IS ALCOHOL A NECESSITY?

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 21, 1899

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 47.

Read the full edition

IS ALCOHOL A NECESSITY?

Dr. B. W. Richardson, in Christian Advocate.
My research first begun in this question did not begin as a research intended to prove that the spirit was not a warmth-giver. I was engaged by the British Association for the Advancement of Science to make a series of researches on another class of chemical substances, but allied to alcohol. I was looking at this substance as I might look at chloroform, ether, and methylene, substances which allay pain; and in the course of my research I made a note-book table, in which I noted certain effects that were important to know. I observed, for instance, whether the pulse was quickened by any agent which I might be trying, whether the breathing was changed, whether there were any convulsive starts in the muscles, if there was sleep produced, if the pupil of the eye dilated or contracted; and I observed, among other things, and perhaps the most important of all, whether the temperature of the body was changed, because if we were administering an agent which was producing fever, that would be a bad agent, or an agent that would bring the body down to deathly cold, that would be a bad agent.
For this reason the temperature was carefully watched, and in the course of my research, going from one substance to another, at last I came upon this strong spirit, when it took effect at all, was to reduce the temperature. This was not credited. I read the statement to the Birmingham meeting of the British Association, and so many objections were taken to the statement,—Professor Ackland, I think, was in the chair,—and such inquiry was made as to the mode of research, that I at last determined, reluctantly determined, to withdraw that part of the report in order that twelve months might be expended in ascertaining whether there were any sources of fallacy.
That time was expended, and more, and confirmed the result,—a result which has never since been disputed or in any way denied,—a result so strikingly manifested that some medical men, when they meet with a senseless person in the street, who is either intoxicated or in apoplexy, use the thermometer as the test, knowing that if the body is colder by two or three degrees than it should be, the chances are almost nine to ten that the cause of the insensibility is alcohol; whereas, if the temperature is above normal, the probabilities are that it is apoplexy.
Indeed, there is no physiological truth better established than this one: that strong spirit taken into the body reduces the temperature. I tried this in other ways. I let pigeons feed on alcoholic spirit, take it with their food, and let them live in the cold weather, some with the spirit and some without it; and I found that there was a certain measure of feeding in that way that inevitably led to the death of the birds, while the others were unaffected. That bore out the Arctic researches.
While I was thus proceeding, there was another physician, since gone over to the majority, experimenting in a different manner, but with results that came close to mine. That was the late Dr. Edward Smith, who was investigating on the respiration. He was taking and administering foods of various kinds, and by means of a fine balance into which he could breathe, he was calculating the product from the burning of his own body and the weight of the gas that was given off from the burning. Burning is produced by different foods, and he came strangely enough to this conclusion, from the facts before him, that the taking of alcohol reduced the product. He came to me one morning with a series of tables, showing me this, and said, “How remarkable that you should have found the decline of temperature, and that I should have found the decline of the animal fire, and that there is really less burning as calculated by the product.” So those two questions came forward for discussion together, and they have both been since connected as corroborative the one of the other in the same way.
Here, then, is a paradox. It is quite true that this strong spirit resembles a food that will burn in the body; it is quite true that this strong spirit will itself burn out of the body; but in the body it does not burn. It can not burn; because the temperature goes down under it, and because the products of burning are reduced. Common experience, coming to our assistance, shows this on all sides, and we are so conversant with the fact that there are not a few medical men who prescribe alcohol in fever as an agent that will reduce the febrile state. It will do so; it does it at a great cost, and I do not advocate it; at the same time, it is an agent that will reduce the animal temperature.