GOOD-CITIZENSHIP MOVEMENT

4%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Jul 25, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 29.

Read the full edition

GOOD-CITIZENSHIP MOVEMENT.

“Christianity” in Politics.

The Pacific Coast Endeavorer in discussing the entrance of Christian Endeavorers into politics, speaks of the opposition which the movement is meeting, and continues:—
This is a day of judgment for the politician and the office-holder. Behind him is a powerful citizenship, reinforced by all that is true in political righteousness and all that is just in God. The time has come when no politician can safely overlook this powerful constituency which is determined to make the state better.
And in this way have those “reformers” always talked who have attempted to reform the world through politics. Note the assumptions: This constituency for which the “good-citizenship” movement stands, and which in turn is fostered, cherished, supported, by the Christian Endeavor organization, “is reinforced by all that is true in political righteousness and all that is just in God.” What opportunity is there then for any other political or religious party, the members of which may not think that all “political righteousness” or “all that is just in God” is found in the Christian Endeavor “good-citizenship” movement? It will be obvious to all that those who would oppose such a movement politically or religiously would be considered enemies to the country and its government, and if power sufficient were obtained, they would be treated as such, by disfranchisement, confiscation of goods, banishment, or death, especially if their opposition were strong and persistent. The religio-political threat and boycott is clearly intimated in the closing sentence of the quotation.
That all this is evident will be seen by further quotations from the Endeavorer:—
So much for the general principle of the good-citizenship movement. The time has gone by when a man can be a good citizen and a poor Christian. The time has come when to be a good Christian and a poor citizen is to be a hypocrite. The Christian man must be a citizen of the highest type. Every man who calls himself a man in these days must take hold of the political machines, not as a Protestant, or a Catholic, or a Methodist, or a Congregationalist, but as a responsible Christian citizen.
This self-assumed judge as to whether a man is a “good Christian” or not, is this Christian Endeavor good-citizenship movement, or such a tribunal as it may set up. “This is a day of judgment,” says the Endeavorer, and “the time has come when to be a good Christian and a poor citizen [according to the good-citizenship standard] is to be a hypocrite.” It does not make any difference what he calls his name, we are told, but he must take hold of the political machine according to their idea of a “Christian citizen.”
It is but just to state that in this same article the Endeavorer says that “it is not wise for the Christian Endeavor Society as an organization to go into politics.” It presents what the New York Sun has to say in the same line as “worthy of the most serious reflection,” and continues:—
The Christian Endeavor Society must not take the organization into politics, but it must teach the civic duty, instruct in political obligation, give courage and inspiration to the young men who go to the polls. But it must not arbitrarily dictate, or intrigue, or “manage.” It must be a political inspiration, not a political machine.
And yet this is just what the Christian Endeavor Society proposes to do through the “good-citizenship movement.” It proposes to sit in judgment on men’s Christianity, politics, etc., and to brand as “hypocrites” those who do not meet the standard of the Christian Endeavor citizenship. It does not deem it wise for the organization to go into politics, nor must it “arbitrarily dictate” or “manage” its members. It will, however, meet all this in a more effectual way by arraigning, condemning, branding, banishing, those who do not reach the standard of “Christian citizenship” which the Christian Endeavor Society has erected. Let us see by the Endeavorer’s own statement. It is a notorious fact that Protestants have held—whether true or not we will not here inquire or attempt to prove, for it is not germane to the argument—that Roman Catholic prelates and priests have been the most persistent intermeddlers and intriguers in politics. Well, the Endeavorer proposes to adopt the same method. It quotes a criticism from the Monitor (Roman Catholic) of San Francisco, and comments thereon as follows:—
The discriminating suggestion of the New York Sun is much more to the point than the criticisms of the Monitor of San Francisco, and the Sacramento Bee. These papers strongly object to the Christian Endeavorers having anything to do with the government. The Monitor declares that “if the Christian Endeavor societies keep on interfering in politics, after a short time there will be no Christian Endeavor Society.” It suggests that rabbis and Catholic priests organize and tell their followers how to vote! This is a sweet bit of innocence on the part of the Monitor. It assumes that the Catholic priest is out of politics, but it knows that every priest carries votes in his vest pocket. We propose to keep company with the Catholic priest, and let him very distinctly understand that a Christian Endeavorer has the same right to go into politics as a Roman Catholic priest.
