Speaking of the Thanksgiving proclamation issued by the governor of New York, the Christian Advocate says that with only the proclamation to work from, no one could “ascertain whether he is a Mohammedan, a Jew, or a Christian.” Well, why not? Was not the proclamation made to “the people of this State”? And among the people of that State are there not Mohammedans, Jews, Christians, and pagans? Why should one particular class be singled out to give thanks and to pray?
Whose Thanksgiving? Questioning the Governor's Proclamation
From Review and Herald, Vol. 76, No. 49., December 5, 1899