[On a recent Sunday, the “Rev. Father Hines” of Manistee, Mich., delivered a sermon on “Sunday in its Relations to the Columbian Exposition.” In his sermon he made reference to the Sunday as a Sabbath, in the following language, as published in the Manistee Democrat of Oct. 25. It is very refreshing to find a man who can tell so much of truth. D. H. Lamson.]
SYNOPSIS OF AN ADDRESS DELIVERED AT HOLY TRINITY CHURCH LAST SUNDAY NIGHT, BY THE REV. FATHER HINES.
He read as a text the words, “One man esteemeth one day above another: another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.” Rom. 14:5. The speaker said that during the past year, there had been quite a controversy in this country, in regard to the opening of the Columbian Exposition on Sunday. Some claim that it should be open for the benefit of workingmen and their families, because they cannot attend on any other day. Others contend that to open it on Sunday will desecrate the Sabbath and bring down upon us the curse of Heaven; and that the workingman can attend on some other day, and if not, he must not attend on that day anyway. The reverend gentleman asked his congregation to lay aside all prejudice, in order that they might examine the subject calmly, honestly, fairly, and fully. He said that there was a vast amount of rubbish which had accumulated about this subject, which must be swept away before we could intelligently understand the question at issue. The first thing to be noticed was, that our Sunday is not the Sabbath day of the Bible. In these modern days, many people use the words interchangeably, as though they meant one and the same thing, but they do not. The Sabbath day is the seventh, or last, day of the week. And the first can no more be made the seventh, than the second day can be made the fifth. The Sabbath day is as old as man, and was in memory of creation.
Sunday as Christian holy day, only dates from the time of the apostles, and is in memory of our redemption. The Sabbath was a solemn fast day; Sunday is a joyful festival. Here then is the first thing to be remembered in a discussion of this subject. Our Sunday is not the Sabbath of the Bible; it is a different day of the week, established with a different object in view, and kept in a different manner.
The next thing to be considered is, that there is no authority in the Bible for keeping Sunday as a holy day. The speaker referred to the fact, that when the Seventh-day Adventists held their tent meeting here last summer, they offered to give fifty dollars to any person who would show them one text of Scripture which required the keeping of Sunday as a holy day. Yet no one accepted the offer. After all the talk of Protestant ministers, about Sunday being the Sabbath day, and about their being Bible and Bible only Christians, and that they take the Bible for their guide, they by their silence virtually confessed that they do not believe what they preach, and that there is no authority in the Bible for keeping Sunday. The observance of Sunday rests not upon the Bible, but upon the canon law of the holy Catholic Church. It rests upon the same authority as the observance of Friday as a fast day, or the observance of Christmas, Lent, Easter, Ascension, or Pentecost. In a word, it is simply a Catholic festival, established by the church as the weekly memorial of Christ’s resurrection from the dead, even as the Friday fast is a Catholic holy day, established by the same authority, in memory of Christ’s death upon Calvary. The Sunday feast, like the Friday fast, is binding only upon Catholic Christians, and is to be observed in accordance with the law of the church which ordained them. Then the question is, How does the church require us to observe Sunday? First, by abstaining as far as possible from all unnecessary labor; secondly, by attendance upon the public services of the church. This is all. Outside of the hours of church services, she does not dictate to us as to what we may or may not do, in regard to social pleasure and innocent recreation. She leaves the matter to the individual conscience, and in the language of St. Paul in my text, says, “Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.” As Bishop Potter of New York expresses it, in the October number of the Forum, in which he pleads for the opening of the Columbian Exposition on Sunday, “The Christian Sunday of primitive times was spent very much as we now observe Christmas and Thanksgiving day.”
With these facts before us, we are now prepared for the question, “Ought the Columbian Exposition to be open on Sunday?” First of all, however, we must consider the statement of the officers of the World’s Fair, that it was not their intention to have the machinery running, nor to barter and trade on Sunday. All was to be still. They would only keep sufficient men on duty to watch and protect the property, but open the gates for visitors to see the wonderful works of art and nature. This being true, I see no harm in opening the Exposition on Sunday. It violates no law of the church, and as we have seen, there is no divine law on the question, except so far as the law of the church is the law of God. I confess that if I had my way, I would close the gates on Sunday morning, but open them wide in the afternoon and evening. He said that he could see no difference between walking through the Exposition grounds and buildings on Sunday, and walking through the parks of Chicago, or walking and driving through the streets of Manistee.p. 759
The speaker said that he advocated the opening of the Exposition on Sunday, because it was in favor of good morals. The saloons, gambling houses, and places of ill repute are all open wide on Sunday. A closed Exposition meant a large patronage for all these places. Hence the Wine and Spirit Gazette, the official organ of the liquor dealers and the saloon-keepers of Chicago, were all in favor of a closed Exposition on Sunday, because it would be profitable for their business. Some say let the people go to church. The answer is, that many do not wish to go; there is no law to compel them to go, and you have no right to pass such a law. Not only so, but there is not church accommodation for one half the permanent residents of Chicago, at any one service, to say nothing about the great influx of visitors at that time. This attempt to close up the Exposition on Sunday is a move in the wrong direction, and will be destructive to good morals.
He also advocated an open Exposition on Sunday for the benefit of the working men and their families, thousands of whom could not possibly see it any other day. He also advocated it upon the ground of personal liberty, and declared that this government had no right to pass Sunday laws to compel its religious observance, or which restricted the rights and liberties of the people.
The speaker said that some might remind him that Congress had already decided that it shall be closed on Sunday. He admitted this, but claimed that this action did not express their convictions on this question, and might not be final. Their action was not in favor of religion, good morals, justice, nor liberty. Having lived in Chicago, he knew whereof he spoke. Their action was based upon fear, forged documents, and bogus petitions. It was through fear that they might lose votes in the pending election, and it was based upon forged documents to a certain extent, at least; for he had seen it stated, and so far as he knew, it was not contradicted, that the States of Michigan and Rhode Island had sent to Congress petitions in favor of Sunday-closing, containing more signatures than the last census gave them population. This being true, they were evidently a gross, willful, and deliberate fraud.
The speaker said that the working men were now being heard from, and other petitions were being prepared to send to the next session of Congress, and he hoped and believed that it would rescind its former action, when the pending election was out of the way.