“A VERY NASTY SOUND” INDEED.
Even Harper’s Weekly now stands among the apologists for slavery within the jurisdiction of the United States in the Philippines. The weekly has an official correspondent in the Philippines. In the issue of Nov. 18, 1899, there is a two-page article on the subject, by this correspondent, in which he writes as follows:— It has a very nasty sound—and one likely to arouse all very good people to a pitch of frenzied indignation—to say that within the territory now owned by the United States, in spite of the Thirteenth Amendment and the war of the Rebellion, slavery still exists. And yet slavery in the Sulus is by no means the dreadful thing that the word suggests. There are many free American citizens who have less liberty of action and opportunity to do what they please than the Sulu slave. The social system among the Moros is much more primitive than it is among the greater part of the other Philippine races. A chief, or dato, controls a district; he has his own particular followers and his slaves; besides these, he may command all the men of his own district in time of war. He also has the right of life and death over his subjects. For instance, a few weeks before we arrived in Jolo, Dato Jokanine had occasion to execute one of his followers. The man had been entrusted with money belonging to the dato. The first time, he came to his chief and said: “O great and benevolent dato, I have gambled away thy money; forgive me!” “Very well,” said the dato; “see that it does not happen again.” Once more the retainer came, saying: “O great and benevolent dato, again have I gambled away thy money, and again I beg thee, in thy great mercy, to forgive me.” “This is the second time I have forgiven thee,” said Jokanine; “but the third time, I warn thee, thou shalt die.” Yet again the unfortunate man returned without the money he had collected for the dato. “O dato,” he cried, throwing himself at the feet of his chief, “I have sinned again and taken thy money; mercy! mercy!” “Cut him down,” said the dato to one of his men-at-arms. The man offered no resistance, and was cut to pieces with one of the great knives of the natives. Another story, which shows well the authority held by a dato over his people, is worth the telling. It seems that a blacksmith had been making love, in a773 quiet way, to a member of the harem of Dato Jokanine. Jokanine knew of this, and came to the man’s smithy one day. The smith was just finishing off a large barong. “Let me see that knife,” said Jokanine. Then, running his finger along the edge, he added, “It seems sharp; may I try it?” “Certainly, dato,” said the unsuspecting smith. Without a second’s hesitation, Jokanine raised the knife and split the smith to the chin. The right a master has to kill his slave is therefore no stronger right than that exercised by all the datos and the sultan over the life of every man in Sulu. Such well-authenticated stories as these show how lightly these people prize life. Indeed, if one freeman kills another, the murderer is brought before one of the datos and fined one hundred and eight Mexican dollars, or fifty-four dollars in gold. There is, however, no fine for killing a slave. Slavery among the Sulus does not originate in difference of race or color; neither has it its origin in war. The slaves are of the same race as their masters, and are for the most part acquired in payment of past debts. Thus, if a man owes you a large sum of money, he may sell himself or his children to you, and thus cancel the debt. Girls are sold for hard cash, I believe, but it is not a common occurrence, nor one which takes place against the will of the girl. If a slave runs away from his master, and returns to his original home, declaring that he positively refuses to serve the master any longer, the custom is for the family to get together and pay the original debt, thus releasing the slave. Of course the slave is bound to work, but, as a rule, he only works when his master works, and as that is a matter of very infrequent occurrence, slavery in the Sulus can not be called an arduous occupation. The slave eats and sleeps in the same house as his master; he is treated more as a retainer than as a slave. The children of Sulu slaves are also slaves, but they have especial privileges, and are considered family retainers. It is considered a disgrace to sell one of these slaves. In fact, it is merely because we have no more accurate word to describe the condition that I use the word “slavery.” The status is really one between the serfdom of the Middle Ages and the peonage of Mexico. Through the diplomacy and patience of General Bates, these Moro people have become our friends, and at the same time have granted us greater privileges than the Spaniards had, not least among these being the privilege of an American to buy land. It would be foolish to overlook the fact, however, that this treaty does not materially touch the institutions of the country, at least two of which are contrary to our Constitution and laws—slavery and polygamy. I have endeavored to show that slavery, as