is Jesus Christ.” 1 Cor. 3:11.