SUNDAY LAWS; THEIR ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT.
By W. A. Colcord
The present movement for the enforcement of Sunday observance naturally suggests an inquiry into the history, nature, and object of Sunday laws. It is being urged that the present Sunday laws should be more vigorously enforced, and new measures be enacted. We ask, Why so? What is the need of Sunday laws at all? Whom are they for, the religious or the irreligious? Law, in civil government, means compulsion. Are Sunday laws to compel those who believe in keeping Sunday to keep the day, or to compel those who do not believe in keeping Sunday to keep it? Sunday-keeping is a religious institution. Sunday laws must therefore be religious laws, and the enforcement of them upon those who do not believe in keeping the day, religious persecution. This is the logic of the case. A brief examination of the origin and development of Sunday laws may better aid in determining their nature and object. During the early centuries of the Christian era, Christianity spread rapidly over the Roman Empire. By the beginning of the fourth century, the persecution of Christians had largely ceased. Christianity had become popular, and, according to church historians, greatly corrupted. Sunday was the day which for ages had been dedicated by the heathen to their chief god, the sun. Through what was at first doubtless only an innocent custom, it had by this time also come to be regarded by Christians, especially in Western Rome, as a religious day. Constantine, who was then emperor, issued, in the year 321 A. D., the following decree:— Let all the judges and the townspeople, and the occupation of all trades, rest on the venerable day of the sun; but let those who are situated in the country, freely, and at full liberty, attend to the business of agriculture; because it often happens that no other day is so fit for sowing corn and planting vines; lest, the critical moment being let slip,503 men should lose the commodities granted of heaven.
—Schaff’s Church History, vol. 2, chap. 3, p. 105. This, according to “Chambers’ Encyclopedia” (Article “Sabbath”), is “the first law, ecclesiastical or civil, by which the sabbatical observance of that day is known to have been enjoined.” It was, indeed, quite a “civil” affair, allowing husbandry to be carried on “freely and at full liberty.” While it was doubtless amply sufficient to satisfy all the requirements of the heathen worshipers of the sun, it did not, however, meet all the demands of the Christian leaders of those times. It allowed too much labor. Its exemption was too liberal. A church council was called not long after, known as the Council of Laodicea, held in 364. The twenty-ninth canon passed at this council reads as follows:— Christians shall not Judaize, and be idle on Saturday, but shall work on that day. But the Lord’s day they shall especially honor, and, as being Christians, shall, if possible, do no work on that day. If, however, they are found Judaizing, let them be shut out from Christ.
—Hefele’s History of the Councils, vol. 1, p. 316. Whatever effect this may have had in suppressing the observance of Saturday, the seventh day, which up to this time had been sacredly regarded by many of the most pious Christians, it did not prevent all from laboring on Sunday, or from attending games and amusements, in preference to church service on that day. Further legislation was thought to be necessary. Says Neander:— By a law of the year 386, those older changes effected by the Emperor Constantine were more rigorously enforced, and in general, civil transactions of every kind on Sunday were strictly forbidden.
—Neander’s History of the Christian Church (edition 1852), vol. 2, p. 300. But the services of the sanctuary could not successfully compete with the attractions of the circus and theater. It was thought by the church officers that a civil law might more effectually regulate this matter also. Consequently, at a church convention held at Carthage in 401, the bishops passed a resolution to send up a petition to the emperor, praying:— That the public shows might be transferred from the Christian Sunday and from feast days to some other days of the week.—Id.
The reason given in support of the petition was:— The people congregate more to the circus than to the church, and it is not fitting that Christians should gather at the spectacles, since the exercises there are contrary to the precepts of God; and if they were not open, the Christians would attend more to things divine.—Id.
The bishops wanted a “civil” law to favor church attendance. The desired law was secured in 425 A. D., upon which Neander thus remarks:— In the year 425, the exhibitions of spectacles on Sunday, and upon the principal feast days of the Christians, were forbidden, in order that the devotion of the faithful might be free from all disturbance. In this way the church received help from the state for the furtherance of her ends, which could not be obtained in the preceding period. But had it not been for that confusion of spiritual and secular interests, had it not been for the vast number of mere outward conversions thus brought about, she would have needed no such help.—Id., p. 301.
The laws thus far asked for were not to compel people to attend church, but to close on Sunday every place but the churches at which they could attend. But the law system for the support and protection of religious institutions in the interests of the church having been adopted, it was natural that it should be carried to its logical ends. A little later, Justinian made a “civil” proclamation, giving all men in the Roman Empire three months to embrace Christianity, or lose all office, property, or right of inheritance. (Bower’s “History of the Popes,” vol. 2, p. 334.) But even this did not have the effect of getting everybody to attend church. It was left for Charlemagne, in the year 800, to make a “civil” Sunday law, compelling all to attend church. Here is a copy of his law:— We do ordain, as it is required in the law of God, that no man shall do any servile work on the Lord’s day; namely, that they employ not themselves in works of husbandry, making hay, fencing or hedging, grubbing and felling trees, digging in the mines, building houses, planting orchards; and that they go not a-hunting in the fields, or plead in courts of justice; that women weave not or dress cloth, do no needlework or card wool, or beat hemp, or wash linen openly, or shear sheep; but that they all come to church to magnify the Lord their God, for those good things which, on this day, he bestowed on them.—Craft’s Sabbath for Man, p. 556.
This, in brief, is the history of Sunday laws, and this their natural development and logical outcome. They are religious; and, consequently, to compel people to act religiously, attend church, and support places of religious worship, are but their natural requirements when fully developed. This is their real design, no matter under what pretext they may at first be urged.