AdventAI

A COMPARISON.

By W. N. Glenn

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 27., July 11, 1895

BY W. N. GLENN.

Much has been said, and justly, too, about the failure of the Roman Catholic Church, after centuries of monopoly, to educate and spiritually elevate the native elements of Mexico and South America. We repeat that all that has been said on this subject has been justly said, but there is an implied and sometimes expressed comparison with the progress of the United States that is not so flattering to professed Protestantism as it appears at first glance. If we assume that the progress in this country is due to Protestant influences, a just comparison with Romanism in Mexico must be of the results upon the condition of the aborigines of the respective countries. It must be admitted that the material and substantial progress of the United States is the outgrowth of immigration from the Old World, including men of all religions and of no religion. Then we inquire as to the condition of the natives of Mexico and of the United States when the former were encountered by the Catholics and the latter by the Protestants. Practically there was no difference, all were in their native credulity—religiously, intellectually, and physically. How is it to-day? In Mexico the natives, descendants of the original stock, still occupy a place among the living—physically degraded, religiously more superstitious than ever, and their education still tending in that direction. In the United States the natives (barring a mere handful) are dead, trodden down before the greed of the white foreigner! Do Protestants insist upon claiming the credit? Wherein is their glory in the light of comparison?

Had Protestantism continued on the line on which it started in Luther’s day, had it clung to the principle of the Bible and the Bible alone for religious doctrine, had it remained true to the theory of no interference in religious matters by the state, and no control of secular affairs by the church, the Protestant pioneers in North America would have inaugurated the principles of the Golden Rule in their dealings with the Indians. Under such a policy, the advent of those professing Christianity might have been a blessing to the red man, rather than the beginning of a system that has resulted in his practical annihilation.

When the vast territory ceded to the United States by the Mexican Government at the close of the war in 1847 changed hands, it contained a teeming Indian population. Now, as Protestants are claiming the credit of the material growth and prosperity of the United States, is it not pertinent to ask them, Where are those Indians? How came they to drop out of sight so suddenly, and that, too, either in their native idolatry or in their Roman superstition? Furthermore, what of the possessions of the red man from the Atlantic to the Pacific? Is it not clear that the so-called Protestant Christianity, which is claiming so much in the development of the United States, has labored on the principle of a Jacob (supplanter) rather than in the character of an Israel (a soldier of God)?

Looking out upon the so-called Christian world from the standpoint of the word of God, whether we look for grapes in the Roman or the professed Protestant vineyard, we see little else than wild grapes. We look for the “fruit of the Spirit”—“love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, faith, meekness, temperance”—and where is it? Instead we see strife for political power, that the self-appointed interpreters and executors of the law of God (both Roman and Protestant) may enforce their dogmas and institutions upon all dissenters by means of human law.

“It is time for thee, Lord, to work; for they have made void thy law.” Ps. 119:126. “He hath showed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the Lord require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?” Micah 6:8.