And what will this be but an image to the beast, the union of church and state formed in the Dark Ages? The Endeavorer then quotes from another paper, and shows that its political machine will not stop if necessary, short of banishment of those who may oppose its ideas of “Christian citizenship:”—
The Sacramento Bee says: “Let us have equal rights in this matter. Let all religious organizations get into the political scramble, and then see what a magnificent country this would be from which to emigrate.” We agree with the Bee. This country needs an exodus; and when once Christians get into politics, somebody will feel very uncomfortable. SOMEBODY MUST EMIGRATE, and the country will be the better for the emigration.
And this is true “National Reform” doctrine. “Christian” citizenship will demand “Christian” officials and a “Christian” Constitution, but always according to the ideas of the Christian-Endeavor-Christian-citizenship movement, and not after Christ. Mr. W. J. Coleman, a prominent National Reformer, said in the Christian Statesman of November 1, 1883:—
I believe that the existence of a Christian Constitution would logically disfranchise every logically consistent infidel.
But who are considered infidels by these “reformers”?—Every one who does not agree with their religious dogmas and political methods. The “logically consistent infidel” is the one who will honestly and consistently oppose the National Reform, Christian Endeavor, “good-citizenship” standard of faith. The more honest and truly courageous he is, the surer is he to be disfranchised; for if not honest he will act the part of the hypocrite, as every selfishly dishonest politician will. The Puritan Parliament “solemnly resolved that no person shall be employed but such as the House shall be satisfied with his real godliness.” As the result, hypocrites were multiplied.
That our conclusions concerning the kind of men which will be adjudged as infidels in this “Christian” government to be, is not too strong, take the following from another prominent “National Reformer,” Rev. Jonathan Edwards. He names four classes which would be considered atheists, because they oppose what he calls “Christian” government: Atheists, deists, Jews, and Seventh-day Baptists. He says:—
These are all for the occasion, and, so far as our amendment [to Christianize the Constitution] is concerned, one class. They use the same arguments and the same tactics against us. They must be counted together. . . . They must be named from him [the atheist, the infidel], they must be treated as one party.
Then in the same speech he further says:—
Tolerate atheism, sir? There is nothing out of hell that I would not tolerate as soon.
Again, Mr. Edwards says in an address which the National Reform Association has published to the world:—
What are the rights of the atheist? I would tolerate him as I would tolerate a poor lunatic, for, in my mind, he is scarcely sound. So long as he does not rave, so long as he is not dangerous, I would tolerate him. I would tolerate him as a conspirator. The atheist is a dangerous man. He not only rejects and opposes my faith [Italics ours], but he aims to overthrow every institution, and to dissolve every relationship growing out of my faith. . . . But he shall be tolerated. He may live and go free; he may even vote; but for any higher, more advanced citizenship, he is, as I hold, utterly disqualified.
Let it be remembered that the atheist includes deists, Jews, and Seventh-day Baptists and all others who may not agree with those “reformers.” He may believe in God and in the Bible; he may love his neighbor as himself; he may observe every one of the Ten Commandments, but woe to him if he interferes with “my faith”! The Endeavorer would go farther still,—they “must emigrate.” But if they will not?—Why then, treat them as rebels.
We might give much more testimony, couched in still stronger terms, from these religio-political reformers, but this is sufficient. Let the true liberty-lover observe that their sentiments are not the American principles on which this government was founded. Let the Christian observe that they are not the principles of Christ. Christ came as our example, but he judged no man. He says even of those who rejected him: “If any man hear my words, and believe not, I judge him not; for I came not to judge the world, but to save the world.” John 12:47. The principles set forth by these “reformers” are contrary to the Golden Rule: “Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them; for this is the law and the prophets.” Matt. 7:12. This is the teaching of Christ, of the law and the prophets; yet these teachers of “Christian citizenship,” who profess to speak “by all that is just in God,” are setting forth principles for the government of this land that are diametrically opposed to the teaching of Christ.
The government of nation, state, and city, is bad enough, God knows; but it will never be helped by the Christian Endeavor and National Reform methods. Such principles as set forth by the Endeavorer, will, when embodied into statutory government, breed discord, mar the peace of good men and women, manufacture hypocrites from material ready at hand, fill whited sepulchers with the corruption of a dead faith, persecute the “whitest of the saints of God,” and involve the government and those committed to the movement in irretrievable ruin. The men behind this movement do not believe this, but its truthfulness is written in the history of the past as well as in the Scriptures of truth. Blessed is he who gives heed to the warnings.
M. C. W.