AdventAI

Death Penalty Demanded

By T. H. Starbuck

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 29., July 25, 1895

THE INTERRELATION OF THE LAW AND THE GOSPEL. NO. 5.

BY T. H. STARBUCK.

Death Penalty Demanded.

PROPOSITION V.—The holiness of God, the stability of his moral government, and the highest good of all his creatures, demand the death penalty for transgression.

God is declared to be holy. “Be ye holy for I am holy.” He is holy because his ways are right in all things. He is beneficent and merciful because he is holy. All things were created for his pleasure. Rev. 4:11. He takes pleasure in bestowing felicity upon his creatures. His purpose is that all his creatures shall be holy like himself; and he has ordained that if they develop holiness of character they shall enjoy pleasures forevermore at his right hand. Ps. 16:11. But to secure permanent felicity, holiness must be maintained throughout his dominions. Sin mars everything with which it comes in contact, and is at variance with the pleasures and felicities of heaven. It is an intruder, for while it wholly depends upon the beneficence of God for its existence and resources, it exerts all its force against the right ways of the Supreme Ruler. No good can possibly be obtained by sin. There can be no possible excuse for its existence. But sin is a possibility wherever intelligent beings exist. God can not bestow the gift of intelligence upon his creatures without making sin a possibility. A rational being without power to sin is not in the nature of things. Loyalty to God is an essential feature of his plan of moral government; for upon it depend the joys of heaven.

But loyalty is a voluntary act of love and obedience on the part of the creature. The fact that it is a voluntary act shows that disloyalty is within the range of possibilities. It is the glory of God’s moral government that his creatures are loyal to him when they have the power to be otherwise. The endowment of reason necessarily carries with it the possibility of evil as truly as the existence of fire makes incendiarism a possibility. The happiness of the created, and the glory of the Creator could be attained only by the endowment of reason; but such a state of things could not exist without the possibility of sin. In the moral government of God, such an emergency would have to be provided for, or else his government would be endangered if sin should ever originate. Withp. 5 the possibility of evil to provide against, the most expedient course would be to make the penalty for transgression of such a nature that it would exterminate sin by the death of the sinner, if he persisted in his sinful course. Accordingly, He whose kingdom “ruleth over all” has seen fit to limit sin by the sentence of death, in order to preserve the holiness and integrity of his moral government.

Stability.

Stability must characterize a government to secure the most satisfactory results. A throne is not stable without a perfect system of laws. That the stability of God’s moral government might be secured, it was necessary to establish in its system of laws, principles which would secure the victory over sin in case of such an emergency. The death penalty is the only principle which could effectually secure such results. But even that could not secure it in harmony with the holiness of God’s character, unless the execution of the sentence were secured in such a manner that it would give the transgressor opportunity to see the error of his ways and turn from sin. An instantaneous execution of the sentence of death would be arbitrary, and allow no possibility of an offer of salvation. Divine wisdom has made the infliction of death for sin progressive instead of instantaneous. Death comes to the transgressor by a process. “Then when lust hath conceived it bringeth forth sin; and sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death.” James 1:15. By this process the final result of sin comes lawfully. This course secures the stability of his government, allows the offer of mercy to the sinner, and inevitably ends in death if the transgressor remains incorrigible.

Justice and Mercy Meet.

The divine plan of government reveals God as he is. He could pursue no other course and be consistent with his divine nature. An instantaneous execution of the sentence of death might have been just, but it would not have been merciful. Mercy as well as justice is in the divine attributes, and will modify the course pursued by divine wisdom. When sin originated, if justice alone had been consulted, universal damnation and destruction of the sinner would have been the result; but such an arbitrary course would not have secured the victory over evil. If the voice of mercy alone had been consulted, universal salvation would have followed; and such encouragement shown to transgressors would have led to the perpetuation of sin instead of getting a complete victory over it. But, in the course that God is pursuing, the demands of justice and the pleadings of mercy are both satisfied. If the sinner accepts salvation on the terms upon which it is offered, the conditions are such that there is a complete victory over sin; and if he rejects God’s mercy, there is a victory over sin in the death that comes through the penal force of the transgressed law.

God can not, consistent with the highest good of his creatures, which good depends upon the course he pursues, permit sin to be perpetuated. The existence of sin would prevent the highest degree of happiness among his creatures; for sin is the source of pain and sorrow wherever it intrudes itself. It is the cause of tears and death. If God’s creatures sin and place themselves under the dominion of evil, there is no alternative but to either forsake the sin or accept death as the inevitable result. It is an enemy to the well-being of all rational beings, for it is death to the disloyal and extreme danger to the loyal. Death is the only remedy that will effectually remove all danger to the obedient, and put an end to the sorrows and tears of the disobedient. It is the remedy of the allwise God. It is the barrier which Infinite Wisdom has erected to prevent anarchy in his moral government. His love is revealed in the death penalty for sin, for “God is love.” It is better for the offender to die than to live, if he is wedded to the ways of sin. His life is a gift from God, and if it fails to meet the great end of existence, he who gave it has the unquestioned right to recall it.

There are three primary objects in God’s moral government: (1) To exemplify and maintain the holiness of God’s character. This would be the first step in his plan; but this could not be attained if sin were perpetuated. (2) A system of immutable laws would be necessary to secure the stability of his throne. (3) Loyalty would have to be maintained to secure universal and unending felicity among all of his creatures. Death, as the wages for sin, secures all these, and is the only effectual remedy consistent with the divine government. It must be remembered that sin has many ways, and adjusts itself to any policy that promises the desired end; but righteousness has but one way. On this account, God’s power would appear to be limited, and yet his resources are exhaustless, for the right way is the infinite way. The plan by which God is dealing with sin is the way of unlimited power, because it is the way of righteousness, and we know that the victory is certain.