it exists in the Sulus, works little or no hardship to the native, that it is far removed from the conventional idea of slavery, and really resembles only in name the status of our North American negroes before the Rebellion. Moreover, any radical interference on our part with the existing institutions of the Moros would unite them against us. The method pursued by General Bates in his negotiations was the English one of playing off the local jealousies of different chiefs against one another, not treating only with the sultan, but with all the leaders. This method was possible because the interests involved in the sultan’s case were selfish ones. The datos knew this, and sided with us, knowing that they would receive a regular, if small, allowance from the American government. The question of slavery is different. To touch more than lightly upon national institutions would be to strike at the very root of social life. General Bates showed exceedingly great tact in the clause of the treaty concerning slavery. Slaves may purchase their freedom for twenty dollars, Mexican money. Only slowly can slavery be eradicated from a country without doing great wrong to property owners; and it is to be hoped that Congress, when it comes to act, will see the advisability of letting the present treaty stand as it is—at least for the present. Polygamy is an institution so connected with the Mohammedan religion that the clause of the treaty protecting the religion of the country practically protects polygamy. The Moros have generally several wives. They are, of course, limited by the Koran to four, and but few have the full number. Besides these wives they have innumerable concubines. If one of the concubines of the sultan bears him a child, she immediately becomes his wife, provided, of course, that the number of his wives is not already complete. Slavery, as it exists among the Moros, can only be abolished gradually, by a judicious series of moves, such as the one made by General Bates in the treaty just signed. Polygamy is even more deeply rooted in a Moro, and will disappear only when Islam has lost its hold over him. If the land of the Sulu group and Mindanao prove the land of promise that some hope,—if American enterprise and capital gradually change the country from a jungle to a paradise of tobacco, hemp, and coffee plantations,—then the Moro and his institutions will gradually be shoved out, succumbing, as our North American Indians succumbed, to the superior race. Until that time comes, by all means let the Moro live in peace; let his children chant the Koran, and his wives weave rough cloth. Of growth he may be capable; but if you force him too hard, he will struggle and fight against progress, and adopt our worst rather than our best qualities. Our civilization, good and bad as it is, is a process of gradual evolution, and you can not expect a wild race to change too suddenly. Our unwillingness to take the other man’s view has wrought trouble for us in Luzon, and the wise ones say: “Beware how you meddle with the institutions of the Moros of Sulu and and Mindanao!” “And yet slavery in the Sulus is by no means the dreadful thing that the word suggests”!!! The chief has “the right of life and death” not only over his slaves, but over his subjects, and he exercises that power according to frightful examples given; “and yet slavery in the Sulus is by no means the dreadful thing the word suggests”!!! One “freeman” can kill another, and the murder be atoned for by cash—“one hundred and eight Mexican dollars, or fifty-four dollars in gold;” he can kill a slave, and make no answer at all; “and yet slavery in the Sulus is by no means the dreadful thing that the word suggests”!!! All this can be practised upon human beings, and yet their condition be so altogether pleasant that “it is merely because we have no more accurate word to describe the condition that” “the word ‘slavery’” can be used at all with reference to it! All this “works little or no hardship to the native”! “it is far removed from the conventional idea of slavery”! “and really resembles only in name the status of our North American negroes before the Rebellion”! And Harper’s Weekly prints and passes along all this as proper and acceptable for its columns!! And all this is carried on under the supreme law—for a treaty is part of the supreme law—of the United States; and is further sanctioned by the payment of ten thousand dollars a year from the United States treasury to these slave-holding, murderous, polygamous chiefs. True, all this is not carried on under the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution; for these documents are repudiated. It is acknowledged that it is “contrary to our Constitution and laws.” It is plainly said to be “in spite of the Thirteenth Amendment” to the Constitution. In view of all this, if the United States is not repudiating “every principle of its Constitution as a republican government,” then what would be such a thing? If that is not “national apostasy,” then how can there ever be such a thing as national apostasy in this land?